Stream

Join this community to post or comment
Pinned by moderator

Jules Sherred
owner

Discussion  - 
 
Star Trek G+ Community Spam Poll

As our Star Trek community has grown to more than 30k members, it has been increasingly difficult to moderate the community and find the right balance between removing spam, reposts and microphone-hogging while keeping useful and interesting posts that spur discussions for Trekkies to participate in.

There are valuable arguments on both sides, but we have been receiving increasingly-more complaints that the microphone-hogging and reposts of just memes and images turn people off. The fact of a matter is that some kind of moderation is needed (i.e., non-Star Trek-related or NSFW posts do get removed without question). Here is a screenshot of what happens when we don’t moderate at all: http://imgur.com/a/Ymh4r (and that was when this community was only half the current size). It really only takes a few people to spam the community with posts that do prevent other people’s posts from being seen.

We are asking for your vote on how our guidelines should be adapted. The choices are:

Keep as is - Keep our current guideline as is (don’t post more than 3 posts within a short period of time)
Restrict guideline a bit - Increase our guidelines (i.e, only 1 post per user per day, so you have to make your post count!)
Remove posts without original content - Remove posts that don’t have any original content or spur discussion (memes, screencaps)

Please respond to this poll by September 22nd. Only poll responses will be taken into consideration for the final decision. You are free to add additional comments below, but whatever has the most votes will be the new guideline. For reference, the current community guidelines are here: https://plus.google.com/+JulesSherred/posts/c9mfPPm4fqy
279 votes  -  votes visible to Public
Keep as is
53%
Restrict guideline a bit
28%
Remove posts without original content
19%
15
1
Phil Miller's profile photoJo Jones's profile photo
48 comments
 
I like memes, polls, etc. --- variety. Your following is big. You should keep things the way they are. It's not broken, so don't try to fix it. 
Add a comment...

lino pang

Discussion  - 
 
sorry, you can't watch this :-(
2
1
30_Helens Agree's profile photoEthan Wang's profile photo
2 comments
 
They're not going through with Axanar?
Add a comment...

Luis Angel Rosario

Around the web  - 
 
RENEGADES

:-)


Starfleet Medical 
11
Craig “Tezrak” Hatler's profile photo
 
I tried watching the Renegades "first episode". Meh.
Add a comment...

Gloria Bunch

Star Trek: TNG  - 
35
Kyllein MacKellerann's profile photoFranke Hernandez's profile photo
3 comments
 
+Kyllein MacKellerann he said and I quote

" I'll just be standing over here dozing off "

End quote.

He's in an official Duty capacity AKA derelict of Duty!

BTW I get the meaning of this clip.
Add a comment...

Snare X

Star Trek: TNG  - 
 
I don't know guys/gals. The whole bajoran thing.
If you remember the 90s
24
Anthony Lasalle's profile photoO'Shea James's profile photo
10 comments
 
I like complex conflicted characters like Ro.
Add a comment...

Chris Halladay

Discussion  - 
 
I have a question. Is there a chat/dating app that is for fans of Star Trek? If so, what is this app called? I tried looking on Google Play and found nothing.
1
Add a comment...

Darryl Neal

Star Trek: ENT  - 
 
And this is what I get for telling him about the red shirt!!🙅🙅🙅🙅
40
Louis Doggett's profile photocrazygirlfun1's profile photo
3 comments
 
Lol
Add a comment...
 
3
Add a comment...
 
Has this ever happened to you?
 
When you finally get into Star Trek, then realize that between you and all you´re nerd friends you´re the only one who likes Star Trek

seriously, have the nerdiest friends in the universe and i´m the only nerd out of all of them to be a big fan of Star Trek?
1
Add a comment...
 
Spoiler Free,
 
Star Trek Beyond Review


King of Geeks, Lord of Dorks, but above all else just a guy trying to give YOU my personal late review for the 3rd installment of the Kelvin Timeline Star Trek Franchise.

Now many of you on this community may know as of last year, I have become a huge Star Trek fan. Star Trek: The Next Generation being my championed series. I think personally it was the spirit of grand endure and social commentary the series always brought up in a most splendid fashion that always kept me coming back. Although, that said, those core concepts seemed to have been lacking in the last 2 Star Treks. Star Trek 2009 was a good start, but Into Darkness despite being enjoyable fell flat in the areas that made the franchise so good. Exploration of the stars and its many characters. Alas Star Trek Beyond is here to remedy the problems of its last 2 predecessors and more by being a fun space action thriller, unique in its own right.


Plot

3 years into the 5 year mission across the stars(get it, because this is the third movie...so clever), after another tiring diplomatic mission gone ary, kirk finds himself questioning the point of being a Star Fleet captain other than to surpass his dad. If all the Federation is meant to do is explore the endless boundaries of space, whats the point of striving for a goal that can never end. All of the depression is leaning Kirk towards wanting to leave the captains chair to Spock and become an Admiral instead(that's an easter egg btw).
However, when a remnant refugee of a destroyed federation star ship in a nearby uncharted nebula near the new star base York Town, desperately requests an immediate rescue party, Kirk´s plans of retirement seem to be constantly put on hold as the Enterprise´s attempts of a rescue mission are turned into a struggle to survive by a mysterious alien army led by a ruthless vigilante known as Krall.


Thoughts

Amazing from start to finish, as a Star Trek fan it completely blew my mind of how perfect of a movie this was. Sure they had the cliche' of the enterprise must be destroyed or near destroyed, in which when i say this ship got destroyed i mean:¨Holy Shit that thing go destroyed¨. No seriously, the Enterprise is more obliterated than Fox´s chances of reviving the Fantastic Four by the time its all said and done(yeah...that bad). A lot of characters get developed but more of their relationships with one another rather than actual development but i´d be lying if i say they weren´t all charming. All of the characters bounced off of each other as if they were actual people, as if it was actually like an episode of the original tv show.

Speaking of which to honor Leonard Nemoy´s death they killed him off in the background by doing something i feel Future Original Spock would never do for the very way it almost affected Kelvin Spock in this movie, but he´s dead got to honor the man and by the end of the movie it creates this really touching meta moment between the original series and the new movies that i quite enjoyed as a treky myself just getting into the Original Series.


Spock and Bones completely stole the show in all their scenes and the actor for Bones still can nail the part and may just be the funniest part of this movie. Him and Spock have this kind of rivalry because of their two clashing philosophies, very much like the show. Spock has the vulcan sense of logic while Bones can´t quite understand why there would be any race so devoted to logic over humanity, often times making him feel as if Spock is as cold as a machine. I think the movie does a really good job of progressing their relationship further and arguably bonding them closer as friends who bust each others balls constantly.

Chris Pine is definitely getting better as Captain Kirk, and his character development as the movie goes on shows it without telling you. By the end of the movie if you pay attention to his attitude slowly becoming more caring and more invigorated by being on the edge of his seat once more, added by Krall´s constant challenging of Kirk´s generation and what it stands for, really elevates the character from being one note:¨I´m doing this for my dad¨ to ¨No..i actually want to do this¨ .

Krall is also a favorite of mine and as the movie goes on and the twist is revealed, you kind of feel he´s more as this soldier who can´t quite come into grips with the times, he´s stuck in the past and believes that the Federation´s a bunch of sissy´s for blindly wanting to make peace in times of what should be war. Had they fleshed him out a tad bit more i think the movie would´ve been stronger for it. As far as the other new character Jaylah, her motivation is probably the weakest part of the movie, but thats a good thing. Because shes actually pretty fun to be around and her motivation is just kind of there..but the way the character is portrayed gratifies her role to where i would be happy to see more of her in future movies.


The Bad

Prior to the movie they made this whole big deal about Sulu being gay, honestly had no one told me he was gay in this timeline i still would never have known. Seriously? Star Trek is the series that created so much controversy for the first televised interracial kiss i kind of was hoping they´d up the ante since they made such a big deal about it. Also, the plot device Krall is looking for just so happens to be in Kirk´s possession because of something completely unrelated to the plot of the movie. I assume it probably has to do with the ongoing comic series but still. Prime Timeline Spock becomes Ambassador of New Vulcan despite being against the Prime Directive of Starfleet to interfere with primitive societies(in which to him this would be one of them) plus he told Kirk and Spock at least once in each movie prior that he would NOT interfere with their predestined lives..although after saying that he did interfere so i mean... I´ll cut him a break because the man did die and it was just made to honor him, but him being an ambassador and dying almost screwed up Kelvin Spock´s pre-determined choices in life to prove my point on why that annoys me. Um....Kirk learns of someones betrayal but despite being constantly asked how he specifically knew who and when the traitor would strike he pulls out a batman and says something along the lines of:¨BECAUSE IM BATMAN¨ (not really but it felt like he said that).
The Fear vs Unity thing is kind of reflective of modern day terrorism, kind of, but it wasn't as fleshed out as it could've been.

And the VERY last scene felt a little forced because they didnt flesh out enough of the plot point that would´ve made it that much more significant.

Favorite Scene

When the crew uses the Beastie Boys to defeat Krall´s army, It´s absolutely creative and amazing.


Conclusion

This is the Star Trek movie that i firmly believe rivals Wrath of Khan if not surpasses it. It nails EVERY character to perfection and it felt like the show. I was enjoying it from start to finish with nothing but a smile on my face. The action scenes where the crew is facing impossible odds forces them to be very creative and tactful and shows off how clever each member of the ship is, the music is on point, and the ending of Spock´s storyline is perfectly done especially for a fan of Star Trek the Original Series. The tones of Fear Vs Unity, leaving the past behind, being just a fun movie..i even dare say i had more fun with this than Civil War even though i like that movie more.
As a Star Trek fan i give it a well deserved 9/10
Average Movie Goer: 7.5/10

Thanks for reading or skimming. if you´ve seen the movie what did you think about it? King of Geeks Lord of Dorks, signing out with one last message:
WATCH. THIS. MOVIE.
1
Add a comment...

About this community

Discuss and share your thoughts on Star Trek. Please read the community guidelines before posting: https://plus.google.com/100576497665628716472/posts/c9mfPPm4fqy You can discuss Star Trek Beyond with spoilers only on this post: https://plus.google.com/+MinhTNguyen/posts/NxMoasjD8MZ All other posts and comments must be spoiler free. Please report any spoilers to the moderators listed in the community guidelines.

Luis Angel Rosario

Pictures and video  - 
 
Star Trek V
CBS Paramount

:-)


Starfleet Medical



10
Luis Angel Rosario's profile photoLaura Ess's profile photo
3 comments
 
No! We must all own our pain! Now where's my fellow warriors with those pain sticks?!
Add a comment...

Phil Miller

The Movies  - 
 
Star Trek III #behindthescenes  
22
David Lee Tibble's profile photo
 
Movie Klingons looked better than Next Gen klingons
Add a comment...

Luis Angel Rosario

Pictures and video  - 
 
Coffee Time!!!

:-)


Starfleet Medical 
45
4
Add a comment...

H.U. Graedener

DIY Costumes, Props, Sets, Tips and Tricks, etc  - 
 
For your next con
You can boldly have a look that honors Uhura, Troi, Vina, or Seven of Nine.
9
Add a comment...

Leandro Lima

Star Trek: TNG  - 
 
Freakin' beautiful!
16
Christian Hansard's profile photoManuel Campos's profile photo
3 comments
 
Now THAT'S how it's done! 
Add a comment...

Darryl Neal

Star Trek: ENT  - 
 
My brother is in the red, he never would put on anything Star Trek, but he did on the 50th!!🙌
69
Add a comment...
4 comments

Darryl Neal

Star Trek: TOS  - 
 
Gifts on my 50th BIRTHDAY and a glass or Romulan Ale.🙌🙌
27
Louis Doggett's profile photoDarryl Neal's profile photo
2 comments
 
+Louis Doggett my wife said that we should have it.😱
Add a comment...

Luis Angel Rosario

Star Trek: TOS  - 
 
Janice Rand

:-)


Starfleet Medical 
49
4
Anthony Lasalle's profile photoFred Einsel's profile photo
2 comments
 
Grace Lee Whitney
Add a comment...
 
Come on its got the K and everything
 
waisted meme opportunity

ok so you guys know how they used Khan in:¨Into Darkness" and Spock says:¨KHAAAAN!¨ instead of Kirk, right?

Well, had they not waisted Khan and made Krall his equivalent in this universe,
wouldn´t the reference have been much more satisfying if when the Enterprise is destroyed and Kirk gets out the escape pod he shouts:
6
Ethan Wang's profile photo
 
HAHA!
This is hilarious! This was awesome...
Add a comment...

Sally Collard

Star Trek: TOS  - 
 
Hi TOS fans. Wrote this to commemorate the 50th anniversary. This is an attempt to write in the style of the original and it has its roots in a classic episode . Set in the last few months of the first five year mission. Feedback very welcome. http://archiveofourown.org/works/1119572
An Archive of Our Own, a project of the Organization for Transformative Works
4
Add a comment...