Gotham Bar & Grill's profile photo
Gotham Bar & Grill
American Restaurant$$$$
Today 5:30 – 11:00 pm
Contact Information
12 E 12th St New York, NY 10003
12 East 12th StreetUSNew YorkNew York10003
$$$$American Restaurant, Bar & GrillToday 5:30 – 11:00 pm
Monday 12:00 – 2:15 pm, 5:30 – 10:00 pmTuesday 12:00 – 2:15 pm, 5:30 – 10:00 pmWednesday 12:00 – 2:15 pm, 5:30 – 10:00 pmThursday 12:00 – 2:15 pm, 5:30 – 10:00 pmFriday 5:30 – 11:00 pmSaturday 5:00 – 11:00 pmSunday 5:00 – 10:00 pm
Google+ URL

See inside

Your Activity

Is this your business?

Manage this page
Write a review
Review Summary
355 reviews
5 star
217 reviews
4 star
115 reviews
3 star
18 reviews
2 star
2 reviews
1 star
3 reviews
A West Village fixture still serving standout New American plates in a stylish yet relaxed setting.- Google
"We also had the striped bass ceviche, Berkshire pork chop and the white cod."
"The Gotham chocolate cake was to die for, just as most people will attest to."
Featured by Zagat
, and 9 other lists
See more from Zagat
Scrapbook photo 2
Scrapbook photo 3
Scrapbook photo 4
Scrapbook photo 5
Upload public photo
Visit this place
Make a free reservation with OpenTable
Find a table
All reviews
Avery Ma's profile photo
Avery Ma
a month ago
Probably the single greatest eating experience we have had here in NYC. Ambiance and dress - Dining is at a comfortable level which borders on romantic and 'dinner with friends'. Dress is smart casual tending to the more formal given the attire of everyone else. Service and greeting - we had to wait for a table to open past our reservation time, they provided our drinks complimentary. Did a mix and match three course - 1) shrimp cocktail and the oysters ( Washington and cape cod) which were excellent. 2) mushroom risotto - a perfectly cooked risotto filled with wild mushrooms. A rich Parmesan cheese flavor backed by white wine. My wife and i split this and it was delicious. 3) Steak ( her) and Duck (me) - both solid flavors and presentation but the duck stole the show. Rich and tender, the duck was a bite-for-bite lesson in savory decadence 4) Chocolate cake - Cake was great but the salted (Carmel?) Ice cream was the perfect compliment and most remarkable element This place should not disappoint you.
• • •
Garner Marshall's profile photo
Garner Marshall
2 weeks ago
That chocolate cake is the truth. I love the place. I've been a few times and have always had a positive experience. Great place for groups to go.
Anya Rasulova's profile photo
Anya Rasulova
8 months ago
I wanted to continue our romance, but this may be my break-up note to you, Gotham. I've eaten there several times and have always been a big fan of their tasting menu (which they currently do not offer). Food was relatively bland, my duck was so chewy that I could not cut it up with a steak knife. Service was so unbelievable inattentive that I had to flag down people with water to bring me menu, or explain items on the menu (yes, that bad!) - definitely not what one would expect from Gotham. Would not be going back - enough great restaurants in NYC to chose from
• • •
Federico Torre's profile photo
Federico Torre
a year ago
Dining here is worth a 20 minute subway ride. I have to immediately point out that I fell in love with their burger. So much so that I ordered one to go and it was able to convince me from awarding them only two stars. Why only two? Well we made the mistake of going here during Restaurant Week. We had made reservations well in advance, but somehow that didn't matter as we still had to wait an additional half hour before being seated. Once seated the service was fair, the food was great, and the prices very reasonable, and of course they have a great selection of wine. I know the hiccups were due to Restaurant Week, but I still expect an establishment to know how to properly manage an event they willingly participate in. Regardless, definitely worth another go.
• • •
Bin Fang
2 months ago
On the first glance, the menu does not seem to offer you a unique new food experience, but the dishes are so well prepared and fresh that you can experience traditional dishes in a new way. The ambiance is great and the service is impeccable. Before we started with the food, we had the prosecco and a cocktail called "royal". The prosecco was very good and brut. I also very much liked the royal, but it has a very strong thai basilicum tasted almost medicine like. Either you love it or you hate it. I've had maya shrimps for the first time in my life and they were by far the best shrimps I've ever eaten. Yet, they were served head-off (I heard some people like to take the head off and suck it). My wife had the seafood salad which was also very good but I'd prefer the shrimps. I continued with the gazpacho which had an orange color instead of the traditional dark red but the tomtoes they used were particularly tasteful and fruity. Our main courses were the duck and the cod - both dishes among the best duck and cod we've ever eaten. The cherry clafoutis were the perfect finish of our meal. As we did not want to go for a full bottle of wine, we asked for recommendations by the glass. I had the Barbera and my wife the white Burgundy wine. Both wines worked very well with the entrees! The chef recommends ordering three courses. I can eat a lot and my two appezizers (shrimps and gazpaccio) were not very filling compared to other appetizers on the menu. However, the entrees were very large and two courses plus sharing a dessert would have been enough food.
• • •
Adam Van Grover's profile photo
Adam Van Grover
4 months ago
Crisp, seasonal menu - new American cuisine served in an exceptionally clean layout by a fully qualified service staff. The decor and ambiance are carefully curated with clean sweeping lines and pristine attention to detail. Fully attentive wait staff complement this. The food is delicious, pricey and worth it.
Ayele Ajavon's profile photo
Ayele Ajavon
5 months ago
Just had the most amazing meal at Gotham Grill tonight and just saw on night line that it was the premier restaurant where Singapore Airlines got its meals for their multi thousand dollar 'suite' class.... All I know is that it must been worth every penny. Service was phenomenal, food was out of this world and ambiance was impeccable. Yummy!
Jenn Fung's profile photo
Jenn Fung
8 months ago
I came here for the most recent restaurant week, and enjoyed every bit of my meal. My appetizer was sashimi; it was so fresh and the sauce really complemented it. The fish came a bit under-cooked at first, but they were able to re-cook it to perfection. The Gotham chocolate cake was to die for, just as most people will attest to. Usually, restaurant week menus are mediocre at best and chefs pay no mind to the quality presented, but at Gotham, the standard was held just as highly.
• • •