Colony Diner Inc
Contact Information
2019 Hempstead Bethpage Turnpike East Meadow, NY 11554
2019 Hempstead Bethpage TurnpikeUSNew YorkEast Meadow11554
(516) 794-5159
$$Restaurant, American Restaurant
American Restaurant
Google+ URL

Street View

Your Activity

Is this your business?

Manage this page
Write a review
Review Summary
21 reviews
5 star
9 reviews
4 star
7 reviews
3 star
1 review
2 star
3 reviews
1 star
1 review
"It was pretty late, so I ordered the matzo ball soup and a tuna sandwich."
"Let me start by saying the waitstaff is incredible as always."
"Really great Pancakes and French Fries!"
Upload first public photo
All reviews
Audrey Rubinstein
2 months ago
I went there a couple of weeks ago with my son, sister and brother in law. The waitstaff is awesome!! Courteous and friendly. It was pretty late, so I ordered the matzo ball soup and a tuna sandwich. I couldn't believe the size of the soup! It literally is a meal in itself....and it tasted wonderful. When my sandwich came, I had to have them pack it up for me because I didn't have room left to eat another bite. My family loved their food. Unfortunately, I live in PA. and I don't visit there often, but when I do I will make it my business to go back again.
• • •
Ryanna Schleifstein's profile photo
Ryanna Schleifstein
4 months ago
Really great Pancakes and French Fries!!! The only reason I don't go there more often is that there is no free wi-fi (according to an internet search). I don't remember if I saw any signs to say otherwise, but the next time I go, I will find out and will definitely come more often if there is in fact free wi-fi!
Marc H
12 months ago
Service is very good here, and the menu choices are good, as well as delicious. The mashed potatoes here are the real deal and should not be missed. You'll taste the butter in the mixed vegetables or string beans - one of the few diners you'll find with truly great side dishes as well as main dishes. Terrific seafood dishes, like shrimp scampi that tastes like shrimp and isn't rubbery, sole that is wonderful, scallops that are delicious. I hesitate to rate a diner as a 5 because I reserve that for high-end food, but if I were ranking only diners, they would definitely score a 5.
• • •
Frank Viquez's profile photo
Frank Viquez
a year ago
Not what it used to be.......Have been going here for over 10 years and it has always been one of my favorite diners. However, since the latest renovation a couple of years ago, it simply isn't the same anymore. Let me start by saying the waitstaff is incredible as always. However, that is the only great thing left about this diner. The latest renovation has created an atmosphere of a high-end ultra-lounge. Don't know why they did that since they are a diner and not a restaurant. The prior art deco theme was fine and suitable for a diner. The prices seemed to have jumped up since the renovation as well and the portions have shrunk (do they actually think they are a restaurant?). The quality of the food has also declined: adequate at best. Have tried to give them the benefit of the doubt many times since the renovation, but cannot do that anymore. Sorry to say I will not be returning to the Colony.
• • •
David Cohen's profile photo
David Cohen
a month ago
They have the best Chicken Cutlet BLT!! The red skin potato salad is incredible!! Top notch diner, consistantly good :)
Frankie Rodriguez's profile photo
Frankie Rodriguez
a month ago
Very nice place to eat. Great service and atmosphere. Highly recommended !!
Jack W
5 months ago
Excellent food,service and atmosphere.
sudeep kaur
a year ago
A terrible experience not particularly for the food which was average but for the treatment meted by the staff including the manger. We were completely ignored from the time we entered the diner by the staff until on our way out. We are stared at and not greeted unlike other customers which I am presuming was due to our appearance being a proud Sikh family from India. The manager shamelessly looked at us and turned himself away while he continued to greet other customers. Never again and will extend my feigns about the diner to others.
• • •