Lucali's profile photo
Pizza Restaurant$$
Contact Information
575 Henry St Brooklyn, NY 11231
575 Henry StUSNY11231
(718) 858-4086
$$Pizza Restaurant, European RestaurantMenu
Google+ URL
Your Activity

Is this your business?

Manage this page
Reviews from around the web
Write a review
Review Summary
408 reviews
5 star
154 reviews
4 star
239 reviews
3 star
63 reviews
2 star
10 reviews
1 star
2 reviews
Popular neighborhood eatery serves thin-crust pizza & guests bring their own wine & beer; cash only.- Google
People talk about byob, carroll gardens, brick oven, pizza and calzones and long wait
Featured by Zagat
, and one other list
See more from Zagat
Scrapbook photo 2
Scrapbook photo 3
Scrapbook photo 4
Scrapbook photo 5
Scrapbook photo 6
Upload public photo
All reviews
Robert R. Murphy's profile photo
Robert R. Murphy
reviewed a month ago
One of the best pizza in Newark. The line is pretty long, but you can always enjoy a beer or a glass of wine and while waiting outside. The atmosphere on a nice sunny sunset is priceless.
Christoph Zachhuber's profile photo
Christoph Zachhuber
reviewed 4 months ago
The best pizza I ever had outside of Italy. They only make pizza at this place, which is good because its perfect. European style pizza like it should be. The alleged ties to the Mob make this place even more interesting and authentic.
Michael Foley's profile photo
Michael Foley
reviewed a year ago
THE BEST PIZZA IN NYC. That says it all. There are 2 things on the menu. Pizza and calzone. My recommendation...get both. A pizza will feed 2 people. The crust is thin and the pizza is so good you will eat a least 1 slice more then usual. The decore and location are about as old school Italian as you can get, and I've never been there when the owner isn't there making sure everything is perfect and chatting with regulars. The front of house staff are very nice, which is important when the wait averages 1.5 hours. They take your number so you can go to the bar while you're waiting. The pizza is a bit expensive, but it's BYO so it makes up for it. And if you didn't order enough the first time, the desert calzone if phenomenal as well.
• • •
Romina Wixom's profile photo
Romina Wixom
reviewed in the last week
Aside for the wait, the pizza was fantastic. Simple and true to its ingredients, flavorful, and included massive bunches of basil on every pie. The staff were friendly and "real" as my high-school students would say.
Tim Sin
reviewed 9 months ago
Despite of the high rating, it did disappoint me somehow when I got there for a second time. (The first time I went there was on new year's eve and they were closed) I waited until 6 PM for dinner. It is a small but neat restaurant. Too many people were trying to fit into that small area, which makes it noisy. The pizza was huge, which was enough for three people, but the pie was too soft that we couldn't even hold it in our hands. You gotta pay for each topping you add, which is another downside. In general, it's something you can expect in the city. Nothing fancy in it.
• • •
Megan F's profile photo
Megan F
reviewed 7 months ago
Pizza is fresh from the oven and served in a casual “feels-like-your-grandma’s-kitchen” space. Never eaten a whole large pie between 2 people before, it was that good!