Profile

Sam's New York Pizza
Pizza Restaurant$$
Today 11:00 am – 9:00 pm
AboutPhotos
Contact Information
4351A Gunn Hwy Tampa, FL 33618
4351A Gunn HighwayUSFloridaTampa33618
(813) 969-4444
$$Pizza Restaurant, Italian RestaurantToday 11:00 am – 9:00 pm
Monday 11:00 am – 9:00 pmTuesday 11:00 am – 9:00 pmWednesday 11:00 am – 9:00 pmThursday 11:00 am – 9:00 pmFriday 11:00 am – 10:30 pmSaturday 11:00 am – 10:30 pmSunday 11:00 am – 9:00 pm
Menu
Google+ URL

See inside

Panorama
Panorama
Your Activity

Is this your business?

Manage this page
Write a review
Review Summary
4.0
21 reviews
5 star
13 reviews
4 star
2 reviews
3 star
1 review
2 star
2 reviews
1 star
3 reviews
"The best PIZZA, Calzone and garlic knots in town!"
"This place is a great place to get world class Pizza pie."
"I love Sam's New York Pizza."
2 reviewers
Photos
Upload first public photo
All reviews
Alfred Hall
2 months ago
Initially Sam's Pizza was the best around but the last three pizzas I ordered which was in the last three months were horrible. I let the first two go by as a quirk, something was off those days, no worries, Sam's Pizza is going to be great next time, I just know it. Well. last night I ordered an "everything pizza". The cook took an old pepperoni pie and added ten thin, very thin slices of sausage and covered his bad deeds with thick slices of green peppers and gigantic uncooked slices of raw onion. There was no ham, no meatballs, no other meats except pepperoni and a tiny bit of sausage. The sauce was dry, the mozzarella was sparse, it was horrible and I got the pleasure of paying him $20.00 for the pie! If you're looking for good pizza avoid this place- keep looking.
• • •
Brittany Luna
4 months ago
I've been calling for over half an hour in the middle of a weekday, and no one is answering the phone. This is REALLY unfortunate because Sam's has been my 2nd favorite pizza provider since I moved to Tampa last year, and because of their quick service compared to my favorite, I order from Sam's 95% of the time I want pizza. If this isn't remedied, I will not give them my business nor recommend this restaurant anymore.
Renaie Brown
a year ago
I love Sam's New York Pizza. I first tried it 6 months ago when I moved to Tampa. It's the only pizza I eat now. When my kids came to visit me, they tried it as well and loved it. They still send me texts saying how they could go for some Sams pizza right about now (They go to school in NC). I took my boys to Sams to try the pizza challenge, which they lost, but we all had a great time and lots of laughs. Thanks so much for the delicious pizza Sam!
Gary Sweigart
a year ago
If I could rate them higher than a 5 I would. This place is a great place to get world class Pizza pie. The dough is just perfect, the sauce is tremendous and just the right amount and the toppings are always fresh and put on generously. It's by far and away some of the best pizza I have ever encountered. The staff is great, eat in, carry out or get delivery, they are just great people who do a tremndous job. I run a large dealership and order from them often, and have never ever had a complaint from anyone..... We absolutley love it....... ps........ U are a pizza Guru if you can tackle the GOLIATH PIE..... Keep up the great work and see you soon !!!!!!
• • •
Renee Hyer's profile photo
Renee Hyer
4 months ago
i usta eat your pizza all the time but ive been very disappointed in how your employees handle a complaint...i called your pizza place at 930pm on thursday jan 8 and the guy that answerws the phone says sams pizza were closed...well your website says you close at 1030pm ..but when i called on friday to ask what your hours were you stated you closed at 10pm...and i asked do you not deliver before closing at 10 and her answer was yes we do ...then why answer your closed..very disappointed
• • •
Alexei Sorokin
4 months ago
Decent food. Absolutely horrible customer service. Just bad. And the place is dirty.
Kathy Dorobkowski
3 months ago
The best PIZZA, Calzone and garlic knots in town!
Meagan Vieren's profile photo
Meagan Vieren
a year ago
Ordered take out from here three times and always great pizza. Tried delivery this time and pizza was still delicious but crummy delivery service....driver was 20 minutes late, food was cold, the sauce for the garlic knots was missing and the potato salad wasn't on the Greek salad.