Profile

Cover photo
Alan Ly
Worked at Nuance Communications
Attends Concordia University
Lives in Laval
76 followers|19,684 views
AboutPostsPhotosYouTube

Stream

In his circles
41 people
Have him in circles
76 people
Lee Kelly's profile photo
Oleksandr Dymov's profile photo
danu tz's profile photo

Alan Ly

Shared publicly  - 
 
 
Editorial: is Engadget really that stupid? Or just corrupt? Or trolling us all?

Here is another "race to the bottom is bad" article, this time in the form of an "editorial" from Engadget. It's even more idiotic than usual.

The whole "race to the bottom" concept is odd to me: people complaining about how technology gets less outrageously expensive, and more available to everybody, and more commoditized.  Like that would be a bad thing? So the whole argument is fundamentally flawed to begin with - any time I see some pundit or CEO complaining about how the competition is making things cheaper, I go "Uhhuh, crybaby".

But when it comes to cellphones, it's not just a flawed argument, it's doubly stupid. Because in that market, particularly in the US, the alternative is the whole broken carrier subsidy model, with all that entails. None of which is good, and all of which is much worse than any (hypothetical) "race to the bottom" arguments.

And at no point did that deeply flawed editorial even mention carrier lock-in issues. What crock.

I have many reasons to like the google nexus phones: I just think that the plain android experience is generally cleaner than most of the skinned ones, and even when there is superior hardware (Samsung Galaxy SIII) I tend to prefer the Nexus model (honesty in advertizing: I've gotten free phones from both google and Samsung, but I actually bought my own Nexus One and Galaxy Nexus on google play store. And I installed CyanogenMod on the SIII Samsung gave me, because I wanted the JellyBean experience).

So I like the Nexus phones just because I think they have a nicer interface.

But I like the Nexus phones even more because they are clearly pushing the whole "no carrier lock-in" model. And price is absolutely part of it. 
1
Add a comment...
People
In his circles
41 people
Have him in circles
76 people
Lee Kelly's profile photo
Oleksandr Dymov's profile photo
danu tz's profile photo
Work
Occupation
Full-Time Student
Employment
  • Nuance Communications
    Quality Assurance Intern, 2011 - 2011
Places
Map of the places this user has livedMap of the places this user has livedMap of the places this user has lived
Currently
Laval
Story
Introduction
I'm a full-time software engineering student at Concordia University with an interest in computing, electronics, technology, music and automobiles.
Education
  • Concordia University
    Software Engineering, 2011 - present
  • Dawson College
    Computer Science Technology, 2008 - 2011
Basic Information
Gender
Male