Cover photo
Verified local business
The Original Bizzarro Famous New York Pizza
Pizza Restaurant$$
Today 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Contact Information
Map of the business location
4 Wave Crest Ave Indialantic, FL 32903
4 Wave Crest AvenueUSFloridaIndialantic32903
$$Pizza RestaurantToday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Monday 11:00 am – 10:00 pmTuesday 11:00 am – 10:00 pmWednesday 11:00 am – 10:00 pmThursday 11:00 am – 10:00 pmFriday 11:00 am – 10:00 pmSaturday 11:00 am – 10:00 pmSunday 12:00 – 10:00 pm
As one of the leading providers of insurance services in North Florida, we represent many large companies whose names you will recognize.
Google+ URL
Your Activity
Write a review
Review Summary
58 reviews
5 star
29 reviews
4 star
11 reviews
3 star
7 reviews
2 star
3 reviews
1 star
8 reviews
Unassuming eatery featuring straight-up Italian dishes & pizzas, plus outdoor seating.- Google
"Good New York pizza near the beach."
"Definitely wasn't "New York style."
3 reviewers
Scrapbook photo 2
Scrapbook photo 3
Upload public photo
All reviews
Brian Harvey
2 months ago
Cash only is annoying, wish they would tell you when you call in the order. They have ATM so they can gouge you. They were really rude too. Pizza was ok but Petrillos down the road is just as good, cleaner, and much friendlier staff.
Bonnie Doty's profile photo
Bonnie Doty
a year ago
Worst pizza I ever had. It's real obvious they have their good and bad days, judging from the positive reviews. My guess is that they don't need to put forth consistent effort because they are the only pizza place at a popular Orlando-tourist destination. I live in Melbourne Beach and most of my local friends counseled me to stay away from beachside Bizarros. My husband and I went at lunchtime on a Saturday. The dough was undercooked, tough and rubbery (my teeth still hurt just thinking about it), they were stingy with the pepperoni, and the cheese wasn't smooth and fatty like normal whole milk mozzarella tastes. Definitely wasn't "New York style." And I'm from Jersey so I know pizza. Also we ordered beer at the counter with the pizza, and paid for it all, waited around at the counter for the beer but the guys back there kept on taking orders so we sat down thinking maybe they brought it to the table. We never got served the beer. Maybe 15 or 20 minutes later my husband finally went to the counter to ask for the beer we paid for. They served it up but offered no apologies or excuses, so we were unimpressed.
• • •
a year ago
to the people who finds this place acceptable and the ones who rave about authentic n.y. pizza because they are from there then i understand why new yorkers and jerseyites are so rude! it's because they hang out in low-class places like bizzaros'! i wonder what their homes look like!
Peyton Briggs's profile photo
Peyton Briggs
2 years ago
I have lived walking distance from this place all my life, but i never understood why people would eat there. The decor is horrible, you just sitting on some wood that they don't ever clean. The pizza is nothing to be proud about, it is just a really thin crust pizza with a large amount of tomato sauce on it and not to much cheese. The service is not to good, i have heard them yell at customers to many times and I have been of to the owners house because I was friends with his daughter in high school and they have the most disgusting house i have ever been in. If you want a great local place then go to Longdoggers, Big Island Burrito, or Sandbar.
• • •
Charles Sheppard
2 months ago
was their on 03/18/2015 had the 24" pizza. was very good.the guy inside with hat on back.wards that grabbed the money out of my hand and told me their are no free about a miserable person.did have one young man their that was friendly and smiled.their were 5 of us and we all liked the pizza.we were their 4 yrs. ago and it was good then.
Renee Thompson's profile photo
Renee Thompson
12 months ago
No credit or debit cards!?!?!? What kind of facility only accepts cash? Are we still in the 80's and nobody told me?
Wesley Godwin's profile photo
Wesley Godwin
a year ago
This place is awesome. They are straight to the point. Order your pizza, pay for it, they cook it and you leave. I dont know what people are talkong about them being rude. They didnt conversate much but i dont see where they would have time as busy as they were. The pizza was awesome..just like u would get in new york. The only complaint i have is that i wish they took debit cards but we made do. I will definitely be back over and over again.
David Somerville
a year ago
Cash only, no beer the day I was there, extremely rude cashier. Need I say more...


The Original Bizzarro Famous New York Pizza hasn't shared anything with you.

People are more likely to share with you if you add them to your circles.