Cover photo
Verified local business
The Plum Tomato
Italian Restaurant$$
Today 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Contact Information
Map of the business location
275 S Main St Colchester, CT 06415
275 S Main StUSCTColchester06415
$$Italian Restaurant, Pizza RestaurantToday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Monday 11:00 am – 9:00 pmTuesday 11:00 am – 10:00 pmWednesday 11:00 am – 10:00 pmThursday 11:00 am – 10:00 pmFriday 11:00 am – 10:00 pmSaturday 11:00 am – 10:00 pmSunday 11:00 am – 9:00 pm
Google+ URL
Your Activity
Reviews from around the web
Write a review
Review Summary
18 reviews
5 star
8 reviews
4 star
9 reviews
3 star
1 review
2 star
No reviews
1 star
No reviews
A big menu of pizza, pastas & sandwiches, plus kids' fare, served in an upbeat faux-rustic room.- Google
People talk about brick oven pizza, sammy the bull, sweet potato fries, wood fired and fried mozzarella wedges
Upload first public photo
All reviews
Cali Flower's profile photo
Cali Flower
reviewed 3 months ago
This place is so good. Seriously don't know how the place across the street still does so well. The food is great here and the people are so freaking nice and welcoming. Not going anywhere else for pizza or sandwiches. Evar.
Sarah Miller's profile photo
Sarah Miller
reviewed 9 months ago
delicious! My Fav pizza place in C-town. :-) Would recommend to all! I would not recommend all you can eat pasta though..... Everything else is great.
stacy manfredi
reviewed a year ago
This is only my second time at The Plum Tomato but after the service we received this time I can say it may be the last. Everything started out fine, we seated ourselves and in a timely manner the waiter came over. We ordered buffalo wings for an appetizer and a salad and a pizza for dinner. The wings came out and everything was still fine. He brought us the pizza shortly after and this was pretty much that last we saw him. He didn't give us plates for our pizza so i had to take the bones from my wings and pile them back on the plate with the wings we hadn't gotten to, and then wipe off my plate to use for the pizza. He never returned so I couldn't ask him for another drink (since i was done with my first shortly after we received the appetizer) or where my salad was. We began eating our pizza and now both of our drinks were empty but no waiter. We finished eating the pizza, and still, no waiter. So we waited. And waited. And waited some more. We ate a little on the late side so it's not like the place was busy. It was us and two other tables and I don't believe he was waiting on the other tables. We finally saw him sitting at a table with other wait staff rolling napkins. After several minutes I think he noticed that we were looking around because he finally came over. I asked him for another drink and some boxes for our leftovers. He left and never came back. So once again, the waiting game. Nothing. After several more minutes I couldn't wait any longer so I got up and asked someone else if they could give me my check and the boxes. She gave me the boxes and the check, but the check had the salad on it that I never received. The waiter saw me up there so he finally came over. He adjusted the check for the salad he never gave us and we were on our way. So, this visit was quite disappointing and I couldn't wait to get home to get a big glass of water since I was unable to get a drink there. The first time we ate here the service was fine and it was much busier, but unfortunately, the service tonight will probably always be what I remember.
• • •
Joshua B's profile photo
Joshua B
reviewed 8 months ago
Our favorite place to go for pizza! The make amazing brick-oven pizzas there, with amazing service and friendly staff. The walls are covered with old objects from the '60s (or is it '80s? I can never tell) such as grape soda ads or even a set of skis. The atmosphere lends a sense of age to the place. Beware though - the cheese on their pizzas is not for everyone! The mozzarella gave some of our friends stomach issues. Other than that, great place which I highly reccommend.
• • •
Alex Bristol's profile photo
Alex Bristol
reviewed a month ago
Great food, I come regularly with my friends and we always enjoy the meal!
A Google User
reviewed 3 years ago
My favorite pizza (The Capone) plus the best fetuccini alfredo ever!
Liked: Food, Service, Atmosphere, Value


The Plum Tomato hasn't shared anything with you.

People are more likely to share with you if you add them to your circles.