Profile

Casamento's Restaurant's profile photo
Casamento's Restaurant
Seafood Restaurant$$
AboutPhotos
Contact Information
4330 Magazine St New Orleans, LA 70115
4330 Magazine StreetUSLouisianaNew Orleans70115
$$Seafood RestaurantMenu
Google+ URL

Street View

Panorama
Your Activity

Is this your business?

Manage this page
Write a review
Review Summary
4.2
40 reviews
5 star
17 reviews
4 star
17 reviews
3 star
4 reviews
2 star
No reviews
1 star
2 reviews
Cash-only spot serving fresh oysters & other seafood in a compact, mosaic-tiled space since 1919.- Google
"Fresh oysters, the best grilled oysters, oyster loaf, crab claws, gumbo."
"We were very disappointed in the service, which was slow, rude, and off-hand."
Photos
Scrapbook photo 2
Scrapbook photo 3
Scrapbook photo 4
Upload public photo
All reviews
Glen Miller's profile photo
Glen Miller
a month ago
Great place for oysters and seafood! But visitors to town should take note: This restaurant closes for summer vacation each June thru mid-September, despite that Google shows that they are OPEN. Always do a reality check to make sure that a place is open when you think it is.
Franz Kafka's profile photo
Franz Kafka
10 months ago
After decades this is the place that makes me glad to live in New Orleans more than any other. The Gerdes are great people, Rocky and Linda are keeping Joe Casamento's place alive as a family business for generations. No hype, no commercials on TV, no gimmicks on the menu, this truly unique restaurant is an absolute pleasure. Crab claws fried in bacon grease, the best oysters in town. Period. Nothing fancy here. Mardi Gras bead wearing tourists please stay in the French Quarter, you'll like it there better. 5 stars is 5 stars too few. Casamento's is ours!
• • •
Kate Kosche's profile photo
Kate Kosche
2 years ago
We basically had oysters three ways- half shell, chargrilled and fried. All three were excellent! Also shared a gumbo which was good but not my favorite. SUPER long wait for lunch on a weekend but had an Abita Strawberry while we waited, so it was all good. Inside is very small. Service was fine once we got seated. The wait line goes right past the counter where they guys are shucking the oysters and the waitresses have to keep going back and forth, so a bit awkward there, but we just tried to stay out of their way since they were really working. I can't wait to return in September!
• • •
Kelly Packard's profile photo
Kelly Packard
5 years ago
We arrived around 8:30 on a Friday night, and they're only open until 9 p.m. so we knew there would be a long line. The line moved pretty quickly, and you can watch the famed oyster chef shuck the oysters right in front of you, and even buy a few and a beer for your wait in line. They had a few different hockey and baseball games on the TVs so the wait didn't seem too bad. We ordered a half dozen oysters on the half-shell as our appetizer, and then each had our own dinner - one fried oyster sandwich and one fried seafood platter. Both dinners were very good. Being from New England, we have both enjoyed a lot of seafood but this was my friend's first experience with raw oysters and even he liked them! I don't remember what the bill was but I do remember that we didn't spend much. The staff was very friendly. They really do lock the front door and close all the blinds at 9 p.m., but they let their customers sit and enjoy their food as long as they want. The oyster chef leaves shortly after 9 p.m., and it's polite to tip him in additional to your server if you order oysters, so be sure to catch him before he leaves. We will definitely go back.
• • •
Mike Klubok's profile photo
Mike Klubok
3 months ago
A real good hole in the wall with great food & service. Enjoyed the oysters and gumbo. This is a real good place to go in the Uptown District. You will not be disappointed.
Seth Bloom's profile photo
Seth Bloom
a year ago
This spot gets the 5 because of it's history and quality of oysters. This is a family run New Orleans institution in the heart of uptown on Magazine Street just before Napoleon Avenue. Often you have to wait in line but it's worth it. The raw oysters are great but don't neglect the loaf sandwiches. These are Texas toast style loaves of bread stuffed with either fried shrimp or fried oysters that are killer. In New Orleans they will ask you if you want them "dressed." Dressed typically means lettuce, tomato, and a bunch of mayonnaise so don't look like a rookie and let them do it up for you. Ignore the staff that can be a bit cold because the food is full of love including crab claws, gumbo and a host of other delicious items. It's a bucket list spot in New Orleans and don't forget to tip the man shucking the oysters!!
• • •
Ronald Theriot's profile photo
Ronald Theriot
2 years ago
Well, sadly, there was a bad sewage smell where we were sitting, and I'm not making this up. I noticed customers at other tables making a face. We were very disappointed in the service, which was slow, rude, and off-hand. The prices were high for what one received- for example $22.00 for a seafood platter, which did NOT come with a side salad, which I had to pay $3.50 extra for!). My platter was very tasty and not greasy, however. For my friend, his shrimp and trout plate was delicious (he said), but it was small. We couldn't wait to leave, especially due to the smell. Too bad, we were expecting it to be nice. I guess that's $76.00 down the drain. RJT
• • •
Anders Malmros's profile photo
Anders Malmros
7 months ago
Great experience, truly authentic.