Cover photo
Verified local business
Gumby's Pizza - Madison
Pizza Restaurant$$$
Today 10:00 am – 3:00 am
Contact Information
Map of the business location
This place has closed. Not true?
2825 University Ave Madison, WI 53705
2825 University AvenueUSWisconsinMadison53705
$$$Pizza Restaurant, Fast Food Restaurant
Pizza Restaurant
Fast Food Restaurant
Italian Restaurant
Today 10:00 am – 3:00 am
Monday 10:00 am – 3:00 amTuesday 10:00 am – 3:00 amWednesday 10:00 am – 3:00 amThursday 10:00 am – 3:00 amFriday 10:00 am – 4:00 amSaturday 10:00 am – 4:00 amSunday 10:00 am – 3:00 am
Order Online for Delivery or Pickup!
Google+ URL
Your Activity
Write a review
Review Summary
21 reviews
5 star
7 reviews
4 star
5 reviews
3 star
2 reviews
2 star
2 reviews
1 star
5 reviews
Informal chain offering an extensive menu of pizza, wings & Italian comfort food.- Google
"While the food itself is decent, their customer service absolutely sucks."
"Fast service, and really affordable in a college town."
Scrapbook photo 2
Scrapbook photo 3
Upload public photo
All reviews
Michael Gaines
a year ago
Itzza Pizza now open 3pm to 3am 233-3500 gives us a call we deliver Great Pizza Pasta Calzones Wings and Salads
Brian Hodgson
6 years ago
These guys can do better. I was served lukewarm chicken tenders and the fries were either old or cooked in dirty fryer oil. Honestly, the staff were good not "food service" people, and I was greeted with more of a "fast food" attitude. Hence the cold (old) food.
A Google User
3 years ago
I have a few employees who work their butts off, so every now and then I like to reward them with lunch. I am also very cheap and like to pinch every penny that I can. Now I know I got a sweet deal because I took advantage of a "Groupon " special...nonetheless, most places seem to almost scrimp on your order because they are giving you the meal at a discount. NOT this place. I no sooner called went to run a few errands and I was called back to the office as our food had already arrived, other places usually take at least an hour. The food was "HOT", they did not scrimp on the toppings and the 10 wings (honey mustard) were not only excellent; there was more meat on the bones than most other places order of 30 wings. Plump, juicy, a little crispy, drenched in sauce. They were not scrawny, cooked to a crisp, anorexic, dried up cold pieces of ?. Never had the pokey sticks before, but they were great. Go else where and you get a couple crunchy or doughy pieces of ? for just as much...these were very tasty. I will definitely order again. Thank you!!!
• • •
A Google User
3 years ago
I called to order some pokey stix. I have never ordered from them before so I wanted to know the pricing on them pokey stix that I heard so good about. I asked nicely how much there largest pokey stix were with there tuesdays deal? the man that helped me was very disrespectful the whole time while I was trying to order. he didnt answer me so I asked if he was still there. he told me the price and a really sassy tone. I then asked for the price of there 16 in and that was still a little bit to much. so i asked for the price for the 12 in? (nicely!) He then hung up on me! i was so upset so i called right back to talk to the manager. I told him what happened and all he said was so... "how can I help you?" so I started yelling at him about what kind of customer service is this when I cant even order from your place? The MANAGER then hung up on me! I cant believe this would happen at any restaurant! I am also not a crabby old person that has nothing else to do but write hate reviews. I'm 19 years old and a student here. The kind of crowd they try to attract. THE WORST CUSTOMER SERVICE... EVER!
• • •
Jeremy Mosier's profile photo
Jeremy Mosier
2 years ago
While the food itself is decent, their customer service absolutely sucks. On a delivery order, the driver did not come with change for an order that cost 20 and change...all i had was two twentys....not giving the guy 18 as a tip. I requested that he return to the store and and get change or i wouldnt take the food. Not only did he never return but i have now effectively been banned from ordering because of this. Truth is, their food is good enough when on sale but their messed up management, and the way he "holds all the power over whether i eat", yes he really said that, is ridiculous
• • •
John Thousand's profile photo
John Thousand
4 years ago
Gumby's rocks! we used to order it almost every night when I was in college.
A Google User
5 years ago
I heard that new management took over Gumby's and now it's actually good. So I tried it and was amazed. Employees were very friendly, food was great; tasted way better than the stuff from the big pizza places. Definately recommend you try this place.
A Google User
7 years ago
This is the pizza you order when you're drunk. Plain and simple. They have really great prices, decent pizza, and some very interesting specialty pizzas.


Gumby's Pizza - Madison hasn't shared anything with you.

People are more likely to share with you if you add them to your circles.