I went here a while back for brunch. I have to say I enjoyed the live music more than the food, which was solid but nothing super out of the ordinary. I did like the cozy space, which worked great with the live music.
Very very good food, at very reasonable prices.
Decor is a bit dated - as are some of the patrons it seems. ;-) But the food is professional, excellent and a great value for high end fare.
Service is beyond attentive.
I come to NYC with some regularity and I like variety, but I'll definitely make a point of returning here. Worth the trek from mid-town, or down-town to the village, even.
Small, but charming neighborhood place on Washington Square Park with excellent creative American food. Civilized, not too noisy, and reliably good. There's a bar area in the back which sometimes has music.