Lilly's Pizza's profile photo
Lilly's Pizza
Pizza Restaurant$
Today 11AM–12AM
Contact Information
810 W Peabody St Durham, NC 27701
810 West Peabody StreetUSNorth CarolinaDurham27701
$Pizza RestaurantToday 11AM–12AM
Friday 11AM–12AMSaturday 11AM–12AMSunday 11AM–10PMMonday 11AM–10PMTuesday 11AM–10PMWednesday 11AM–10PMThursday 11AM–10PM
Google+ URL

Street View

Your Activity

Is this your business?

Manage this page
Write a review
Review Summary
56 reviews
5 star
20 reviews
4 star
12 reviews
3 star
4 reviews
2 star
11 reviews
1 star
9 reviews
Cozy pizza joint & bar with artsy decor features specialty pies including vegetarian options.- Google
"Roasted vegetable salad was good."
"They also offer gluten free pizzas."
Scrapbook photo 2
Scrapbook photo 3
Scrapbook photo 4
Scrapbook photo 5
Upload public photo
All reviews
DY OH'AR's profile photo
a month ago
Surprisingly really good! We weren't impressed with the Raleigh location, so when we moved to Durham, we didn't make a point to try it out. Similar to the Raleigh location, it's by no means a meticulously clean restaurant. You look around and you find ball of dust everywhere. Despite the less than appetizing atmosphere, the pizza pie dough was crisp and flaky on the outside and chewy on the inside. Toppings are generous. And portions are on the larger side. I also liked that you could watch as the dough makers threw the dough in the air, making beautiful base layers of perfect pie. We will definitely come here again and prefer it over Mellow Mushroom for casual pizza. The value is better and it's local.
• • •
Zack Bartlett
a month ago
Best pizza around, like best I've ever had. But Jesus Christ get your act together. You have two locations that I know of and you don't even have the phone system down. On more than one occasion I have been simply unable to talk to anyone there because your systems sucks SO BAD. I even called the Raleigh location thinking they might want to let Durham know they had a problem and the idiot there couldn't care less. Which brings me to my next point, either your managers are horrible or you just have the highest concentration of idiots in the food service industry. I make it a point to be clear and precise when speaking on the phone because I mumble, but I have to repeat my order multiple times EVERY TIME because I'm convinced everyone is just playing grabass. I think this, because the few times I've been IN your location I SEE them behaving like children. I get the s pizza place is fun and the staff is young and I'm a grumpy old man, but behave like a business. I LOVE your food but I get scared every time I call and I get the message that your phone has been disconnected because I just think "yeah I knew they couldn't last operating like they do"
• • •
Curtis Chi
3 months ago
In the past Lily's has been a great place for pizza, and we were thrilled when they opened in Durham. However based on our past several visits their star is falling. Make no mistake, their food is still very good. However, customer service has been spotty at best. On our last visit the servers themselves were very nice, but the food was extremely slow to arrive. It should not take 90 minutes to eat lunch at a pizza restaurant - no matter how good the pizza is! Secondly, when the pizza was finally brought out with plates, our plates were dirty - they appeared to have not been washed, only brushed off as there were still bits of someone else's food on them. Lastly, we had a coupon from a ubiquitous fund-raising coupon book to use on our visit, which stated 'buy one lunch or dinner entree, get a second entree free up to $12 value'. We mentioned the coupon when we were seated and were assured we could order anything off the menu and apply the coupon. However, when the bill arrived our server apologetically told us that the manager had said we could not use the coupon because the pizza we ordered 'cost too much'. Now, we ordered drinks, a salad, a small pizza and a medium pizza. Apparently the manager said that since our medium pizza was $21 the coupon could not be used. But why not apply it to the $11 small pizza? We don't blame the server, but it sounded like the manager just did not want to honor the coupon. We did not argue the point, because by that time we had been there over 90 minutes and just needed to be on our way. In short - Very good pizza, however these days there are many very good pizza restaurants in Durham so you aren't limited to going to one with optional customer service. I'm sure the point of putting coupons in the coupon book is to gain new customers, not lose existing ones, but there you are.
• • •
John Ahlers's profile photo
John Ahlers
4 weeks ago
Great pizza and good lunch specials! Service isn't always great, but the pizza is generally pretty good. Wish they'd thin-slice the potatoes on "The Aristocrat" though...
Brittany Stephenson
a week ago
Food is good but the service is the downfall. Wait staff is slow. Drinks were never refilled in a timely manner. Took 10 minutes to get a bottled beer. Waitress never came to check on us. Waited over an hour and half for small pizza.
rick wilson
3 months ago
Best pizza around, hands down. They also have honey sriracha wings which are off the chain! I recommend the Dantes Inferno or the Super Duper. The salads are really good too. The atmosphere, decorations and music are a good way.
Matthew Clayton
3 months ago
This is the best pizza I have found anywhere and their salads are amazing too. Great food and a good atmosphere. Can't speak to the service complaints because I always do take out or delivery.
Inka Johnson's profile photo
Inka Johnson
4 months ago
The pizza was good, not spectacular. I think Enzo's was better (and cheaper!). Roasted vegetable salad was good. But the service is HORRIBLE!! Arrived at 6:50pm, got food at 8:15. Pint of beer took 15 minutes. The kitchen capacity of this place is WAY too small for the number of tables. Don't seat a full house until you add some ovens!