Aurelio's Pizza
Pizza Restaurant$$
Today 11:00 am – 9:00 pm
Contact Information
Gulf Coast Town Center 9909 Gulf Coast Main St Fort Myers, FL 33913
9909 Gulf Coast Main StreetUSFloridaFort Myers33913
$$Pizza Restaurant, Italian RestaurantToday 11:00 am – 9:00 pm
Monday 11:00 am – 9:00 pmTuesday 11:00 am – 9:00 pmWednesday 11:00 am – 9:00 pmThursday 11:00 am – 9:00 pmFriday 11:00 am – 10:00 pmSaturday 11:00 am – 10:00 pmSunday 11:00 am – 9:00 pm
Google+ URL

Street View

Your Activity

Is this your business?

Manage this page
Write a review
Review Summary
40 reviews
5 star
15 reviews
4 star
5 reviews
3 star
7 reviews
2 star
6 reviews
1 star
7 reviews
Longtime chain known for thin- & thick-crust pies, pastas & other Italian staples.- Google
"Pizza: thin crust = thick and doughy, cheese = cheddar (ewwww) and mozzarella."
"Our waitress (can't remember her name, sorry dear!"
Upload first public photo
All reviews
Sophia Holt
2 months ago
WORST PIZZA PLACE IN TOWN! I'm telling you, will be in a daze and hitting the toilet hard after you finish eating at this place. Waiter was very sketchy and seemed to be interested in his phone than his customers. Ordered the large aurelios salad (family of 6) with hint of dressing on it, big chunks of ice berg lettuce, how much cheaper can you get?! Than ordered the calbrese that was loaded with way too much spinach and tasted odd. Got medium pizza that costs 20 bucks I'll never get back. SERIOUSLY, WHO PUTS CHEDDAR CHEESE ON PIZZA???? It was so greasy, I thought I could use the extra oil to take home and fry a couple of things. Next, we got the chicken parmesan that obviously came straight from the GFS Market freezer. Why do these people think they can pawn this junk off on people? The waiter was a whole another story. This guy was serving us our drinks with his greasy paws touching the rims of our glasses and still to this day I do not know his name, I don't think I want to either. Anyway, the bill came out to a staggering 100 hundred dollars and at that moment I was better off just buying a couple of DiGiorno's with a 2 liter and call it a night. Almost instantly, I felt sick to my stomach with pounding migraine and couldn't see straight. The waiter asking me if I want a refill 50 times, also worsened my sick feeling. Please, save your hard-earned money from this dump. They really should put out a sign that says, "Sorry! We're Open!"
• • •
Erica DeWalt
8 months ago
Our family stopped by one night and got pizza and a few drinks. Can't complain, pizza was thin and crispy. Our waitress (can't remember her name, sorry dear! We sat right near the bar) was very attentive and nice as can be. They weren't too crowded, atmosphere was nice, and most importantly the food was great!
Kristy Castrogiovanni's profile photo
Kristy Castrogiovanni
9 months ago
Well the place was great as was the salad, BUT then the pizza came out and there was cheddar cheese on it?? Extremely disappointing and greasy. It ruined the flavor of the pizza and the sausage did not taste like Chicago. We are both from Chicago and know what Chicago pizza is and that wasn't it. If they fixed the pizza the place would be a hit. We will be waiting on Rosati's to open in Fort Myers.
Ron Johnson
a year ago
Pizza is good, however....$30 for a large pizza? That is outrageous. Again, good pizza but not worth the price at all. I have had much better for half the price. Try Jet's pizza instead. Much better!
Craig Grissom
4 months ago
My wife and I stopped by for the lunch buffet. The salad was not fresh with very few options. The soup was cold and after waiting for pizza to be put out it was a bigger disappointment. The pizza was all cheese with very little if any meat and very greasy. I wanted to treat my wife to a nice lunch today and made the mistake of stopping here.
3 months ago
Having been to the original in Homewood IL I was afraid that it would not be as good. I had nothing to be worried about. The pizza was amazing and our server was awesome. We drove an hour and 45 minutes for pizza and it was worth it!
Ken Figurelli
11 months ago
I am from Chicago, and grew up with Aurelio's pizza. Best pizza on the planet. Suasage, mushroom, and onion - YUM.
P.J. Lucus
2 years ago
Our waiter Carlos couldn't have been nicer and our kids and we had great meals for a reasonable price. We were stuffed and still brought enough home for lunch the next day. The calabrese was out of this world.