Cover photo
Verified local business
Nathaniel's Pub
Today 11:00 am – 2:00 am
1 follower|176,505 views


Nathaniel's Pub

Shared publicly  - 
251 Exchange Boulevard, Rochester, NY 14608-2706
Add a comment...
Have them in circles
1 person
michelle tancrede's profile photo
Contact Information
Map of the business location
251 Exchange Blvd Rochester, NY 14608
251 Exchange BoulevardUSNew YorkRochester14608
(585) 232-8470
$Pub, RestaurantToday 11:00 am – 2:00 am
Monday 11:00 am – 2:00 amTuesday 11:00 am – 2:00 amWednesday 11:00 am – 2:00 amThursday 11:00 am – 2:00 amFriday 11:00 am – 2:00 amSaturday 11:00 am – 2:00 amSunday 12:00 pm – 2:00 am
Great Food, Great Drinks, and a Great Time with Friends and Family!
Google+ URL
Have them in circles
1 person
michelle tancrede's profile photo
Write a review
Review Summary
32 reviews
5 star
4 reviews
4 star
3 reviews
3 star
7 reviews
2 star
6 reviews
1 star
12 reviews
"Food was great (I had a wrap and my wife, a salad."
"And then 35 more minutes to get our buffalo wing dip appetizer!"
Upload first public photo
Your Activity
All reviews
Anthony DiSanto
2 months ago
wud never go there again owner was rude we had coupon that said 1 per table so did another couple said we wud sit at table side by side owner said no way wud have to sit on other side of restraunt so we left wud nevr step foot in that hell of a place to be treated like that was very rude to my wife so recomend go to otterslodge like we did they let us sit at same table and both use a coupon very nice servers and waitress tony disanto
David Kavanagh's profile photo
David Kavanagh
a year ago
My wife had a gift certificate for here, so we checked the menu on-line and reviews. We saw a lot of negativity but decided we ought to try it since we had $25 already paid for. We went on a Thursday about 6pm. It wasn't crowded and we got really prompt service. We sat a a table, were offered a sample of a new beer on tap (which we tried). We ordered beer and got 2 pints in a normal time. We ordered just after that and got food in what I thought was also reasonable time. The waitress checked on us twice during the meal. Food was great (I had a wrap and my wife, a salad). Overall, very happy. Maybe they saw the reviews and got things together. In fact, I mentioned this to the waitress after we paid and she said they'd seen them, so maybe I'm right.
• • •
Mindy Sammon
8 months ago
The food was great, our server was nice but the service was sloooow!!!
Sarah Cox
2 years ago
We live in the Corn Hill Neighborhood and desired a plate of nachos. Upon searching the area we decided on walking down the street to Nathaniel's Pub, a restaurant we hadn't tried that was three blocks away. Upon entering an almost empty restaurant/bar, we waited 10 minutes while the the female bartender (short with dark hair) socialized before she took our order. It then took another 5 minutes before she brought our drinks. She continued to socialize through the time that our food was delivered by the cook. She didn't check on us for another 15 minutes when we flagged her down for another drink. She approached us with mouth full of food and poured our wine, while smacking at the mouth. She also spilled the beverage all over the counter. We are constant patrons of local restaurants around Rochester and have never received such poor service as this. We will never return.
• • •
Michael Marciano
2 months ago
Shittiest restaurant ever, cheapo bastards. Foods greasy and people are rude. AVOID AT ALL COSTS!
Tracy Adams
a year ago
What a racket this place has with TNT & Flower City towing companies. I arrived to meet a friend for an early lunch at about 15 minutes before 11:00 and they were not open yet. We parked our cars and decided to walk around and look at the Cornhill area until they opened. Surprisingly we came back for lunch at 11:10 and her car GONE, it had been towed in like 20 minutes and I am not exaggerating!!! Must have been a Nathaniel's Employee that called them to tow it....because think about what a racket that is....we park and maybe 20 minutes later the car is GONE...didn't take long that's for sure.... someone is getting kickbacks for the pricey $130.00 cost of the tow! BEWARE OF SCUM ARTISTS AT NATHANIEL"S PUB!!!! The food is nothing special and the service is lacking a seems funny how this place could hold up in such a newly developed and updated district that Corhill claims to be... Not worth your trip, spend your money elsewhere.
• • •
karen franklin
a year ago
On Wednesday, June 19th I was eating lunch at Panzari’s Italian Bistro between the hours of 1pm and 2:20pm. Due to the lunch time the rush, the parking lot was very full so I parked outside of your pub which is located in the same parking lot as Panzari’s. When I had finished lunch, I went back to my car to find it missing. I went into your pub and spoke with a bartender asking her if she saw someone take my car and was told that it was probably towed. She was very aloof and didn’t seem to know where any of the signs were in the parking lot giving me the name of the towing company or why it was towed. I eventually found a sign noting the towers name and address, however the red & white sign above this sign stated that the parking lot was for restaurant and shopping patrons; I was a restaurant patron. Because this sign states you must be a restaurant patron to park in the parking lot and my car was towed even though I was visiting a restaurant in this lot, I believe I was a victim of predatory towing. The City of Rochester law (ordinance 83-317, section 108A-7) regarding towing practices clearly states, “The signs shall state that unauthorized vehicles will be towed at the vehicle owner's expense and shall contain the towing company's name, the telephone number to call to retrieve towed vehicles, and the street address where towed vehicles may be retrieved.” I took video and pictures of all the signs in that parking lot and can prove that there is no sign that states the parking places in front of Nathaniel’s Pub are specifically reserved for patrons of the pub while also stating that if you park there, your car can be towed at the owner’s expense. I can also prove by my restaurant receipt from Panzari’s along with having a witness with me who was also having lunch that I was there between this timeframe. Needless to say, I will never be going to Corn Hill Landing Plaza owned by Mark IV Enterprises, trolled by TNT Recovery & Flower City Towing and will be telling everyone I know about my experience.
• • •
e Iversen's profile photo
e Iversen
2 years ago
I am a regular here and can tell you they have wonderful friendly staff and great food for a fair price. They have a large selection of beer, some local, which we love. As for the comments about the service, I have seen a lot of new waitresses and assume they have gotten rid of the not so friendly or experienced girls. As for the review about the blue cheese "food poisoning", I am an RN and can safely say food poisoning happens much more quickly than 5 hours! All in all it's a fun place to bring my family, the atmosphere is great, and I love the DJ on Tuesdays for "Ladies Night". I suggest you go see for yourself.
• • •