Cover photo
1,671 followers|604,063 views


Comment Tracker

Shared publicly  - 
PSA - YouTube Live comments are broken

Due to a bug or unannounced changes on Google's side, YouTube Live/HOA comments don't show up in the API and therefore can't be included in Comment Tracker.

(They also don't show up on the video page after the HOA is over...)

Sorry for the inconvenience. Unfortunately there's nothing I can do about it until Google fixes the issue.
Server-side issues and feature requests
Gerwin Sturm's profile photoMatthew WIDELL-SC's profile photoComo Vivir Por Fe's profile photo
+Matthew WIDELL-SC While I think the comment tracker app is the best program I have seen for displaying YouTube and G+ comments on screen, I am also exploring the use of the "audience questions" feature in google slides, where you get a url that people can visit and start putting their questions and comments on, up or down vote them, and then you, as the presenter, can choose which comments to show on screen. There are a few inconveniences with it (namely that the url for submitting the questions is limited to the time you have it open, so that you cannot send out the url days in advance to people), and other hassles. But I am doing a live show this coming Tuesday where I'll be testing that feature out). You may also want to look into it in case it is of use to you.
Add a comment...

Comment Tracker

Shared publicly  - 
Everything new and shiny

After having the new version tested by a beta group (thanks to all of you!) I felt the new version was ready enough to publish to all.

You will find the new version using the URLs you are already used to.

Stand-alone version:
Hangout app:

If you should run into problems with the new versions, the old versions are still available as well:

Old stand-alone version:
Old Hangout app:

The attached Google Doc should include all the important infos about features in the new version:

Feel free to ask questions and provide feedback :)
Comment Tracker's profile photoHangout Staff's profile photo
Add a comment...

Comment Tracker

Shared publicly  - 
#io14  is coming closer and closer

If you can't attend in person and also can't attend one of the numerous #ioextended  events, but want to keep up-to-date with what is currently going on, we have prepared a tracking URL for you, which brings together #io14  posts from Twitter and Google+.

And once the URLs for the live streams are public you can simply add those to the tracker and watch the video right there together with the social stream. (We'll try to update the tracking URL in this post including the live streams, but can't promise to change it in time for the keynote).

Edit: URL Updated with the live stream.
Add a comment...

Comment Tracker

Shared publicly  - 
Profile Photos

By popular request the "comment screen" now features a photo of the commenter. Note that this is just a quick prototype, I'll have to spend some more time to rewrite the comment screen with some better styling.

In addition for YouTube comments I now try to retrieve a proper profile image when available, as opposed to just showing the YouTube logo.

As always, feedback welcome :)

#commenttracker   #hangoutapps   #hangouts   #hangoutsonair #hoa
Carol Dodsley's profile photoSheila Strover's profile photoGerwin Sturm's profile photoMichael Tucker's profile photo
I was running a livestream over the weekend and being able to pull in the comments from YouTube as well as Twitter would have been very handy.
Add a comment...

Comment Tracker

Shared publicly  - 
Thanks +Ronnie Bincer for putting together another great tutorial on how to use the not-so-obvious Twitter-functionality in Comment Tracker :)
10 Steps to Bring Twitter Comments into your HOA Broadcast
HOA Tips & Hashtag Tips
Hangouts on Air are a Magical Communications Tool... but not everyone can be In the Show, so we have found a way to make the HOA more interactive when live by bringing the viewer's comments onto the screen as part of the broadcast.

Grabbing the comments from all over the place can be a challenge... that is why we use the +Comment Tracker tool to help wrangle them into one place. They come in fairly easily from Google+ and YouTube, but take a bit more work to herd them into the broadcast from Twitter... but it is possible and this step-by-step set of graphics shows you how.

For those that don't like pictures as much:
Make a Twitter Widget using a unique hashtag for your HOA show, copy the URL of the Widget and paste it into the stand-alone Comment Tracker tool's "Sources" field... do the rest of the stuff you know/should know how to do ref:  - now you got 'em.

If using the HOA (Hangouts on Air) tool is part of what you do, or will be, you should check out our awesome membership community called Hangout Mastery here
=== ===
#HOAtips   #CommentTracker   #TwitterTips   #TwitterComments   #HashtagTips   #HangoutMastery   #TheHangoutHelper  
Ronnie Bincer's profile photoKristal Reagan's profile photoAlice Fuller's profile photo
Really helpful. Thank u
Add a comment...

Comment Tracker

Shared publicly  - 
It's now easier than ever to start +Comment Tracker as part of +Hangout Toolbox :)
Recommended Hangout app
If you have never used the Hangout Toolbox before in your video calls, you will now see the app listed at the very top of the app bar.  The Hangout Toolbox has several features like Lower Thirds or Comment Tracker. You should definitely give it a spin in your next video call or Hangout On Air.

#Hangouts   #HangoutsOnAir   #googleplusupdate  
Dave Hill's profile photoMark Burns's profile photoKevin Tumlinson's profile photoSallena Pool's profile photo
+Mark Burns and +Kevin Tumlinson   Were you ever able to get answers to these questions?  I'm a couple of months behind you and stuck in the same place!
Add a comment...

Comment Tracker

Shared publicly  - 
Since the question came up several times, and Google doesn't really make the process obvious/easy, here's a step-by-step guide on how to enable Comment Tracker (or any other Hangout Apps) when running a Hangout as a Google+ Page:
Patrice Green's profile photo1SG Jeffery W. Crane's profile photoComment Tracker's profile photoDenver Prophit Jr.'s profile photo
Thanks for the update, +Comment Tracker.
Add a comment...

Comment Tracker

Shared publicly  - 
Beta is live for testing!

If you have signed up as beta tester you should have gotten an invite to a community where all relevant information is shared.

If you haven't gotten/have missed the invite or still want to join the beta, head over to and "Ask to join".
Michael Mason (What No Website)'s profile photo

Haven't Hungout in a while and have just seen the new CT standalone.

How do I track events posts, tweets or YouTube videos...?
Add a comment...

Comment Tracker

Shared publicly  - 
Looking for testers. Please comment on this or the original post to sign-up for the beta, which should be available in the coming weeks.
Sneak peek - Materialization and Polymerization

+Comment Tracker desperately needed a design and code refresh for quite a while now. With the new material design and accompanying Polymer paper elements coming out at #io14 (and the web-starter-kit that was published just before I/O), I felt inspired enough to get started on bringing Comment Tracker to more screens inside and outside of hangouts.

There's still some work to be done, but I'll be looking for testers in the coming weeks. So if you are interested in trying out the new version of Comment Tracker let me know in the comments, and I will add you to the circle I will share the links to the standalone and hangout-extension with, once it's stable and feature-complete enough for testing.

Some interesting custom elements that I needed to create in the process of implementing this so far (all of which will be open-sourced soonish)

A <twitter-fetcher> element based on the work by +Jason Mayes ( to retrieve and parse tweets as JSON from a Twitter widget.

A <text-screen> element based on the work by +Allen Firstenberg that takes text as input and displays a Hangout overlay.

A <simple-html> element that takes html as input, removes most of the tags, but still allows links to be displayed. This was necessary because Polymer automatically escapes all html input, so the only way to get links to be displayed is to split the html in text and link parts, extract the href from the links and have a template like this:

<template repeat="{{part in parts}}">
  <template if="{{}}">
    <a href="{{}}">{{part.text}}</a>
  <template if="{{!}}">

Having the design fully responsive also means, that it automatically works as Hangout extension which are limited to a width of 300px.

So now I have one <comment-tracker> element that includes all the functionality, and is included directly on the website.

For the Hangout extension I have a <hangout-comment-tracker> element, extending my <hangout-app> element ( to do the necessary Hangouts API setup. And inside the <hangout-comment-tracker> the same <comment-tracker> element as on the website is used. In the <comment-tracker> element I then check for existence of the Hangouts API to enable Hangout-only functionality, like the overlay.

#gde   #googleplus   #polymer   #article  

PS. Device template adapted from:
Dwaine Stroud's profile photoGilbert Mizrahi's profile photoRhonda Abrons's profile photoB.L. Ochman's profile photo
+Gerwin Sturm Comment Tracker seems to be getting more stable in HOAS latest, FYI :)
Add a comment...

Comment Tracker

Shared publicly  - 
Bringing Comment Tracker to the Big Screen

If you own a Chromecast device you can now use it to display your Comment Tracker stream on a bigger screen.
If you visit the standalone tracker at you can collect your sources as usual, and provided a Google Cast device is available you will see the cast icon on the top left of the middle column. (If you don't see the button right away it might mean that the app hasn't been published all the way to your device yet, restarting the Chromecast might fix this.)

While this might not be all that useful for following Hangouts (which was the original use-case of Comment Tracker), there are certainly other use-cases for this.
For example, how about events where you want to have a "social wall" displayed? We got you covered there. Arrange your Google+ and Twitter hashtag searches for your event (see for setting up Twitter) and you are all set to cast.

Since it's (of course) all over the news and social networks at the moment, the example in the video shows how to keep track of events in #sochi

While it would be possible to add the same functionality to the Hangout Extension of Comment Tracker, it doesn't make all that much sense there, so I will keep it in the standalone version for now. Let me know if you think the Cast button would be useful directly in the Hangout Extension as well :)

#chromecast   #commenttracker  
Comment Tracker's profile photoKathi Browne's profile photoCharlotte Pierce's profile photoMichael Mason (What No Website)'s profile photo
We're already doing this with +Hosted Hangouts and have the Comment Tracker Ticker running on screen while we broadcast.

Great for the viewers as they can see their comment even if the host/guests do not have time to respond.

Thanks for the update +Comment Tracker 
Add a comment...

Comment Tracker

Shared publicly  - 
Comment Tracker now appears in a new and awesome look inside of +Hangout Toolbox. Huge congrats and thanks to +Moritz Tolxdorff and +Robert Pitt for getting this out into the public :)
Introducing Hangout Toolbox v2

Today we are please to announce the release of the long-awaited Hangout Toolbox V2.

Hangout Toolbox V2 has been re-designed with simplicity in mind. we have created the application from the ground up, putting performance and beauty at the top of the list, it’s now clean and super friendly to use.

You can now enjoy your Lower Thirds or Custom Overlays in HD quality as they have also been redesigned allowing for a better experience for your audience.

We also changed the Comment Tracker’s Overlay. This will give your next Hangout On Air a really cool professional look.

We are also introducing a new settings tab that allows you to Auto load Hangout Toolbox when you enter a hangout, we have also added the ability to mute hangout sounds, allowing you to be more professional within Hangouts On Air.

We are deprecating Hangout Toolbox V1 during this release, we are also sorry to say that your previously stored overlays are not compatible with V2, but we are sure you are going to love V2 so much, this shouldn't be a problem :).

We are currently doing a staged roll-out, this means that over the next 24 hours more and more people will have V2 activated.

You can learn more about Hangout Toolbox on and check out the videos for each feature.

#HangoutToolbox   #Hangout  
archiles de mesa's profile photo
Ever since i am a number 1 fan and friend of google in time of any circumstance came on my life, and im so glad with their tools hangouts that gave more life on me, and ofcours for every one.. Thanks to you... Enjoy this special gifts for us.. Happy new year...
Add a comment...

Comment Tracker

Shared publicly  - 

The possibility to add Community streams as source to comment tracker (as described in isn't working currently. This functionality was based on an unofficial functionality in the Google+ APIs which isn't working any more. If you want this possibility back, please star the following issue:
Larry Fournillier's profile photo
Add a comment...
The must-have hangout extension for Hangouts on Air

Do you use Hangouts on Air and want your viewers to interact with you more directly?

This simple Hangout extension gives you this possibility by displaying the comments happening on Google+ posts directly inside of the hangout, giving you the chance to react to the comments live.

You can install the extension in your hangout by using this link: