Cover photo
Verified local business
Murphy's Steakhouse
Steak House$$
Today 4:30 – 10:00 PM
Contact Information
Map of the business location
This place has closed. Not true?
4189 N Keystone Ave Indianapolis, IN 46205
4189 North Keystone AvenueUSIndianaIndianapolis46205
$$Steak House, Seafood Restaurant
Steak House
Seafood Restaurant
Soup Restaurant
Today 4:30 – 10:00 PM
Saturday 4:30 – 10:00 PMSunday ClosedMonday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PMTuesday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PMWednesday 11:00 AM – 9:30 PMThursday 11:00 AM – 9:30 PMFriday 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
We offer steak, seafood, a signature house salad, and the best filet of beef tenderloin in Indianapolis. Our steak house has been a landmark since the 1970s! Stop in today to experience it yourself!
Google+ URL

Street View

Write a review
Review Summary
12 reviews
5 star
4 reviews
4 star
4 reviews
3 star
1 review
2 star
3 reviews
1 star
No reviews
"Once all orders were in, the wait for soup n salad, Good timing."
"Warm Berry Cobbler topped with Ice Cream was wonderful too."
"Thank you again, Murphy's Steak House in Indianapolis."
Scrapbook photo 2
Scrapbook photo 3
Scrapbook photo 4
Scrapbook photo 5
Upload public photo
Your Activity
All reviews
rs smith's profile photo
rs smith
2 years ago
Well where do I start, this was our first time visiting this eatery, no Good expérience. The family of about 50 or more was celebrating my brother in law 80th birthday party. First when entering the place we were instructed to seat ourselfs, started badly right there. Once escorted, @ my request, to the party, there were no seating aviliable. They made it happen. Once all orders were in, the wait for soup n salad, Good timing. Once everyone got their food, corrections when myself, my sister, and five or six others got their food it was cold, cold, cold...not good. My steak was over cooked, I order medium well, it was well done :-( wasnt happy @ all. Me n my husband meal costed 60.00 dollars or so. Still not happy thinking bout it. Not Good First time Visit. Will we return??, not sure. POOR FOOD.
• • •
Ashley Flew's profile photo
Ashley Flew
2 years ago
I would not even give this place 1 star! If I could give them a negative, I would. Worst 70 dollars I have ever spent in my life. Would rather drive down the interstate and throw my money out the window! We ordered a combination platter which had zucchini, cauliflower, cheese sticks, and mushrooms and it was all fried and so bad we could not even distinguish which was which (aside from what "looked to be" something). For the next course we got onion soup and bean soup...yeah, very salty is an under statement. It was so awful and salty my man drank my water AND his to bring his taste back to life. The cornbread they served with my soup was cold and had ZERO flavor aside from the butter that I had to put on it to give me some sort of taste! The next was the salad, lets just say the only thing good on there were the croutons; how you mess up a salad...IM NOT SURE?! Last but not least our main course...I got grilled chicken breast and a twice baked potato. I am a HUGE potato person.. that potato was so bad and looked bad that I would not have even given that to my dog or wish such an awful taste in my worst enemy's mouth!! The chicken was juicy (probably the only highlight of my meal) but once again was beyond salty. My man got their porterhouse and he ordered it medium and it came out medium rare... he is a big person on "if steak is good you dont need steak sauce"... that being said, i think he used half the bottle of steak sauce on it to get some sort of flavor. The waitress took away each plate we had and it was full of food she just served....DISGUSTING! I will never recommend anyone go to that place ever, Id rather lick a gas station bathroom floor. AWFUL!!! ZERO PROPS TO ANYONE WHO COOKED ANYTHING IN THAT PLACE!!!
• • •
mrs sim's profile photo
mrs sim
4 years ago
SEAFOOD, I won't tell you what, I don't want it to be absent from the menu when I return
A Google User
5 years ago
This business went out of their way to provide awesome food and service to my son and daughter-in-law's wedding rehearsal dinner. They handled my Friday evening party of 20 with nothing but compliments from my guests; they have my highest recommendation! Thank you again, Murphy's Steak House in Indianapolis.
Tyler Ludlow's profile photo
Tyler Ludlow
2 years ago
Good steaks, fries, fish, burger. The chipotle marinated steak wasn't very chipotle-ish, but still tasty. 9 people for lunch and everyone thought the food was very v9d and the service friendly.
John F. Bruns's profile photo
John F. Bruns
4 years ago
Very disappointing lunch. Had a Reuben the day after St. Pat's day and the corned beef was so tough neither of us could bite though it. By the time we fought with the sandwich, it was in pieces with sauce and bread everywhere. The staff was very friendly. The atmosphere was dark for lunch time. Not planning on going back
Darin Bagley's profile photo
Darin Bagley
4 years ago
Great little family place
A Google User
5 years ago
Have not been here in years, but made a trip there tonight. Was better than I remembered. Staff friendly & efficient. The hot bacon dressing on fresh salad was so good. Beef-noodle soup was flavorful & hot on this cold night. Steak was cooked to perfection & very tender. Warm Berry Cobbler topped with Ice Cream was wonderful too.


Murphy's Steakhouse hasn't shared anything with you.

People are more likely to share with you if you add them to your circles.