Profile

Cover photo
Matthew Collin
Attends University of Oxford
Lives in Oxford, UK
403 followers|2,461 views
AboutPostsPhotosYouTube

Stream

Matthew Collin

Shared publicly  - 
 
Ugh, after slating Econ 101 with the previous link, I take it all back. Here is an organisation that buys AK-47s at above-market prices in conflict zones to try and reduce the number of AK-47s in conflict zones.
2
1
Add a comment...

Matthew Collin

Shared publicly  - 
 
Wow - the US is joining IATI - this I would not have expected.
1
Add a comment...

Matthew Collin

Shared publicly  - 
 
I have yet to get my hands on the copy of this study, but a few things are worth noting. They're important not only because the media is embracing this study in a typically stupid, careless and sensational manner - it's also just bad science, and the sort of thing we should be watching out for in development research as well.

1) Firstly, note the extremely small sample size of this study - 22. If the results are coming through at a statistically significant level, this indicates quite large impacts. Still, we should be cautious at extrapolating something from such a small sample especially since

2) The sample selection criteria is suspect - the men who were chosen for the study were chosen because they previously had not had much exposure to violent video games. Think about the external validity here - we are making statements about an entire population (adult men who play video games) based on a sample of people who self-select out of the treatment. It's quite possible that the effect is nil on the type of people who choose to play violent video games.

3) The fact that the treatment is "playing violent video games" and the control is "doing nothing" means we can't really say it was the violence itself which had an impact on the brain. Nor, possibly, can we even say it is video games at all - staring at a tv screen more often than normal could be the result. We need different types of treatments to parse out these impacts: some men need to be playing non-violent video games, some men need to be watching movies, etc. This study really doesn't allow us to make many assertions about the components of the treatment itself.

4). Again, I haven't gotten the chance to see the paper yet, but fMRI studies are notorious for plucking significant results out of thin air - for example, less than 50% adjust their inference methods to account for sub-group analysis (fMRI studies divide the brain into regions and test effects within each region, which increases the probability that we'll find a result by chance). Recall the fMRI paper where researchers got positive results out of a dead salmon.

5). The reports on actual aggression are mixed - but generally I haven't seen any reports which actually cite evidence that the treatment group got more aggressive, just that their brains looked different after playing the games.

6). The men were measured a week after cessation of the treatment and the results were already fading - these are, at least as far as we can trust the study, not permanent changes in the brain.
1
1
Add a comment...

Matthew Collin

Shared publicly  - 
 
I have yet to see a film in 3D, but this Ghanaian film is a candidate for conversion if ever I've seen one.
1
1
shine sun's profile photo
 
waouwwwwwww!!!!
Add a comment...
Have him in circles
403 people
Sean O'Leary's profile photo
Abhijeet Singh's profile photo

Matthew Collin

Shared publicly  - 
 
Shameless self-promotion, but nice surprise to discover I got linked by Andrew Sullivan yesterday
1
Add a comment...

Matthew Collin

Shared publicly  - 
 
If you aren't reading Global Dashboard, you should be. Not frequently updated, but frequently hilarious and well-argued.
1
Add a comment...

Matthew Collin

Shared publicly  - 
 
Some useful thoughts on the Greg Mankiw walkout - brings me back to my first days of Econ 101 at Clemson.
1
Add a comment...

Matthew Collin

Shared publicly  - 
 
The recent research paper on the impacts of the MDGs (conducted independently) purported that there was no impact on income. Predictably, Team Impact (you can guess who's in Team Impact) jumps on it and uses it to thwack Team MV over the head.

Ever the sly contrarian - Chris Blattman bothers to read the paper with a critical eye, and finds many shortcomings. Really crucial discussion between Blattman and Michael Clemens in the comments.

Something that Clemens says jump out of me, roughly: `these results are important because the are independent'.

Are independent results more likely to be truly unbiased? Let's think a little bit about standard research bias - usually we 're always looking to show an impact, positive or negative. But now the null hypothesis is: "Millennium Villages are the holy grail of poverty alleviation, prove us wrong." To me, it seems like `independent' researchers have a huge incentive to disprove, not affirm, the MVP's claims. True independence would have involved a little more transparency at the start - although this may not have been practical.

http://chrisblattman.com/2011/11/29/the-millennium-villages-evaluated-a-skeptical-view/#comments
1
1
Add a comment...

Matthew Collin

Shared publicly  - 
 
Just had a glance at my `African Leaders 2010 Calendar' which sits rolled up behind me in the dept - I crossed off 6 - either dead, deposed, or defeated in just over a year.
1
Paul Clist's profile photoMatthew Collin's profile photoHunter Nielson's profile photo
3 comments
 
There were some rumours of his death recently - turned out to be untrue, but he's traveling in East Asia right now, possibly for health reasons.... so who knows.
Add a comment...
People
Have him in circles
403 people
Sean O'Leary's profile photo
Abhijeet Singh's profile photo
Work
Occupation
PhD student
Employment
  • Student, present
  • Ministry of Finance, Malawi
Places
Map of the places this user has livedMap of the places this user has livedMap of the places this user has lived
Currently
Oxford, UK
Previously
Conway, South Carolina - Lilongwe, Malawi - Dar es Salaam, Tanzania
Links
Other profiles
Story
Introduction

I'm a DPhil (PhD) student in Economics at the University of Oxford and New College, where I also obtained an MSc in Economics for Development.

I blog about economics, development and international aid at aidthoughts.org

My interests are broadly centred on development economics, ranging from larger issues such as the political economy and impact of international aid, to the smaller, microeconometric questions concerning nutritional distribution and health, land rights, and ethnicity in SSA.

I am a former ODI Fellow, having worked for two years as a budget officer in the Ministry of Finance for the Government of Malawi.

I am also an amateur film director, some of the films I have produced can be found here.

Education
  • University of Oxford
    present
  • University of Oxford
  • Clemson University
Basic Information
Gender
Male