Start a hangout
The Original Benito One
Verified local business
3 followers|625,401 views
Write a review
Hearty helpings of classic Italian fare dished up in a simple, long-running (since 1968) trattoria.- Google
Upload public photo
5 months ago
My wife and I eat here every time we visit the city. Never had anything on the menu I didn't like. They treat you like family. Recommend to everyone. LOVE THIS RESTAURANT!
4 months ago
I was looking for a place that would remind me of my travels to Itlay. This place couldn't get any more authentic. Would love to eat here often and could afford to do so as it's not expensive, but I love a planes ride away!
Fred Amy San Juan
2 years ago
My husband expressed that this was the best meal he ever had. The stuffed veal shank was delicious and so was my penne with mushrooms and Marsala sauce. Our waiter was awesome and recommended everything we ate - no need to even look at the menu - it was almost as if he knew what we wanted! We're in the city every autumn for our anniversary - thanks for making our 6th one tops!
3 months ago
Only been there once. However, I think of it often and look forward to the next time. It's a long way to NY from GA to go just for dinner. Fantastic experience!
11 months ago
Quaint little place. Loved the baked ziti! Just so happened, that the weekend we visit NYC, there's a week long Italian festival, every place was PACKED! They got us in and seated on record time. Bravo!
2 years ago
An authentic Italian restaurant with a relaxed atmosphere, great food, and faultless hospitality.
3 years ago
I was walking down the street with my family looking for a place to eat when we were politely greeted on the curb by a gentleman who said hello and asked how we were doing. The service was excellent and the food was just as good! We were all very happy with the place and I would go back.
Response from the owner - 3 years ago
Dear Zisconnected, Thank you for such a great review, Hope to see you again Jimmy (Benito One)