Profile

Cover photo
Ryan Hayes
Works at Steadfast Networks
Lives in Chicago
302 followers|354,273 views
AboutPosts+1'sReviews

Stream

Ryan Hayes

Shared publicly  - 
 
“The Matrix”… (red pill = reality; blue pill = blissful ignorance)
8 votes  -  votes visible to Public
Red Pill
100%
Blue Pill
0%
1
Add a comment...

Ryan Hayes

Shared publicly  - 
 
 
Probability and statistics abounds with many fallacies, "paradoxes", and otherwise unintuitive statements, often caused by the presence of various sampling biases that might not be immediately obvious without some mathematical (or similarly careful) analysis.  Some of my favorite examples of these phenomena are Simpson's paradox, Berkson's fallacy, and the friendship paradox (all of which can be found for instance on Wikipedia).

One such unintuitive fact (basically a special case of Simpson's paradox) is the following: the number of failures that a person experiences in a field can be positively correlated with how competent that person is in that field: the more failures a person generates, the more likely that person is to be competent!  

Let's see how.  For sake of discussion, let's say that the field is book writing, and that there are only two types of book one can produce: good books (successes) and bad books (failures).  Let's also say for simplicity that authors fall into two classes: competent writers, who produce good books 3/4 of the time and bad books 1/4 of the time, and incompetent writers, who produce good books only 1/4 of the time and bad books 3/4 of the time.

Intuitively, one would then expect that an author who has written a lot of bad books is more likely to be an incompetent author than an author who has written very few bad books.  But this is not necessarily the case!  The problem is that there is a confounding variable, namely the number of books each author writes.  This variable is partly determined by internal author traits, such as the author's persistence, but is also influenced by the external success of the author's works, and this can be enough to flip the correlation.

To make a concrete numerical illustration of this, let us consider four types of authors, who are either competent or incompetent, or persistent or not persistent.

1.  A competent, not persistent author might write just 4 books (say) during his or her career, of which 3 are good and 1 is bad.

2. An incompetent, not persistent author might also write just 4 books in his or her career, of which 1 is good and 3 are bad.

3.  A competent, persistent author might write as many as 40 books over his or her career, of which 30 are good and 10 are bad.

4.  An incompetent, persistent author might aspire to write 40 books in his or her career, however faced with frequent negative reviews and poor sales, he or she may eventually quit after writing only 8 books, of which 2 are good and 6 are bad.

With this simple example, one sees that it is the competent author who ends up writing the most bad books; also, out of all the bad books published by the above four authors, the majority were written by competent authors rather than incompetent ones.  Because of the biasing effect of discouragement of persistent, incompetent authors, the fact that an author has a large number of bad books to his or her name becomes evidence in favor of competent writing, rather than incompetent writing!

EDIT: It is important though to note that correlation does not imply causation: the above analysis does not indicate that one can become a better writer by intentionally producing bad books.  (See also "Goodhart's law".)
22 comments on original post
1
Add a comment...

Ryan Hayes

commented on a video on YouTube.
Shared publicly  - 
 
One can see how studying this isomorphism grew into category theory. At least MacLean/Eilenberg 1948 used this example when introducing categories.
1
Add a comment...

Ryan Hayes

commented on a video on YouTube.
Shared publicly  - 
 
"A locale is, intuitively, like a topological space that may or may not have enough points (or even any points at all). It contains things we call open subspaces but there may or may not be enough points to distinguish between open subspaces. An open subspace in a locale can be regarded as conveying a bounded amount of information about the (hypothetical) points that it contains."

not to be mean but please do not imply mathematicians are to be "bested". we are not interested in your 100 TeV pissing match.


1
Add a comment...

Ryan Hayes

commented on a video on YouTube.
Shared publicly  - 
 
What an excellent view of philosophy.
1
Add a comment...

Ryan Hayes

commented on a video on YouTube.
Shared publicly  - 
 
Thanks for making this video. I don't have schizophrenia but it's really insightful to know what it's like. Thanks for sharing your story. 
1
Add a comment...

Ryan Hayes

Shared publicly  - 
 
Check out this video on YouTube:
1
jean Olaf's profile photoRyan Hayes's profile photo
2 comments
 
is there another span in history where 14,000,000 people died in such a period? and in such a confined geographical space? as a matter of policy?
Add a comment...
In his circles
314 people
Have him in circles
302 people
stacy keaton's profile photo
Andrew Sheldon's profile photo
‫احمد رضا‬‎'s profile photo
tucker s's profile photo
Jemetrius Wilson's profile photo
Maxwell Clinkingbeard's profile photo
Arpit Daniel Das's profile photo
Rana Owais's profile photo
Steven Pemberton's profile photo

Ryan Hayes

Shared publicly  - 
 
dyh
1
Peter Her's profile photoRyan Hayes's profile photo
3 comments
 
thanks
Add a comment...

Ryan Hayes

commented on a video on YouTube.
Shared publicly  - 
 
:-(
1
Add a comment...

Ryan Hayes

commented on a video on YouTube.
Shared publicly  - 
 
Deodorant, deodorant, deodorant, deodorant.
3
Ryan Txanson's profile photo
 
This is how crazy NIMBY people sound at neighborhood meetings too. 
Add a comment...

Ryan Hayes

commented on a video on YouTube.
Shared publicly  - 
 
This is so stupid.
3
Peter Her's profile photo
 
He knows he's viewed as "an expert on sex", so he spews out his own personal ideas to get everyone to believe him, in order to act out on his sexual appetite, justified by the words spoken from his own mouth.
Add a comment...

Ryan Hayes

commented on a video on YouTube.
Shared publicly  - 
 
I am obsessed with military history and Rumsfeld is without a doubt an awful Defense Secretary. I don't generally agree with dovish people but Rumsfeld was that awful combination of hawkish and stupid.
1
Add a comment...
People
In his circles
314 people
Have him in circles
302 people
stacy keaton's profile photo
Andrew Sheldon's profile photo
‫احمد رضا‬‎'s profile photo
tucker s's profile photo
Jemetrius Wilson's profile photo
Maxwell Clinkingbeard's profile photo
Arpit Daniel Das's profile photo
Rana Owais's profile photo
Steven Pemberton's profile photo
Work
Occupation
Research.
Skills
Thinking.
Employment
  • Steadfast Networks
    Director of Research, 2007 - present
Basic Information
Gender
Male
Birthday
March 28
Relationship
In a relationship
Story
Tagline
Hi, I’m Ry.
Introduction
Walking up and down the Earth since day 88 of '88.
Places
Map of the places this user has livedMap of the places this user has livedMap of the places this user has lived
Currently
Chicago
Contact Information
Home
Email
Ryan Hayes's +1's are the things they like, agree with, or want to recommend.
Minecraft Servers - Minecraft Server List
minecraft-server-list.com

Search and Find the best Minecraft Servers using our multiplayer Minecraft Server List. Vote for Top Minecraft Servers. Survival, Creative o

König's Lemma - Google Groups
groups.google.com

König's Lemma, Ryan Hayes, 8/13/14 3:14 AM. Has anybody attempted to prove König's Lemma in UF? As a refresh, König's Lemma states that if a

Homotopy Type Theory - Google Groups
groups.google.com

Linear Dependent Types, Alexander Kuklev, 8:29 AM. is a term a program? v v, 4:06 AM. two papers, v v, 7/14/14. HoTT with an interval object

The HoTT Book
homotopytypetheory.org

Homotopy Type Theory: Univalent Foundations of Mathematics The Univalent Foundations Program Institute for Advanced Study Buy a hardcover co

George Zimmerman Charged With Aggravated Assault
abcnews.go.com

George Zimmerman, who was acquitted this summer of murdering teenager Trayvon Martin, has been arrested in Florida and charged with aggravat

Wii Sports Club
www.nintendo.com

Play your favorite Wii Sports™ games on the Wii U console! With Wii Sports Club, you can now take the competition online* with tennis and bo

This Is Why You Shouldn't Interrupt a Programmer | The Slightly Disgrunt...
heeris.id.au

Yep. One time someone came in and quietly stood by my desk until I noticed him. Literally just stood there. I ignored him for a little bit h

Re: [ 00/19] 3.10.1-stable review
lkml.org

On Mon, Jul 15, 2013 at 8:52 AM, Sarah Sharp wrote: > > I'll roar > right back, louder, for all the people who lose their voice when they >

Question about frame metadata in assembly/linker - Google Groups
groups.google.com

Google Groups. Question about frame metadata in assembly/linker. Keith Randall, Jun 12, 2013 10:27 AM. Posted in group: golang-dev. As part

LEGO
plus.google.com

Inspire and develop the builders of tomorrow

D. J. Bernstein Mathematics and computer science Computer hardware ...
cr.yp.to

D. J. Bernstein. Mathematics and computer science. Computer hardware: chip speed, buying computers, etc. Data structures and program structu

Google Maps - Apps on Android Market
market.android.com

Download the latest release of Google Maps, and never carry a paper map again. Get Google Maps with Navigation (Beta), Places, and Latitude

Google Music - Apps on Android Market
market.android.com

Shop music on Android Market and listen instantly using the Google Music app. Google Music is a cloud-powered music player and storage servi

Uniqlo
plus.google.com

Change clothes, change conventional wisdom, change the world

Occupy Wall Street Crowd Greets Fox Host With Chants Of ‘Fox News Lies’
thinkprogress.org

Conservative Writer Admits 'Infiltrating' 99% Movement To 'Undermine' It. NEWS FLASH. Occupy Wall Street Crowd Greets Fox Ho

The Colbert Report
plus.google.com

Hosted by Stephen Colbert, "The Colbert Report" airs at 11:30/10:30c on Comedy Central.

Martha Stewart
plus.google.com

The Official Google+ page for Martha Stewart

Python
plus.google.com

Python is a remarkably powerful dynamic programming language.

Schneier on Security
www.schneier.com

My Next Book Title: Liars and Outliers. Thank you for all your comments and suggestions regarding my next book title. It will be: Liars and

Yes
Public - 2 months ago
reviewed 2 months ago
Worst DMV in the world. They're insanely rude and seem to get off on using their petty power... Sickened. Rick is a sociopath.
Public - 4 months ago
reviewed 4 months ago
Brought a friend from Japan here… amazing. :) The owner is amazing! Excellent food!
Food: ExcellentDecor: ExcellentService: Excellent
Public - 2 years ago
reviewed 2 years ago
52 reviews
Map
Map
Map
Public - 5 months ago
reviewed 5 months ago
Best market in Tower Hamlets area.
Quality: ExcellentAppeal: ExcellentService: Good
Public - 2 years ago
reviewed 2 years ago
At least they're open really late?
Food: GoodDecor: GoodService: Good
Public - 2 years ago
reviewed 2 years ago