Peanut Butter & Co.'s profile photo
Peanut Butter & Co.
Sandwich Shop$$
Today 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Contact Information
New York University 240 Sullivan St New York, NY 10012
240 Sullivan StreetUSNew YorkNew York10012
$$Sandwich Shop, Fast Food Restaurant
Sandwich Shop
Fast Food Restaurant
Family Restaurant
Takeout Restaurant
Today 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Tuesday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PMWednesday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PMThursday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PMFriday 11:00 AM – 10:00 PMSaturday 11:00 AM – 10:00 PMSunday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PMMonday 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
In 1998 The Peanut Butter & Co. Sandwich Shop opened as a a cozy little shop in Greenwich Village NYC, famous for making the world's greatest peanut butter sandwiches.
Google+ URL

Street View

Your Activity

Is this your business?

Manage this page
Write a review
Review Summary
125 reviews
5 star
39 reviews
4 star
47 reviews
3 star
29 reviews
2 star
5 reviews
1 star
5 reviews
Cafe selling its imaginative assortment of peanut butters in eat-in sandwiches & take-out jars.- Google
"The Dark Chocolate Dreams peanut butter really is the stuff of dreams."
"Can't understand why anyone would pay $7 for a peanut butter and jelly sandwich!"
Featured by Zagat
NYC's Best Kid-Friendly Restaurants
See more from Zagat
Scrapbook photo 2
Scrapbook photo 3
Scrapbook photo 4
Scrapbook photo 5
Scrapbook photo 6
Upload public photo
All reviews
Patrick Madden's profile photo
Patrick Madden
3 months ago
The sandwiches are pretty good, and have some interesting combinations of flavors I would never have thought to combine. This being said, none of the sandwiches are anything insanely unique that you could only get here - you could make every sandwich yourself at home for a fraction of the cost. The $6.00 to $8.50 cost is really very steep for a peanut butter sandwich. I get that they make their own peanut butter, but I couldn't tell the difference between it and a store bought brand. But that's beside the point. After hearing so much about this place, I was just really curious to see how it tasted. I went for the first time and ordered a fluffernutter sandwich and a vanilla shake. It tasted pretty good, and the peanut butter was really creamy. Again, something you could easily make yourself. What really annoyed me was when the guy was making my shake just left it blending in the machine for almost 5 minutes while he went to talk to someone in the kitchen. By the time he came out and turned off the mixer with my shake in it, I basically had a glass of milk. It was a poor excuse for a shake because it was just so thin. To make matters worse, he only filled about 3/4 of the cup. Really disappointing, and I feel like I got ripped off. Update: since last time I've ordered from here on a a few occasions with some friends. Every time it hurts my wallet, but always seems worth it. I tried recreating some of the sandwiches on my own and just couldn't do it.
• • •
Malea Grubb's profile photo
Malea Grubb
2 months ago
Cute, niche place. If you love peanut butter, you'll be happy here. Personally I think it's overpriced, but it's probably great for kids.
stanton lloyd's profile photo
stanton lloyd
a week ago
Awesome place, had the bees knees it was really tasty. Love the chips and veggies that came with it
Christopher Westendorf's profile photo
Christopher Westendorf
11 months ago
I came here with my family who has a slight peanut butter addiction. If you know anyone obsessed with peanut butter then this place has an amazing peanut butter menu they will love. We tried everything from a peanut butter cake, to a milkshake and a few sandwhiches such as the elvis. The elvis was amazing but the shake and the pie were so so.
Joseph Wieczorek's profile photo
Joseph Wieczorek
6 months ago
I came here with my family on Saturday, May 23, 2015. We sat down and took menus to decide what we wanted. The RUDE, RUDE, RUDE woman working behind the counter--slowly with the 3 people in line, I might add--came over to our table to chide us because "customers wanted to sit down." Ummm...We were customers, and there was only 1 table taken. Had she been quicker in line with those 3 people in line, we would have been able to order. She was offensive and everything that everyone says bad about New Yorkers was embodied in this older woman who clearly doesn't have business sense. We left without buying anything, but thank you, Peanut Butter and Company. A jar of Skippy and your unique menu left us with great ideas of how to prepare them. Please don't complain when you go out of business because you don't have customers. You let 4 people walk out the door because you would rather show that you're in charge than sell. Being civil goes a long way, Mrs. Peanut.
• • •
Marc Starvaggi's profile photo
Marc Starvaggi
a month ago
The sandwiches are great, but they're also peanut butter sandwiches and you're paying a restaurant price for them. A fun place to try, not frequent.
Leslie Teng's profile photo
Leslie Teng
3 months ago
Unique peanut butter flavors, helpful staff, inspired creations. Also a quick and filling bite
Ruth E.'s profile photo
Ruth E.
8 months ago
I'm in love with the Dark Chocolate Dreams! 😘 I've never been to the actual store but sending you guys some love from Miami☀️! Keep those chocolate dreams coming. ❤️