Cover photo
Verified local business
Today 6PM–2AM
Contact Information
Map of the business location
171 Avenue C New York, NY 10009
171 Avenue CUSNew YorkNew York10009
$Bar, Cocktail BarToday 6PM–2AM
Wednesday 6PM–2AMThursday 6PM–4AMFriday 6PM–4AMSaturday 6PM–4AMSunday 3PM–1AMMonday 6PM–2AMTuesday 6PM–2AM
Google+ URL

Street View

Write a review
Review Summary
23 reviews
5 star
11 reviews
4 star
5 reviews
3 star
1 review
2 star
3 reviews
1 star
3 reviews
Chill choice for artisanal cocktails in a funky-chic setting with low lighting & late hours.- Google
"The bartenders are friendly and really know how to craft these drinks."
"High quality cocktails in a cozy, relaxed setting."
Scrapbook photo 2
Scrapbook photo 3
Scrapbook photo 4
Scrapbook photo 5
Scrapbook photo 6
Upload public photo
Your Activity
All reviews
George Falero's profile photo
George Falero
a week ago
Loved the staff! Loved the cocktails! Wish they had happy hour or events but otherwise the perfect place to grab a great cocktail and relax after a hard day.
Response from the owner - in the last week
Hi George, Thanks so much for you great review of Evelyn. Thanks for your business. We DO have a happy hour, every day M-F 6pm-8pm, and all night long on Mondays. We also have a late night happy hour Monday through Thursday, midnight until close. Also, if you're interested in our events, forward us your email address and we'll put you on our email list. Thanks again. best, Jared
Silvana Catoiu's profile photo
Silvana Catoiu
a month ago
Only 2 types of wine, the bar ran out of ingredients to make drinks on several occasions during the few months I visited this bar and very limited beer selection. Additionally, one of the owners (Jared) is to be avoided if you don't want to regret it one way or another. He is unprofessional, rude and will stare at you all night long from the end of the bar. Too bad, Evelyn sure had potential!
Lisa Solimeo's profile photo
Lisa Solimeo
a year ago
Stumbled into Evelyn on a rainy Friday night around 1am and I loved it, mainly because there weren't a lot of people. I heard it is usually packed, so if you like your bars with seats go when it rains! Got a table for my group of 6 in the front section and we all ordered the very dangerous punch which goes down like a juice box. Really great atmosphere, dim lighting, great for a date or night out with good friends.
Response from the owner - a year ago
Hi Lisa, Thanks so much for the high praise. We appreciate your business. best, Evelyn team
Phil Novoa's profile photo
Phil Novoa
a year ago
Beautiful savage. .. what more do you need? The only beer on tap is Estrella Damn so you KNOW this place is legit. I love this place, great music!
Response from the owner - a year ago
Thanks so much for your kind review, Phil. We're looking forward to serving you many more Beautiful Savages! See you soon.
Jason James's profile photo
Jason James
4 months ago
High quality cocktails in a cozy, relaxed setting. The bartenders are friendly and really know how to craft these drinks. They're sophisticated, inventive, fun, and overall delicious.
Dan Gross's profile photo
Dan Gross
6 months ago
The drinks are ok (though worse than in the past), and the atmosphere is fine. Apparently they now enforce a 20% tip (on top of posted prices, without informing you) which I guess is why it's almost empty on a Friday night. And why service was still slow, apathetic, and inattentive. I really used to like this place but won't be back anymore. A real shame.
Rachel Hyman's profile photo
Rachel Hyman
a year ago
The bartender has no concept of hospitality. The drinks were little lists of ingredients, but they didn't understand the fundamentals of making a drink. When I asked about the odd use of crushed ice in a egg cocktail, the bartender was condescending and also, wrong. The drink has 7 ingredients, but tastes like an over sugared sour, served like a swizzle, with a garnish of tattered basil. The music was too loud to talk even though the place was nearly empty. This bar was a perfect storm of every mistake you can make in a cocktail bar, including the rude drivel on the back of their menu ( and a happy hour menu in orange ink on red paper! no one can read that). I'm happy to never go back.
• • •
Jason Wagg's profile photo
Jason Wagg
3 years ago
I am extremely biased as I am friends with the owners. I knew about this place well before it opened and waited eagerly for it to come together. Although I know the owners, I've always paid for my drinks and thoroughly enjoyed every one of them. Great guys, great drinks. A nice laid-back vibe takes the edge off and lets you hang out over a drink or several.


Evelyn hasn't shared anything with you.

People are more likely to share with you if you add them to your circles.