Today 5–10PM
Contact Information
This place has closed. Not true?
26 Virginia Pl Buffalo, NY 14202
26 Virginia PlaceUSNew YorkBuffalo14202
(716) 884-2630
$$FoodToday 5–10PM
Tuesday 5–10PMWednesday 5–10PMThursday 5–10PMFriday 5PM–12AMSaturday 5PM–12AMSunday ClosedMonday Closed
Google+ URL

Street View

Your Activity

Is this your business?

Manage this page
Write a review
Review Summary
12 reviews
5 star
3 reviews
4 star
4 reviews
3 star
No reviews
2 star
3 reviews
1 star
2 reviews
"The banana pepper app was pretty much all melted cheese."
"And were ordered medium rare and came out medium well to well."
"A fine dining establishment should know better."
Upload first public photo
All reviews
Katie Lane's profile photo
Katie Lane
3 years ago
It was about a 2 hour wait at Mother's at 9 o'clock 3 Fridays ago, so we went across the street to Scarlett. We should have stuck it out and waited for a table at our first choice. What a terrible experience at Scarlett. There were bar seats open and we were starving so we ate there. We ordered banana peppers as an app, ceasar salads, and the $34 steak dinners each. We waited 20 minutes for the first item to arrive...which was the salad and not the app. This wasn't Denny's so I'm not sure why the salad came before the app. A fine dining establishment should know better. 3 minutes after our salad came, the app came out. We love feeling rushed. The banana pepper app was pretty much all melted cheese. 3 minutes after that, our steak dinners came out. Our $34 steaks were about 85% fatty. Barely any meat on them at all. And were ordered medium rare and came out medium well to well. It was disgusting. Friends had joined us at the bar to have drinks. Maura, the bartender (and the one who served us) didn't come over till they had been standing there about ten minutes. This was the worst meal and the worst experience we have had dining out ever. Our bill for the salads, app, steaks, and one pepsi was $90 and we were starving when we left. People say horrible things about this place but I wanted to give Scarlett the benefit of the doubt. Now I know why. We will never return and I suggest you don't either. Mother's across the street has an amazing strip steak dinner for $24 and it is soooo much more worth your money. They have a two hour wait for a reason I guess. Next time I'll make a res...or wait.
• • •
Tana Stewart's profile photo
Tana Stewart
a year ago
This place is closed - never was good anyway
A Google User
6 years ago
With all the other wonderful restaurants on or around Virginia Place sometimes I feel Scarlet get's lost in the mix, but this is a restaurant that shouldn't be discounted because it's the new kid on the block. On an average Friday night where it might take an hour to get a table anywhere else in the area, you can just walk right into Scarlet with no reservation and most often than not be seated immediately. With a wide variety of scrumptious dishes from appetizers to entrees this contemporary treasure should be a must on your radar of places to dine!
• • •
A Google User
4 years ago
We were enjoying our dinner and were rudely asked to leave the table after paying a $300 dollar check. Food was o k. Don't waste your money , go to a real restaurant in the buff. Scarlet is a JOKE!
Rob Rash
3 years ago
The owner tried not honoring a groupon then was extremely rude and embarrassing about it in front of my date. There were fruit flies all over too.
A Google User
5 years ago
I went to dinner here for restaurant week and thought it was fabulous. We were seated upstairs and ambiance was definitely romantic. Downstairs, there is a nice bar, and seating with more lighting. Everything that I ordered was delicious, I would say this restaurant's food quality and preparation is probably one of the best in Buffalo! The waiter was knowledgeable and professional. The only cons for this place is that I would have expected it to have a larger wine list.
• • •
A Google User
5 years ago
dinner was great. it was a tuesday and it wasn't busy at all. our waitress was a delite. also, when she found out it was my birthday she also brought me a piece of cake with a candle in it. i would definately go back again. i had the pasta dish, and my sister had the sea bass. both were excellent. sandra dee
A Google User
4 years ago
Clean, sexy, beautiful people and good food accompanied by excellent service.