Thanks very much for doing these comparisons, this has helped me to decide which extruder to buy. (Going for Walnut Hollow.)
I did look at the Lucy Clay Tools Czextruder as well, but that seemed too expensive to me - for my budget. Sort of overkill.
I did however wonder if the Lucy Clay Tools discs would fit in the Walnut Hollow extruder like the ones for the Makins Extruder do?
And do the Sculpey discs fit in the Walnut Hollow extruder too?
I saw a very good Polymer Clay artist showing us his new Walnut Hollow extruder - he had been used to using a 'push-it-with-your-fingers' one - like Sculpey's and even though he was quite strong and had no arthritic problems like I do he'd found the push one rather hard on the hands and it took a long while to do enough for a certain project.Clay Extruder [Review!] made by Walnut Hollow
It was funny, cos once he'd tried the Walnut Hollow one on camera - he was actually struck dumb he was so surprised and excited by how easy it was...