Agnello's Pizza
Pizza Restaurant$$
Today 11:30 am – 10:00 pm
Contact Information
170 N Main St New City, NY 10956
170 North Main StreetUSNew YorkNew City10956
$$Pizza RestaurantToday 11:30 am – 10:00 pm
Monday 11:30 am – 10:00 pmTuesday 11:30 am – 10:00 pmWednesday 11:30 am – 10:00 pmThursday 11:30 am – 10:00 pmFriday 11:30 am – 10:00 pmSaturday 11:30 am – 10:00 pmSunday 2:00 – 9:00 pm
Google+ URL

Street View

Your Activity

Is this your business?

Manage this page
Write a review
Review Summary
24 reviews
5 star
14 reviews
4 star
3 reviews
3 star
3 reviews
2 star
No reviews
1 star
4 reviews
"Their baked spinach balls are the Best!"
"The waiters and waitresses are all so friendly and attentive."
"There is no coal fired oven."
Upload first public photo
All reviews
Janice P's profile photo
Janice P
a year ago
The food here is amazing and so is the service! The waiters and waitresses are all so friendly and attentive. The pizza is by far the best I have ever had! They also have really good fried calamari, spinach balls and you HAVE to order the lasagna when they offer it as a special! Oh and if you have never had vodka sauce on your pizza instead of tomato sauce.....try it! I come here week after week and I have never encountered any of the negative things people have said. Yes this place can get very busy but that alone should tell you how good this place is, I'd be more concerned if was empty all the time. Oh one last thing, if you base your reviews on this place because it was on "reality" tv you are dumb! All that stuff is scripted!
• • •
Will Silver's profile photo
Will Silver
5 years ago
Although I am not personally a fan of the pizza, many of my friends and family are. The entrées are excellent. I ordered one of my favorites, chicken parm, and the waiter asked me if I wanted vodka sauce instead of red. I said yes, and it was the best chicken parm I've had in a while. Highly recommend. Compared to the other Italian places in New City, this one ranks as #1.
Anthony Gonidakis's profile photo
Anthony Gonidakis
a year ago
Limp pizza, limp pizza, limp pizza. Grew up in Brooklyn and they just don't compare. Sorry but three strikes and your out.
Ronald Santini
2 years ago
The pizza here is excellent, the person that implied if you were different that the staff and patrons stared at you, is so far from the reality. I suggest that they adjust their attitude a bit and try again. Maybe that's why they just signed it google user.
Vasiliy Rodin's profile photo
Vasiliy Rodin
a year ago
If i could give it 0 stars I totally would. Regarding food itself, pizza that I always order is good, no complaints regarding pizza. BUT....... Consumers BEWARE. service is horrid and staff is non-carrying. as a personal experience, staff is rude, shows no interest in costumers. talk about customers behind their backs and I heard them talking about my minor complaint in front of me before I even had a chance to walk away. the show Restaurant Stakeout hit the nail on the head when they showcased agnello's. staff DOES NOT CARE ABOUT CONSUMERS. eat at your own risk
• • •
Michele Fuller
2 years ago
The cook mike cameout and said thanks for coming by hopes we enjoyed and allysa the waitress was so sweet, lovely and very caring and made us feel like we came to a family gathering.
Ioannis Siantos's profile photo
Ioannis Siantos
2 years ago
Great food and the staff is always very friendly. I live in North Carolina now, but I always drop in when I am visiting home. Can't wait to have real pizza again!
Chandresh Shah's profile photo
Chandresh Shah
2 years ago
Their baked spinach balls are the Best!