Cover photo
Verified local business
Paulie Gee's
Pizza Restaurant$$
Today 6:00 – 11:00 pm
6 followers|3,357,657 views
Contact Information
Map of the business location
60 Greenpoint Ave Brooklyn, NY 11222
60 Greenpoint AvenueUSNew York11222
$$Pizza Restaurant, Vegan RestaurantToday 6:00 – 11:00 pm
Monday 6:00 – 11:00 pmTuesday 6:00 – 11:00 pmWednesday 6:00 – 11:00 pmThursday 6:00 – 11:00 pmFriday 6:00 – 11:00 pmSaturday 5:00 – 11:00 pmSunday 5:00 – 10:00 pm
Napoletana inspired pizza with creative topping combinations, served in a rustic, romantic setting.
Google+ URL

See inside

Your Activity
Write a review
Review Summary
134 reviews
5 star
88 reviews
4 star
30 reviews
3 star
6 reviews
2 star
5 reviews
1 star
5 reviews
Gourmet pizzeria where the wood-fired pies are topped with unusual, locally sourced ingredients.- Google
"...Fior di Latte, Italian Tomatoes, Parmigiano Reggiano, Mike's HOT Honey..."
"I really love the wood fire oven."
Featured by Zagat
NYC's Best Cheap Eats
, and 2 other lists
See more from Zagat
Scrapbook photo 2
Scrapbook photo 3
Scrapbook photo 4
Scrapbook photo 5
Scrapbook photo 6
Upload public photo
Have them in circles
6 people
Macha Jewelry Studio's profile photo
Paul J. Froggatt's profile photo
Jenna Hauser's profile photo
William Sorrentino's profile photo
MAX Sound and Security's profile photo
Nixdo's profile photo
All reviews
Tommy Prime's profile photo
Tommy Prime
a month ago
We went there with friends because of great review by FB Gothamist. After waiting 30min utill open we got in to a crowded wood finish, not great atmosphere restaurant. Staff friendly, cant complain. The worst were pizzas. Very excited we ordered 3 kinds.. and I must say they werent good, dough was not crispy, sauce ok, but toppings looked like thrown on top with total mess, very little and bad quality. I say dont go there when its packed, nobody cares about food they serve you just trying to get rid of you asa you eat your meal. Bad experience, OVERRATED!!!
• • •
MAX Sound and Security's profile photo
MAX Sound and Security
2 months ago
The Hellboy is the best pizza EVER! The decor and feel of this nondescript (a bit decrepit on the outside actually) building in Greenpoint is incredible. Extremely inviting. After being seated in the back, myself and my 2 companions ordered up some of the house red. Now, we're seated in the far back... first visit ever. Paulie Gee himself makes it a point to recommend the hellboy! He spent the last hour that they were open telling us his story as we ate the best pizza ever Even tunred us on to several shots of his homemade limoncello.. Wish I could give it a 6.
• • •
James Henry's profile photo
James Henry
3 months ago
Now this is what pizza should taste like! It's not your traditional Italian pizza, but who ever said it was? Yes, the wait can be long and the music can sometimes be loud, but every time I've been here, I haven't been disappointed.
Devon Petley's profile photo
Devon Petley
8 months ago
Makes the top 10 of New York pizza for good reason. Well worth the wait time. And Paulie himself is such a nice guy. Best pizza in north Brooklyn.
Caroline Bergmann
a week ago
Like fornino in my opinion. But here you can get great vegan pizza! Okay often you have to wait but even an hour is worth it. They carry on with a wood old-fashioned style in there. It's comfy. Staff is helpful. But sometimes "Old Pauly" likes to come around and talk to his guests in a little drunk way..
James Hansen's profile photo
James Hansen
3 months ago
Beautiful ambience. Wretched service. Mediocre vegan pizza.
Luke Hansen's profile photo
Luke Hansen
7 months ago
After hearing that Paulie Gee's was recently named the best pizza in NYC by Zagat, I figured we better try it. The fact that they have a large vegan selection made Paulie Gee's even more attractive. Although we couldn't tell it was open from the outside, we ventured in hoping the pizza was as good as advertised. The first thing you'll probably notice about Paulie Gee's is that it is loud. I am fine with higher decibels but it was ridiculously loud for a restaurant. A bar is one thing; I would like to talk without screaming while eating dinner. We ordered some vegan pizzas but when we requested that they hold off on the olive oil this seemed to provide some consternation. They went along with our request and were nice enough about it but it didn't seem to thrill them either. We were surprised by this considering they are so willing to provide food for people with varying food preferences. The pizzas were very good but I wouldn't say they were better than other pizza places we've been to. Because I can get equally good pizza closer to home I doubt we'll make a habit of going here but I am glad we tried it.
• • •
Sue R
8 months ago
I went to try out their pizza because of the rave reviews. I was so totally disappointed that I am angry about it. The pizza is not italian at all. The pizza I was served was so totally soggy that I threw out most of the pie. It is unacceptable to serve wet, soggy pizza in NYC. The restaurant also has no traditional spices for the top of the pizza. Do not go there if you have an ounce of italian blood in you, because it will curdle.


Have them in circles
6 people
Macha Jewelry Studio's profile photo
Paul J. Froggatt's profile photo
Jenna Hauser's profile photo
William Sorrentino's profile photo
MAX Sound and Security's profile photo
Nixdo's profile photo

Paulie Gee's hasn't shared anything with you.

People are more likely to share with you if you add them to your circles.