Cover photo
Verified local business
Goodfellas Brick Oven Pizza
Today 11:30AM–12AM
Contact Information
Map of the business location
144 Orchard St New York, NY 10002
144 Orchard StreetUSNew YorkNew York10002
$$Restaurant, Italian Restaurant
Italian Restaurant
Pizza Restaurant
European Restaurant
Today 11:30AM–12AM
Friday 11:30AM–12AMSaturday 11:30AM–12AMSunday 11:30AM–10PMMonday 11:30AM–10PMTuesday 11:30AM–10PMWednesday 11:30AM–10PMThursday 11:30AM–10PM

Goodfella’s Brick Oven Pizzeria and Restaurant specializes in wood fired pizzas as well as gourmet pasta dishes and homemade desserts. Being around for a number of years Goodfellas has put a significant mark on the pizza industry by winning numerous awards. The Goodfella “experience” is all about having a warm and inviting environment where you can enjoy award winning pizza and hearty homemade pastas and most importantly friendly service.

Google+ URL

Street View

Write a review
Review Summary
24 reviews
5 star
11 reviews
4 star
11 reviews
3 star
1 review
2 star
No reviews
1 star
1 review
Semolina-dough brick-oven pizzas are offered as well as Italian staples at this casual spot.- Google
"The pizza was New York style with a golden brown crust."
"Amazing brick oven Italian style pizza."
Scrapbook photo 2
Scrapbook photo 3
Scrapbook photo 4
Upload public photo
Your Activity
All reviews
Lady Ace's profile photo
Lady Ace
3 weeks ago
Lapin and I came here the other night for dinner. We got the Buffalo Chicken pizza ($14), meatballs ($5 for 3), cheese calzone ($10) and a couple of sodas ($3 each). Our waiter, Mike was the only waiter but he was very nice and attentive. The pizza was good, but didn't have bruschetta like the one in Staten Island. This pizza is also smaller, think along the lines of a medium size Domino's pizza. Two people can share one pizza but it would leave each person satiated but still peckish. The cheese calzone (mozz and ricotta) was very generous portion and it tasted on par with other pizza places. The meatballs were just okay. They were decently sized but Lapin said they tasted like meatballs you can get at Costco. All in all, we had a great server and the food was good. On a side note, look at the black chalkboard when you sit down because they have specials Sunday - Thursday. On Sundays, you get free cannolis, Wednesdays its free draft beer with a pizza purchase and on Thursday its half price house wine bottles.
• • •
Arthur A's profile photo
Arthur A
3 weeks ago
Great small spot. Whole in the wall. Amazing brick oven Italian style pizza
Kelsey Robinson's profile photo
Kelsey Robinson
4 months ago
The best pizza I've every had. Really nice atmosphere, really nice staff as well.
vince laliberte's profile photo
vince laliberte
a year ago
The actual restaurant isn't the nicest atmosphere but the food is great. Possibly my favorite cannoli around. The filling has some vanilla in it, which is my favorite. Definitely worth stopping in for a meal.
Ken Harrison's profile photo
Ken Harrison
2 months ago
I got the meatball sub and the homemade chips, my boyfriend got a pepperoni pizza. The pizza was New York style with a golden brown crust. He ate 3/4 and took the rest home. He enjoyed it. My sub was delicious, with fresh, well sized meatballs and a tasty marinara. Although the chips were made there--and lord knows I was drooling for them--they were only okay. The chips are supposed to have rosemary on them, but you couldn't really tell. Next time I'll get the waffle fries instead. The place was clean and the waiter was young, friendly and attentive. It's worth going back, just don't get too excited about the chips.
• • •
Luis NY's profile photo
Luis NY
5 months ago
Nice place and good pizza, another groupon that was worth the price! The bruschetta is very BIG and messy, I had to eat the bread separated from the vinaigrette, if you can fit it in your mouth, it will dismantle when you bite total mess... They got our first pizza wrong, but they made it right and left the wrong one at the table and provided us with the right one after that... we end-up taken 1 pizza back to home.. another great Sunday breakfast...
Ken Sweet's profile photo
Ken Sweet
a year ago
Very good food. wife got the brick oven steak and I got the chicken good fellas was awesome. little pricey but good. If you like connoli get them here not Ferrara's way better.
Ian Schwartz's profile photo
Ian Schwartz
a month ago
great lunch special!


Goodfellas Brick Oven Pizza hasn't shared anything with you.

People are more likely to share with you if you add them to your circles.