Profile

Cover photo
Darren Whitelaw
Works at Department of Planning and Community Development
Attended Harvard University
128 followers|37,152 views
AboutPostsPhotosVideosReviews

Stream

Darren Whitelaw

Shared publicly  - 
 
Darren Whitelaw originally shared:
 
[To those following my Gplus stream, please ignore the following post. I am using the text below for a training exercise]

STORY 1
Engagement, Empowerment and Transparency: Publishing Crime Statistics using Online Crime Mapping
_By Spencer Chainey and Lisa Tompson_ http://policing.oxfordjournals.org/content/early/2012/03/14/police.pas006.abstract

Since December 2008, police forces in the UK have published crime statistics using an online crime mapping tool (www.police.uk). The drivers behind this were to help improve the credibility and confidence that the public had in police-recorded crime levels, address perceptions of crime, promote community engagement and empowerment, and support greater public service transparency and accountability. This article captures the policy rationale behind this initiative, and draws together the research evidence on its impact. We argue that many of the original objectives relating to improving engagement and empowerment have yet to be realized, poor cartographic discipline has led to misinterpretation and confusion, and that the initiative instead has primarily become a tool for promoting political transparency. We suggest that future focus should be on improving the quality and cartographic visualization of the published information alongside the integration of social media functionality to enrich local dialogue on crime issues.

STORY 2
Does Digital Crime Mapping Work? Insights on Engagement, Empowerment & Transparency
By Patrick Meier via http://irevolution.net/2012/06/18/crime-mapping-insights/

In 2008, police forces across the United Kingdom (UK) launched an online crime mapping tool “to help improve the credibility and confidence that the public had in police-recorded crime levels, address perceptions of crime, promote community engagement and empowerment, and support greater public service transparency and accountability.” How effective has this large scale digital mapping effort been? “There continues to be a lack of evidence that publishing crime statistics using crime mapping actually supports improvements in community engagement and empowerment.” This blog post evaluates the project’s impact by summarizing the findings from a recent peer-reviewed study entitled: “Engagement, Empowerment and Transparency: Publishing Crime Statistics using Online Crime Mapping.” Insights from this study have important implications for crisis mapping projects.

The rationale for publishing up-to-date crime statistics online was to address the “reassurance gap” which “relates to the counterintuitive relationship between fear of crime and the reality of crime.” While crime in the UK has decreased steadily over the past 15 years, there was no corresponding in the public’s fear of crime during this period. Studies subsequently found a relationship between a person’s confidence in the criminal justice system and the level to which a person felt informed about crime and justice issue. “Hence, barriers to accurate information were one of the main reasons why the reassurance gap, and lack of confidence in the police, was believed to exist.”

A related study  found that people’s opinions on crime levels were “heavily influenced by media depictions, demographic qualities, and personal ex- perience.” Meanwhile, “the countervailing source of information—nationally reported crime statistics—was not being heard. Simply put, the message that crime levels were falling was not getting through to the populace over the cacophony of competing information.” Hence the move to publish crime statistics online using a crime map.

Studies have long inferred that “publically disseminating crime information engages the public and empowers them to get involved in their communities. This has been a key principle in the adoption of community policing, where the public are considered just as much a part of community safety as the police themselves. Increasing public access to crime information is seen as integral to this whole agenda.” In addition, digital crime mapping was “seen as a ‘key mechanism for encouraging the public to take greater responsibility for holding the local police to account for their performance.’ In other words, it is believed that publishing information on crime at a local level facilitates greater public scrutiny of how well the police are doing at suppressing local crime and serves as a basis for dialogue between the public and their local police.”

While these are all great reasons to launch a nationwide crime mapping initiative online, “the evidence base that should form the foundations of the policy to pub- lish crime statistics using crime maps is distinctly absent.” When the project launched, “no police force had conducted a survey (robust or anecdotal) that had measured the impact that publishing crime statistics had on improving the credibility of these data or the way in which the information was being used to inform, reassure, and engage with the public.” In fact, “the only research-derived knowledge available on the impact of crime maps on public perceptions of crime was generated in the USA, on a small and conveniently selected sample.”

Moreover, many practitioners had “concerns with the geocoding accuracy of some crime data and how this would be represented on the national crime mapping site (i.e. many records cannot be geographically referenced to the exact location where the crime took place) [...] which could make the interpretation of street-level data misleading and confusing to the public.” The authors thus argue that “an areal visualization method such as kernel density estimation that is commonly used in police forces for visualizing the geographic distribution of crime would have been more appropriate.”

The media was particularly critical of the confusion provoked by the map and the negative media attention “may have done long-term damage to the reputation of crime statistics. Whilst these inaccuracies are few in number, they have been high profile and risk undermining the legitimacy and confidence in the accuracy of all the crime statistics published on the site. Indeed, these concerns were highlighted further in October 2011 when the crime statistics for the month of August appeared to show no resemblance to the riots [...].”

Furthermore, “contemporary research has stressed that information provision needs to be relevant to the recipients, and should emphasize police responsive-ness to local issues to chime with the public’s priorities.” Yet the UK’s online crime map does not “taylor sub-neighborhood reassurance messages alongside the publishing of crime statistics (e.g., saying how little crime there is in your neighborhood). General messages of reassurance and crime prevention often fail to resonate. This also under-scores the need for tailored information that is actively passed on to local communities at times of heightened crime risk, which local residents can then use to minimize their own immediate risk of victimization and improve local public safety.”

In addition, the presentation of “crime statistics on the national website is very passive, offering little that will draw people back and keep them interested on crime trends and policing in their area.” For example, the project did not require users to register their email addresses and home post (zip) codes when using the map. This meant the police had no way to inform interested audiences with locally relevant crime information such as “specific and tailored crime prevention advice regarding a known local crime issue (e.g. a spate of burglaries), directly promoting messages of reassurance and used as a means to publicize police activity.” I would personally argue for the use of automated alerts and messages of reassurance via geo-fencing. (The LA Crime Map provides automated alerts, for example). I would also recommend social networking tools such as Facebook and Twitter to the map.

In conclusion, the authors question the “assumption that all police-recorded crime data are fit for purpose for mapping at street level.” They recommend using the Management of Police Information (MOPI) protocol, which states that “information must fulfill a necessary purpose for it to be recorded and retained by the police.” MOPI would “help to qualify what should and what should not be published, and the mechanism by which it is published.” Instead of mapping everything and anything, the authors advocate for the provision of “better quality information that the public can actually do something with to minimize their risk of victimization, or use as a basis for dialogue with their local policing teams.” In sum, “the purpose of publishing the crime statistics must not lose sight of the important potential it can contribute to improving the dialogue and involvement of local communities in improving community safety, and must avoid becoming an exercise in promoting political transparency when the data it offers provides little that encourages the public to react.”
1
Rob O'Brien's profile photothemediapod aka Ross Monaghan's profile photo
2 comments
 
I can't work out if your request was for real, or the sneakiest hook ever Darren.
Add a comment...

Darren Whitelaw

Shared publicly  - 
 
[Watch] this great video using kinetic typography (AKA animated infographics) revealing statistics on the use of Facebook. Unfortunately, no reference to the original source for the statistics (beyond the original OnlineSchools.org infographic) but a nice way of letting motion graphics do the talking.
1
Add a comment...

Darren Whitelaw

Shared publicly  - 
 
Just delivered a presentation on "Government 2.5" at the Smart Government conference in Canberra. Conference opened by Senator Kate Lundy (how do we clone her?) followed by the First Assistant Secretary from AGIMO Glenn Archer.

I was asked to talk about Government 2.5, and give a report card on the progress of Gov2.0 to date. Hope I didn't upset too many in the audience, because I said it was way too early talking about Gov2.5 because we were probably only at Gov1.6.

Said despite some promising policy commitments, and a handful of public servants and govt agencies doing great stuff, the average bureaucrat faced a swamp of red tape and barriers to collaboration, openness and empowerment.

My scorecard:
Collaboration: B
Openness C-
Empowerment: E
Possibility: A+

Take a look at my slides, Do you think I was being too harsh, or not tough enough. This is the first time for most of this material, so welcome your feedback!
1
Add a comment...

Darren Whitelaw

Shared publicly  - 
 
Fantastic report out this week by KPMG on social media for business (another group of accountants demonstrating they are embracing modern communication; Deloitte anyone?).

Shows more than half of Australian businesses are playing catch-up when it comes to social media, well behind China and the US. Outlines a six-step process for considering before starting out.

It's a good report, and has been written in a way that will be non-threatening to the C-suite executive audience. It's nice they reinforce what I've banging on for so long now... the first step is to listen. But their thinking hasn't yet matured into understanding that just having a free (or paid) social media monitoring tool is not enough -- you have to involve humans in the process. It's not like Google Analytics where you can set-and-forget. Social media monitoring, to be effective, must involve humans. Either your own, or outsource -- but don't rely on a computer to make sense of what they are crawling... it's a waste of time and provides dumb insights.
1
1
Christoph Hewett's profile photoDarren Whitelaw's profile photo
2 comments
 
Doh! [Slaps forehead]. Rookie mistake; posted before I pasted in the link. Fixed now, thanks.
Add a comment...

Darren Whitelaw

Shared publicly  - 
 
New website launched today by @Justice_Vic that gives people their chance to have a say on Victoria's sentencing regime. Uses opensource Joomla platform, YouTube video and survey tool to collect feedback. More than 1000 people have contributed in the first day... a great result so early on. What are your thoughts?
2
Add a comment...
Have him in circles
128 people
Susan Manniche's profile photo
themediapod aka Ross Monaghan's profile photo
Geoff Barbaro's profile photo
Vince Colaci's profile photo
Mark Elliott's profile photo
Matthew Nette's profile photo

Darren Whitelaw

Shared publicly  - 
 
Wonderful decision-support flowchart helping step you through the questions you need to ask before posting something to that social media profile...
1
Add a comment...

Darren Whitelaw

Shared publicly  - 
 
Some great data in here on gov2.0 adoption across Australia...
1
Add a comment...

Darren Whitelaw

Shared publicly  - 
 
Wow! Thanks to a buzz on LinkedIn my slides on internal social media just trended! Nearly 1,000 extra views! http://bit.ly/qNf2uV #in
1
Darren Whitelaw's profile photoNicholas Gruen's profile photo
2 comments
 
Nicholas -- yes, planning on sticking around! ;-) Plenty of work still to be done, so much more to be done! Thanks for the +1 and the RTs.
Add a comment...

Darren Whitelaw

Shared publicly  - 
 
Preparing a talk to a government department on the merits of gov2.0. the challenge is they aren't really convinced this whole social media thing is for them, because they don't have any direct contact with citizens. (They are like a public service equivalent of business-to-business communicators).

Aside from the obvious efficiencies of staff productivity increases through an internal enterprise social network (like Yammer), I'm looking for examples of other government agencies using social media for G2G. Ideas anyone?
1
Darren Whitelaw's profile photoMick Doherty's profile photo
3 comments
 
incentives are important - aim to engage with high quality web community. You are right the quality was not the greatest, but the key is getting fresh / new ideas ... If you only get one good idea out of the project - could be useful for future concepts? Like your thinking, the next phase of Gov social media will be very interesting
Add a comment...

Darren Whitelaw

Shared publicly  - 
 
Kudos to @SAPoliceNews- first coppers in #au to have a mobile web site: http://www.sapolicenews.com.au/ Great job to @brownlow and team!
2
Add a comment...
People
Have him in circles
128 people
Susan Manniche's profile photo
themediapod aka Ross Monaghan's profile photo
Geoff Barbaro's profile photo
Vince Colaci's profile photo
Mark Elliott's profile photo
Matthew Nette's profile photo
Work
Employment
  • Department of Planning and Community Development
    Director Communicaiton, 2012 - present
  • Strategic Counsel - 360m
    Strategy Advisor, 2011 - 2012
  • Victorian Department of Justice
    General Manager, Corporate Communication, 2009 - 2011
  • Victorian Department of Justice
    Manager, Online Communication & New Media, 2008 - 2009
  • Victorian Department of Justice
    Strategic Adviser, Office of the Executive Director, 2007 - 2008
  • Victorian Department of Justice
    Manager, Media & Communication, 2006 - 2007
  • Victorian Department of Justice
    Deputy Manager, Public Affairs, 2004 - 2006
  • Victorian Department of Justice
    Communications Coordinator, Justice Operations, 2003 - 2004
  • City of Greater Dandenong
    Communication Adviser, 1998 - 2003
  • Fresco
    Marketing Manager, 1997 - 1998
  • Impact!
    Account Director, 1993 - 1998
Basic Information
Gender
Male
Story
Tagline
Social media junkie, Gov2 groupie, geek translator, PR professional, cultural spectator, speaker, proud dad. Views are my own.
Education
  • Harvard University
    Kennedy School of Government, 2010 - 2010
  • Australia & New Zealand School of Government
    Public policy and administration, 2006 - 2008
  • University of Melbourne
    Executive Masters, Public Administration, 2006 - 2008
  • RMIT University
    Bachelor of Arts (Public Relations), 1992 - 1995
Great food. Wonderful hangover cures. (We weren't hung over but can imagine how it would be good!). Tried the granola and vanilla yoghurt, big breakfast, and the Eggs Benedict (of course!). All delicious. Smoky baked beans really yum. They also know how to make coffee. We'll be back!
Public - 7 months ago
reviewed 7 months ago
1 review
Map
Map
Map