Cover photo
Verified local business
extra fancy
Seafood Restaurant$$
Today 6:00 pm – 4:00 am
3 followers|1,057,386 views


extra fancy

Shared publicly  - 
Visit Extra Fancy every Tuesday as we offer Lobster Roll Tuesday!

You get our CT Style Butter Poached Lobster Roll, Fries and an ice cold Budweiser for just $20 bucks!! 

Our kitchen is open 'til 3:30am, 7 nights a week.
Add a comment...
Have them in circles
3 people
Vaporizers & Tobacco | Smoke Shop's profile photo
Contact Information
Map of the business location
302 Metropolitan Ave Brooklyn, NY 11211
302 Metropolitan AvenueUSNew York11211
$$Seafood Restaurant, Cocktail Bar
Seafood Restaurant
Cocktail Bar
Oyster Bar Restaurant
Today 6:00 pm – 4:00 am
Monday 6:00 pm – 4:00 amTuesday 6:00 pm – 4:00 amWednesday 6:00 pm – 4:00 amThursday 6:00 pm – 4:00 amFriday 6:00 pm – 4:00 amSaturday 12:00 pm – 4:00 amSunday 12:00 pm – 4:00 am

At Extra Fancy, we celebrate the East Coast, from New England to below the Mason Dixon. While we concentrate predominantly on the fresh fish and shellfish culled from the long stretch of bountiful seashores of the Northeast, we are also drawn inland to the wonderful fruit, vegetable, and dairy farms that scatter the Northeastern geography.  Farm and Sea to Table.

We also celebrate a good drink. We have a world class American Style Beverage Program that has a little something for everyone. Whether it’s a glass of wine or cider from a local vineyard, some classic tincture from days of old, or a boozy concoction from one of our talented barkeeps, we are sure you will find us Extra Fancy.

Google+ URL

Street View

Your Activity
Visit this place
Make a free reservation with OpenTable
Find a table
Write a review
Review Summary
24 reviews
5 star
11 reviews
4 star
8 reviews
3 star
4 reviews
2 star
No reviews
1 star
1 review
Crab-shack-chic eatery serving New England-style seafood plates, creative cocktails & craft beer.- Google
"Fun menu, great vibe, comfortable setting- Highly recommend the Deviled Eggs."
"For me, I would come back just to sit at the bar and talk to the bartenders."
Featured by Zagat
NYC's Best Seafood Shacks
See more from Zagat
Scrapbook photo 2
Scrapbook photo 3
Scrapbook photo 4
Scrapbook photo 5
Scrapbook photo 6
Upload public photo
Have them in circles
3 people
Vaporizers & Tobacco | Smoke Shop's profile photo
All reviews
Debbie Parker's profile photo
Debbie Parker
4 months ago
Nice atmosphere , great food. Wish they had fried oysters, but most enjoyed .
Lamarr Hawkins's profile photo
Lamarr Hawkins
11 months ago
The one downside is the place doesn't open until 5 (or maybe 6?) plenty of times I've been in Williamsburg during the day craving their oysters and they're closed. But once you get there and sit outside on their back patio it'll be worth it. Delicious food and a good price and in a fun environment.
Baron Drumm's profile photo
Baron Drumm
8 months ago
Not the worst, but sadly it's just another overpriced imitation of an actual new england style eatery.
Stephanie Gross's profile photo
Stephanie Gross
11 months ago
Fun menu, great vibe, comfortable setting- Highly recommend the Deviled Eggs.
Darien D's profile photo
Darien D
11 months ago
Always a great time here at Extra Fancy. From their fantastic lobster rolls and sweet potato fries to their enticing cocktails, this place is a definitely a must visit for any successful night out. With a kitchen that is open until 3:30 one can always stop off for a delectable snack and quick night cap. With an amazing staff you are guaranteed to have a good time, and if you don't then something is probably just wrong with you. Keep up the great work everyone Extra Fancy you guys are doing it right.
• • •
Jesse Card's profile photo
Jesse Card
2 weeks ago
There's no other bar in the Tri-State area I'd rather be at.
Catherine Allen's profile photo
Catherine Allen
a year ago
So I stumbled upon this bar once and realized I had coupon for a free drink here so, obviously, I had to stop. Upon entering, I was greeted by extremely friendly bartenders, helpful (but busy) waitresses and a cute ambiance that made me think small town Texas meets casual NYC. If you have no idea what I mean, think: wooden floor, walls, bar, table tops plus ultra fancy drinks + booths (which are rare in texas bars). Unsure of what to order next, we tell the bartender "two bourbons and one gin drink" and he proceeds to blow our minds with what he serves. 110% for his creativity, thoughtfulness and attention during such a busy bar hour. I wish I remembered his name :( **KUDOS TO YOU BARTENDER ON MONDAY, SEPT 16** There are a bunch of 2 top tables right when you walk in and larger tables/booths in the back. I recommend coming her for a date/small group function rather than a large group. For me, I would come back just to sit at the bar and talk to the bartenders. They're fun, drink-spertised (yes, i just made that up) and it's not too loud that you can't carry on a conversation. THEN AGAIN: it was a MONDAY night. Regardless -- can't wait until we meet again, Extra Fancy.
• • •
Owen Iverson's profile photo
Owen Iverson
2 years ago
2 for 1 brunch drinks for starters. Had some amazing deviled eggs for easter appetizers. But the honey butter on the pancakes was mind melting. Throw a little compote on there and you'll wonder why you didn't order two servings. (The breakfast sandwich sausage is also really tasty)