Cover photo
Verified local business
Five Mile Stone
Today 11AM–4AM
Contact Information
Map of the business location
1640 2nd Ave New York, NY 10028
1640 2nd AvenueUSNew YorkNew York10028
BarToday 11AM–4AM
Thursday 11AM–4AMFriday 11AM–4AMSaturday 10AM–4AMSunday 10AM–4AMMonday 11AM–4AMTuesday 11AM–4AMWednesday 11AM–4AM
Google+ URL

Street View

Write a review
Review Summary
45 reviews
5 star
18 reviews
4 star
15 reviews
3 star
7 reviews
2 star
2 reviews
1 star
3 reviews
Upscale American comfort food & craft cocktails are prepared in this homey frontier-chic tavern.- Google
"The food - lobster roll - was delicious!"
"Also, the homemade potato chips were bland at best and burnt scraps at worst."
Scrapbook photo 2
Scrapbook photo 3
Scrapbook photo 4
Scrapbook photo 5
Scrapbook photo 6
Upload public photo
Your Activity
Visit this place
Make a free reservation with OpenTable
Find a table
All reviews
Paul Feshchenko's profile photo
Paul Feshchenko
2 weeks ago
The balcony looked like a great time on a hot summer day, and I sure am glad I stopped in. The bar upstairs was more then okay with me just having a pint and people watching, and now I've been back more then once. I was treated to Superfuzz Blood Orange Pale (Elysian Brewing Company from Seattle) on my last trip, and was excited/surprised to get a taste of home on tap!
Viktor Milev's profile photo
Viktor Milev
a month ago
Good bar for casual food and or drinks. Upstairs area I liked more, especially the barkeeper there. Chap with a random accect, but sure shot skills behind the bar
Niklas Holmström's profile photo
Niklas Holmström
a month ago
A next level brass band called Lucky Chops play every Thursday night at 9pm and they are out of this world. Unbelievable talent!
RJ DiBella's profile photo
RJ DiBella
a month ago
Great food, unique atmosphere!
Davin Davis's profile photo
Davin Davis
2 months ago
Nice atmosphere...nice selection of drinks and food. Like the upstairs balcony view in the summertime. Staff was friendly. Prices are a little Upper East Side fare, but still manageable. All in all, a good spot to hang out for drinks.
Erlinda Brent's profile photo
Erlinda Brent
8 months ago
I had a wonderful experience there. I had a rough two weeks, and was throwing my own "pity party." Having just had surgery, I couldn't climb the stairs to the second floor. The host kindly set up a tall table with a tall chair (as opposed to a stool) for my comfort. The food - lobster roll - was delicious! The service - my waiter was Robbie - was very friendly and efficient. I also had an order of raw oysters and dessert - raisin bread pudding with caramel sauce!!! No reason at all to complain. I had a great meal. I had a nice time. I felt a lot better, and cannot wait to return.
• • •
Costa Michailidis's profile photo
Costa Michailidis
a month ago
College bar, two floors good variety of main stream music. Cheap booze. Nothing too crazy. Plenty of people dancing on weekends.
Giancarlo Trentini's profile photo
Giancarlo Trentini
3 weeks ago
Has a big variety of both food and beer selections.


Five Mile Stone hasn't shared anything with you.

People are more likely to share with you if you add them to your circles.