Cover photo
Verified local business
Mario's Trattoria
Italian Restaurant$$
Contact Information
Map of the business location
This place has closed. Not true?
493 9th Ave New York, NY 10018
493 9th AvenueUSNew YorkNew York10018
(212) 239-3394
$$Italian Restaurant, Pizza Restaurant
Italian Restaurant
Pizza Restaurant
Mario's Trattoria in New York serves up brick oven pizza and pasta a la Napoletana. From date nights to happy hours, Mario's Trattoria has delicious Italian food, appetizers, desserts and drinks.
Google+ URL

See inside

Write a review
Review Summary
16 reviews
5 star
8 reviews
4 star
5 reviews
3 star
No reviews
2 star
No reviews
1 star
3 reviews
Small, relaxed Italian restaurant with brick-oven pizzas, pastas & seafood in a warm setting.- Google
"I would definitely recommend the muscles marinara they were so tender and juicy."
"Our waiter was so accommodating to our dietary restrictions."
Scrapbook photo 2
Scrapbook photo 3
Scrapbook photo 4
Scrapbook photo 5
Scrapbook photo 6
Upload public photo
Your Activity
All reviews
charles j's profile photo
charles j
2 years ago
don't understand how anyone can give this 5 stars. I guess their idea of a good Italian restaurant is The Olive Garden. We both agreed that, for the most part, they obviously opened up cans and arranged the contents on the plate. To give just one example, the black olives in the salad weren't even decent, much less good quality olives. They were those rubber black olives sold in cans that you can buy at CVS., as was pretty much everythtng else in the salad, and in everything else we ordered. We unfortunately bought a internet deal, which is why we wound up here (we wouldn't have noticed it otherwise), and even with the discount, it wasn't worth what we paid Actually, I wouldn't pay anything for this junk as I can open cans and arrange the contents on plates at home, and it would be better than this. UPDATE: I figured it out. People who gave this place good reviews MUST be thinking that they are reviewing Mario's on Arthur Avenue in the Bronx, a totally different restaurant. There's no other explanation.
• • •
Hugo Borja's profile photo
Hugo Borja
2 years ago
The place is in a very nice area. I visit NYC several times a year first place i go is Mario's. The linguini and clam sauce, cream of broccoli soup and their brick oven pizza is feast. The happy hour mango margaritas are excellent I drink too and I'm ready to go for the night. I wish they were open and Marios in Los Angeles
A Google User
5 years ago
The food was delicious. Unfortunately it wasn't what I ordered and the requested bread arrived after the wrong appetizer. The waiter opened by delivering fried rather than grilled calamari apologizing and proactively offering to take half off the dish since they were now out of calamari (which he forgot to do on 'the bill). My entree was wrong too, with the waiter again apologizing and for some reason bringing me a piece of 'free' chicken after we'd finished eating. My date did receive the entree she ordered, but we passed on dessert not knowing what I should order to get what I wanted. Bathroom was very clean and spacious. Today's price for annoyance: $39
• • •
A Google User
5 years ago
Great place ,friendly people. Great food. Will definitely return when were in NYC again.
Randy S's profile photo
Randy S
2 years ago
The service here was amazing. Our waiter was so accommodating to our dietary restrictions. The food was great. I would definitely recommend the muscles marinara they were so tender and juicy. The atmosphere was calm, relaxing and romantic. The prices were extremely reasonable and the portions were generous. I would definitely recommend Marios
Mike Peterson's profile photo
Mike Peterson
2 years ago
My first NY Pizza experience and it was pretty good. I wasn't sure what to expect, but was happy we stopped. It was the middle of the afternoon and we were the only one in the place so the service was good. One thing I thought was sort of strange was the fact when I asked for a beer, they checked a dorm-sized refrigerator to tell me they had one of one brand and a couple of another. So if you're thirsty for beer with your pizza, I'd suggest elsewhere.
A Google User
4 years ago
Visted with my daughter from the Netherlands. very friendly people, we got table at the window, but left after 2 mintues: the smell was horrible.
A Google User
4 years ago
Great food, great price, not huge, would have trouble bringing big groups there, but worth it!


Mario's Trattoria hasn't shared anything with you.

People are more likely to share with you if you add them to your circles.