NHL 2004 was the first game I bought; It was awesome. I wish I never gave it away, especially since they don't even sell old Gamecube games anymore. NHL 10-14 were great, especially 11 and 14. 15 is good; the graphics are great, the gameplay is pretty good, although the goalies and defensive AI are terrible. I didn't expect many game modes and detailed commentary with it being the first game on new consoles. NHL 16 looks like will be better.