Blue Marble Ice Cream's profile photo
Blue Marble Ice Cream
Ice Cream Shop$
Today 12:00 – 9:00 pm
Contact Information
186 Underhill Ave Brooklyn, NY 11238
186 Underhill AvenueUSNew York11238
$Ice Cream ShopToday 12:00 – 9:00 pm
Monday 12:00 – 9:00 pmTuesday 12:00 – 9:00 pmWednesday 12:00 – 9:00 pmThursday 12:00 – 9:00 pmFriday 12:00 – 9:00 pmSaturday 12:00 – 9:00 pmSunday 12:00 – 9:00 pm
Google+ URL

See inside

Your Activity

Is this your business?

Manage this page
Write a review
Review Summary
49 reviews
5 star
22 reviews
4 star
19 reviews
3 star
4 reviews
2 star
1 review
1 star
3 reviews
Upscale ice cream parlor in Prospect Heights serving scoops made with locally sourced ingredients.- Google
"This is my favorite ice-cream store."
"I can't get enough of their sea salt caramel."
Upload public photo
All reviews
Crystal Henderson's profile photo
Crystal Henderson
a month ago
Good ice cream and excellent service. I've hand blue marble's ice cream over five times now and I hate to admit it but I'm not as excited about their ice cream as I use to be. It's still good, but not 'wow! That was awesome!'. I had their apple cider sorbet today and it was tasty but on the icy side. My all time favorite is the burnt sugar, but they didn't have it so I opt for coffee. The coffee ice cream was really good, but didn't satisfy me like the burnt sugar does. Hope they have it next time! Can't wait to get my hands on that caramel/nutty goodness! The girl working there is a sweetheart, she was nice enough to give me the rest of the chocolate chip when there wasn't enough for one full scoop. And I swear the servings in this blue marble is bigger than the others.
• • •
Richardo Charles's profile photo
Richardo Charles
5 months ago
The service is good. I tried to apple cider sorbet which was good. The right amounts of tart and sweet. A lil pricey but justified for the uniqueness. In the afternoon they run out of croissants. Didnt get to try the coffee will have to do that another time. The ambience is chill nice for chill convo, do work, kid friendly and date friendly.
Christopher Westendorf's profile photo
Christopher Westendorf
10 months ago
Best Ice cream in New York .PERIOD. I recently took a stroll here for their seasonal pumpkin ice cream which is the perfect amount of sweetness and vanilla bean-esque pumpkin pieces. And in typical fashion I get here and contemplate ordering a new flavor that I didn't even consider to exist in such perfection. So on this occasion I got to sample the pistachio almond which is a transcendent marriage of subtle sweetness a must have for those that still think vanilla is their favorite flavor. However, what made me change my order was the mexican hot chocolate with its gazillion pieces of chocolate in it. And now I am left telling every stranger that the secret to fall is one scoop pumpkin ice cream and one scoop mexican hot chocolate.
• • •
Maryann Yin's profile photo
Maryann Yin
10 months ago
So so delicious! I can't get enough of their sea salt caramel. I love their golf ball size portions. The servers are always really nice. I also love that they seem to be a fairly green company with a feel-good mission statement.
Jean Carman's profile photo
Jean Carman
a month ago
DELICIOUS organic ice cream and sorbets but be ready to spend a pretty penny. Had the blueberry pomegranate sorbet and vanilla ice cream and was thoroughly satisfied with the combination...the sorbet was light and refreshing (altho a bit too sugary) and went well with the creamy richness of the vanilla ice cream. Will definitely be stopping by next time I visit Prospect Park or the Botanical Gardens nearby. OHH and they also have a cart at the Brooklyn Flea Market on Saturdays. Expect a really really long wait tho (even when the line doesn't look long).
• • •
Kate Kosche's profile photo
Kate Kosche
6 months ago
Ice cream here is absolutely delicious! I have never had a flavor I didn't like. Another hint- when the line at Ample Hills down the block is a mile long, this place has ice cream that is every bit as superb without the insane line.
Danny France's profile photo
Danny France
3 months ago
The sea salt caramel after the sweet cream is a yes ! and the cone doesn't get soggy :}
Quinn White
2 months ago
Best coffee ice cream!! My favorite