Original Italian Pizza
Pizza Restaurant$$
Today 11:00 AM – 9:30 PM
Contact Information
5 W Pennsylvania Ave Stewartstown, PA 17363
5 West Pennsylvania AvenueUSPennsylvaniaStewartstown17363
$$Pizza RestaurantToday 11:00 AM – 9:30 PM
Wednesday 11:00 AM – 9:30 PMThursday 11:00 AM – 9:30 PMFriday 11:00 AM – 10:30 PMSaturday 11:00 AM – 10:30 PMSunday 12:00 – 9:30 PMMonday ClosedTuesday 11:00 AM – 9:30 PM
Google+ URL

Street View

Your Activity

Is this your business?

Manage this page
Write a review
Review Summary
14 reviews
5 star
6 reviews
4 star
2 reviews
3 star
No reviews
2 star
1 review
1 star
5 reviews
"Staff super friendly - pizza, wings and chicken parm spaghetti best around."
"The owners and workers at Original Pizza are rude."
"Amazing family-owned local business."
Upload first public photo
All reviews
Quentin Lapp
in the last week
Absolutely awful service and treated like garbage! We decided to dine in on a slow monday night and ordered soup, salad and a cheeseburger sub. After about 25 minutes our server brought the soup out which was obviously frozen and microwaved, and way too salty. Another 20 minutes went on and the server was nowhere to be found so we took the full bowl of soup back to the counter and informed them it was extremely salty and we did not wish to eat it. We also requested that the salad be boxed and sub wrapped as we had now spent 45 minutes sitting down without our main dishes and no explanation or apology for the delay. Our server did come back to us with the bill for our food we havent received and said out food was being wrapped up for us. We decided to up to the counter and ask if the soup could be removed from the bill since it was not edible and that our wait was now 45 minutes. At this time the the owner got an attitude towards us and said that we didn't wait 45 min and said told us that he we weren't going to get our food and that he no longer wants our business! It's unbelievable that he would get so offended by our claim that his store bought frozen soup was bad and that he no longer wanted our business. While the subs are good (I've actually been a takeout customer quite a few times prior) be prepared to be treated like dirt if something goes wrong with the order. I'm glad that some other customers were at the counter and witnessed his sheer lack of respect to us as human beings and customers.
• • •
Ken Pfeiffer
2 years ago
Staff super friendly - pizza, wings and chicken parm spaghetti best around..
A Google User
4 years ago
You want bland with that? I don't know what's worse the food or the atmosphere. The crust was like cardboard and tasted like it too. The old guy behind the counter was rude and made multiple nasty comments to me about some of the other customers. And finally.....we get like the Pittsburgh Steelers. Could you fit any more cheesy tacky Steeler knick knacks to in the store? I doubt it...
A Google User
4 years ago
The owners and workers at Original Pizza are rude. When you call to place an order they act as it they are doing you the favor. I have lived in the area for 5 years and would order there at least once a week, but got tired of their horrible customer service. I understand they are Italian, but that is not excuse to treat your customers like crap. I would rather go to a place that has average food and great customer service. Hey OIP, learn some Customer Service skills and maybe I will consider giving you my $. I doubt if will happen anytime soon since my sister just order from there and they treated her the same way.
• • •
Pat Clemens's profile photo
Pat Clemens
8 months ago
Amazing family-owned local business. Food is delicious and there is a great selection on the menu. Staff is always friendly. Enjoyable atmosphere.
Sheenna Parr's profile photo
Sheenna Parr
3 years ago
If you want to give your money to rude people, be my guest. The subs are pretty good but over priced at 8+, the pizza is so so. The customer service is horrrrriible. Way too much competition around for you guys to be rude.
A Google User
6 years ago
Crust is thin and crisp, sauce is a little light but acceptable, toppings are quite sufficient. Salads were crunchy. Garlic bread was tasty. For a local Mom + Pop pizza joint, it's a great option. We're glad to be in the neighborhood of Original Pizza. ---- thought I'd write a review while I'm waiting for my order.:-)
A Google User
3 years ago
I love this place. Fresh baked bread. Pizza sause has the perfect flavor and the cheese on the pizza is stringy. So delicious!!!!