Cover photo
Verified local business
Carmine Street NY Pizza and Mussels
Pizza Restaurant
Today 11:30AM–10PM
1 follower|267,019 views
Contact Information
Map of the business location
3422 Del Prado Blvd Cape Coral, FL 33990
3422 Del Prado BoulevardUSFloridaCape Coral33990
Pizza Restaurant, Seafood Restaurant
Pizza Restaurant
Seafood Restaurant
Live Music Venue
Italian Restaurant
Today 11:30AM–10PM
Wednesday 11:30AM–10PMThursday 11:30AM–10PMFriday 11:30AM–10PMSaturday 12:30–10PMSunday 12:30–10PMMonday 11:30AM–10PMTuesday 11:30AM–10PM
Best Known New York Style Pizza and Mussels In SW Florida! In-door & outside patio dinning at affordable prices. Live Entertainment Thursday - Sunday. Offering the NFL package during football season.
Google+ URL

Street View

Your Activity
Write a review
Review Summary
19 reviews
5 star
7 reviews
4 star
5 reviews
3 star
2 reviews
2 star
No reviews
1 star
5 reviews
"I recommend 2 dishes...The veal sorrentino and the Grandma Pizza."
"Authentic Italian food is hard to find in WILL find it here!"
"Dirty expensive little bugs flying on pizza waitress was awful."
Scrapbook photo 2
Scrapbook photo 3
Scrapbook photo 4
Scrapbook photo 5
Scrapbook photo 6
Upload public photo
Have them in circles
1 person
Kimberly Artessa's profile photo
All reviews
Abbe E. Forman's profile photo
Abbe E. Forman
3 months ago
Hands down the best pizza in Cape Coral. LOVE the chicken parm pizza. Pasta dishes (especially mussels or clams) are also outstanding. Written 7 months ago. Something has changed since then, sadly. Last 2 times, not so great. First a couple of months ago, mushy over-salted pasta and mussels. Then yesterday, Chicken Parm Pizza was just not the same. Dough was different, sparse amount of chicken parm....what changed? Please go back to how it was 7 month ago when I originally wrote the review....
• • •
Response from the owner - 11 months ago
Thank You Abbe!! We Are So Happy To Hear That You Think We Have "Hands Down The Best Pizza In Cape Coral" Our Chicken Parm Pizza Is One Of My Personal Favorites Too!! Thank You For Sharing Your Five ☆ Review With Google! We Hope To See You Soon!! Have A Wonderful Weekend! ~Cheers Lauren Marie, Partner Carmine Street N.Y. Pizza & Mussels 3422 Del Prado Blvd. South Cape Coral, FL 33904
Denis Janousek
8 months ago
I ordered 3 18 inch pizzas which came to over $63. When I got them home they were barely 16 inches. When I called up to complain, the first time, I was hung up on. The second time I was transferred to a guy who abruptly told me, "There's nothing I can do about it now. The next time you come in you can have $10 off a cheese pizza". I guess they won on both accounts because there is no way I am going back. You want real NY pizza in Cape Coral? Go to JimJim's on Del Prado.
• • •
Rick Rosato's profile photo
Rick Rosato
a year ago
I started to go here months ago and then Lauren took over and just great, what an improvement I wish I could go more but when ever I do it's been great. I tell everyone it is one of the best places around for Good food and great people. Keep up the good work for a GREAT SPOT in Cape Coral it's a "10" Good Luck, Rick New report on this GREAT restaurant It is even better, if that is possible. I was in this business for 20 years up North, Pa so I know GOOD ITALIAN foods and went to N Y C to Carnine Street I swear they are the same people??? Good Luck and keep it up The Cape really need s you.
• • •
Response from the owner - 2 years ago
Thank You Rick For Your Four Star Review! We Look Forward To Seeing You Soon!! Best Regards ~ Lauren & Pete
Kimberly Artessa
a year ago
This is my favorite place to eat in Cape Coral Fl. I have been there a few times and each time is always perfect. The food is amazing! Authentic Italian food is hard to find in WILL find it here! I recommend 2 dishes...The veal sorrentino and the Grandma Pizza. They are famous in Cape Coral for both their pizza and the mussels..will be trying them next. The people who own this place have done a great job. I love the outdoor patio and there is always live music on the deck. The service has always been spot on! You will not be disappointed if you go here...I PROMISE
• • •
Response from the owner - 11 months ago
Thank You Kimberly!! We Appreciate You Sharing Your Review With Google!
Jennifer Bixler's profile photo
Jennifer Bixler
6 months ago
Pizza was great! Had to wait quite awhile for our food but the waitress was super nice and apologetic...brought us some breadsticks on the house to help ease our hungry bellies 😀 atmosphere was great..very italian! Good beer selection. Loved it and will be back!
Ann Narber
11 months ago
Didn't expect much and wasn't disappointed. The pizzas are far from Italian and the service is even worse. They should check into their employees better. One was caught in a phony check cashing ring. I'm praying she didn't take my bank card number.
Response from the owner - 4 months ago
nice cynthia
Karen Rios
9 months ago
Dirty expensive little bugs flying on pizza waitress was awful. Distgustimg we couldn't even eat the pizza. 60 bucks for 2 pies n some drinks. So gross. Do not go here the health department should visit.
Max Garcia
6 months ago
Food was bad service was horrible


Have them in circles
1 person
Kimberly Artessa's profile photo

Carmine Street NY Pizza and Mussels hasn't shared anything with you.

People are more likely to share with you if you add them to your circles.