Cover photo
Verified local business
Prima Pizza
Pizza Restaurant$$
Today 11AM–9PM
Contact Information
Map of the business location
252 Main St Cornwall, NY 12518
252 Main StreetUSNew YorkCornwall12518
$$Pizza Restaurant, Italian RestaurantToday 11AM–9PM
Tuesday 11AM–9PMWednesday 11AM–9PMThursday 11AM–9PMFriday 11AM–10PMSaturday 11AM–10PMSunday 12–9PMMonday 11AM–9PM
Google+ URL

Street View

Write a review
Review Summary
45 reviews
5 star
29 reviews
4 star
6 reviews
3 star
4 reviews
2 star
2 reviews
1 star
4 reviews
Long-standing family-owned pizzeria serving brick-oven pizzas & Italian fare in a modest cottage.- Google
"Good food but very slow service."
"Absolute worst service I've ever had for a small place that wasn't too busy."
Scrapbook photo 2
Scrapbook photo 3
Scrapbook photo 4
Scrapbook photo 5
Scrapbook photo 6
Upload public photo
Your Activity
All reviews
Emmet Spiegel's profile photo
Emmet Spiegel
in the last week
I don't go to Cornwall often but I have been here once before a couple of years ago. Back then it was delicious, good sauce, and good crust. Today I went there and it was terrible. I just got a couple of slices of pepperoni pizza to go (which I ate within 6 min of getting it) and it was bad. The crust was very hard, and thin. Next was the whole slice had no taste. I didn't taste anything when I was eating it. I also felt like there was no sauce or at least I didn't see/taste any. It felt like I was eating nothing. I had a good experience last time but this time was a joke. They probably got new chefs.
• • •
Nicholas Baldwin's profile photo
Nicholas Baldwin
3 months ago
Ordered a grandma pie and an order of wings for delivery. Was told it would be 25-30 minutes. An hour and fifteen minutes later I called wondering why I haven't received my order. I was told that they made a mistake with taking down my address and the delivery driver couldn't find my place. I asked why they didn't call to correct the mistake so they could deliver the food and they couldn't give me an answer , they just said that they would get my order out to me immediately. Not even five minutes later my doorbell rings ( which makes it very apparent that they didn't cook new food ) and the delivery guys gets an attitude about me asking why they didn't cook new food. This is my first delivery experience with primas and will be my last. I order a lot of food from primas and always pick it up but their food quality recently has been inconsistent and sub par. I will never order from them again. There are plenty of pizza places around and I'm sure they would appreciate the business. P.S Your restaurant needs a good deep cleaning.
• • •
Paul Paquin's profile photo
Paul Paquin
a month ago
Best pizza place in Orange County! Their sandwiches and pizza is amazing.
Yunicorn SoFab's profile photo
Yunicorn SoFab
6 months ago
Good food but very slow service. We had to ask for water 3 times and the place wasn't even that full. Then we waited 10 MINUTES FOR PIZZA!
Beatrice Bianchi's profile photo
Beatrice Bianchi
2 weeks ago
Amazing service, amazing pizza. We were visiting the small town and I saw this place was recommended. We ask for a XL veggie for two and we couldn't eat even half!! The pizza was amazingly tasty , real flavors, and fresh veggies!!! I absolutly recommend this place!!! SO GOOD FOOD
Marc Cuomo's profile photo
Marc Cuomo
5 months ago
The hodge podge of junk, and clutter thrown all over the place doesn't make up for the crappie food.... not impressed.
Aaron Geisel's profile photo
Aaron Geisel
a year ago
Real New York Pizza! The price is a little higher that you average pizza place, but it's well worth it. They have so many choices for their piazza that it's hard to pick a favorite. No other place can really compare, especially not that $1 slice stuff. Did I mention that they ship anywhere in the US?
Mario Brooklyn's profile photo
Mario Brooklyn
7 months ago
It's a cool place. Like going back to 1955. The workers could be nicer. It's just pizza no reason to act stressed out all the time.


Prima Pizza hasn't shared anything with you.

People are more likely to share with you if you add them to your circles.