Michael's Frozen Custard's profile photo
Michael's Frozen Custard
Dessert Shop$
Today 11:00 am – 10:30 pm
Contact Information
2531 Monroe St Madison, WI 53711
2531 Monroe StreetUSWisconsinMadison53711
$Dessert ShopToday 11:00 am – 10:30 pm
Monday 11:00 am – 10:00 pmTuesday 11:00 am – 10:00 pmWednesday 11:00 am – 10:00 pmThursday 11:00 am – 10:00 pmFriday 11:00 am – 10:30 pmSaturday 11:00 am – 10:30 pmSunday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Google+ URL

Street View

Your Activity

Is this your business?

Manage this page
Write a review
Review Summary
32 reviews
5 star
12 reviews
4 star
12 reviews
3 star
6 reviews
2 star
1 review
1 star
1 review
Local chain serving frozen custard, burgers & hot dogs in a casual, old-school setting.- Google
"The frozen custard is super smooth and creamy."
"The sundaes are also a must-try, like the cookie dough and peanut butter ones."
Scrapbook photo 2
Upload public photo
All reviews
Raymond Yingling's profile photo
Raymond Yingling
a month ago
Over priced... Way over priced...
Dylan Peterson
10 months ago
This is awful. I found a couple fly's in my ICe cream and the owner was grabbing me. Not Recommend.
Candy Bell
2 years ago
Love the flavors, have gone there for years, but saw the ads on tv and thought "oh my goodness, if that was supposed to entice me to go there... they have another think coming!" I'd never walk through the door. Those are the most awful ads I have ever seen! Where did you get these people? If those faces represented the flavors...ugh! I'd never get that flavor.... get some help with your ads! please! I'm loosing my appetite for them! Its like you picked the most sleazy people you could find and then made them say "what they are". ICK! For your own sake...get rid of those ads! Sorry to say this, but, its true.... and I love your custard, but those ads are just so unappetizing!
• • •
Joel Rogness's profile photo
Joel Rogness
2 years ago
Try to get the custard right as it's coming out of the machines. Get the vanilla. Plain. With maybe a few pecans or cashews.
Matt Lynch's profile photo
Matt Lynch
2 months ago
Great custard, and a lot of choices. Seating outside is great. Prices are a but steep, though - $5 minimum for a small custard.
Mike Schmidt's profile photo
Mike Schmidt
2 years ago
Wow! A friend suggested we have lunch at Michael's yesterday (3-11-13). We were there at noon and immediately noticed a conspicuous lack of customers. We were the only two people in the place. We sat there for 30 minutes and not one other customer arrived. We both had the same thing: a cheeseburger basket (with "onion petals") and a malt. While the malts were pretty good, the cheeseburgers were mediocre at best. For two baskets and two malts...$26.09!!!! That's right! Twenty-six dollars and nine cents! If you want a decent (but expensive) malt, Michael's is ok. If you want a decent cheeseburger... go somewhere else.
• • •
Jacinth Sohi's profile photo
Jacinth Sohi
3 years ago
The frozen custard here is amazing--by far high on the list of the best frozen custard I've ever had anywhere in the country. The standard chocolate and vanilla are always available and delicious, and then there's a flavor of the day. Oreo is particularly good. The sundaes are also a must-try, like the cookie dough and peanut butter ones. And if you have a dog, make sure to check out the "K-9 custard." The food is good (think burgers and hotdogs). Pretty standard, but what's unique and especially delicious are the fried cheese curds. In the summers, the Monroe street location is also known for its walk-up counter. Grab your custard and then walk through the park in the back to eat by Lake Wingra. Michael's is definitely a Madison tradition and staple year-round. Whenever I come back to visit, I always make sure to stop at Michaels at least once.
• • •
Ian Gatley's profile photo
Ian Gatley
4 years ago
In my opinion the best ice cream available anywhere. The ingredient list scares me as someone who gravitates toward natural foods, but it's so tasty who really cares.