Cover photo
Verified local business
Goodfellas Pizza
Takeout Restaurant$
Today 11:00 am – 9:45 pm
2 followers|45,557 views
Contact Information
Map of the business location
1718 Hylan Blvd Staten Island, NY 10305
1718 Hylan BlvdUSNY10305
$Takeout Restaurant, Pizza DeliveryToday 11:00 am – 9:45 pm
Monday 11:00 am – 9:45 pmTuesday 11:00 am – 9:45 pmWednesday 11:00 am – 9:45 pmThursday 11:00 am – 9:45 pmFriday 11:00 am – 9:45 pmSaturday 11:00 am – 9:45 pmSunday 11:00 am – 9:45 pm
Google+ URL
Have them in circles
2 people
Write a review
Review Summary
39 reviews
5 star
27 reviews
4 star
5 reviews
3 star
4 reviews
2 star
No reviews
1 star
3 reviews
Established spot for basic brick-oven pizzas, with a few unique varieties like Clam Pie Oreganata.- Google
People talk about brick oven, fresh mozzarella, vodka pie, wood fired oven and rigatoni alla vodka sauce
Upload first public photo
Your Activity
Reviews from around the web
All reviews
lindsay shapiro's profile photo
lindsay shapiro
reviewed 9 months ago
Let me tell you something, I am addicted to pizza, but this is not pizza. This is artwork and food from the gods. I ordered several pies for delivery with a bill totaling well over $100. The food was extremely hot, still tasted as if they just cooked it, the delivery driver made sure we had utensils and such and even brought our food in and placed it on the table for us. I gave a generous $40 tip for the courtesy and service I received. We have dined in at Goodfella's plenty of times and love it. There is a pizza place up the street from us, but we will always order from Godfella's. A MUST HAVE IF IN STATEN ISLAND!!!!! Don't get stuck with mediocre Italian food, stick with the best.
• • •
Brianna Slyman
reviewed 9 months ago
What a wonderful experience it was eating at Goodfella's Restaurant. The staff was very friendly and attentive. The Lasagna was delicious and served in such a big portion, leaving me with more than enough to bring home and enjoy again later on. Their food and service is always great ! I will defineitly be going back there to enjoy more of their delicious Italian cuisine
Chrys Gee
reviewed 11 months ago
My boyfriend came for lunch Friday and there were 4 people behind the counter completely ignoring him. He waited for service for about 15 minutes and was overlooked. Then a Caucasian man came in and he was served right away. Since Goodfellas Pizza had a problem acknowledging this Black customer, he took his GREEN money elsewhere. All paying customers should be treated the same. SHAME ON YOU GOODFELLAS!!!
rob zorcik's profile photo
rob zorcik
reviewed 9 months ago
love this place! the staff is amazing, and Andy is jus the best guy around! I love their Vodka Pie and Chicken Francese. I could drink the Francese sauce... I would bathe it in... the food is great, and dining there is always a joy.
Lauren Polvere
reviewed 9 months ago
I tried Goodfellas for the first time a few months ago and was pleasantly surprised. The drinks were delicious, the food was delicious, and the staff was so nice and attentive. The first time I went I ordered a beer and a vodka pie. My beer was ice cold and the vodka pie was excellent. I actually ordered another pie to take home with me to have my family try. I have been back a handful of times since and my experience is just as pleasant every time.
N Pi
reviewed 9 months ago
I ordered lunch for delivery for my office yesterday afternoon for 35 people. It was a last minute impromptu business lunch, and I was afraid that my order would not be able to be accommodated on such short notice. I was more than impressed with how quickly our food arrived, and how delicious everything was! We will absolutely be ordering from Goodfellas again.


Have them in circles
2 people

Goodfellas Pizza hasn't shared anything with you.

People are more likely to share with you if you add them to your circles.