Cover photo
Verified local business
Italian Restaurant$$
Contact Information
Map of the business location
674 US-206 Bordentown, NJ 08505
674 U.S. 206USNew JerseyBordentown08505
$$Italian Restaurant, Pizza Restaurant
Italian Restaurant
Pizza Restaurant
Google+ URL
Your Activity
Write a review
Review Summary
24 reviews
5 star
13 reviews
4 star
7 reviews
3 star
No reviews
2 star
2 reviews
1 star
2 reviews
"Tomato pies are usually consistent, ask for extra sauce."
"There is no way it could be confused with a mushroom."
"Their tomato pie is incredible."
Upload first public photo
All reviews
Katy Ciampa's profile photo
Katy Ciampa
4 months ago
Antipasto was very good. I enjoyed that it was chopped. Pizza is an authentic tomato pie. That means there is very little cheese & if you go for toppings there is just enough. The sauce is on the sweet side for my liking, but the crust is crispy without being overdone.
2 years ago
I used to eat at this pizzeria frequently, I even had a large party there. The food was always good but today I found some 2 inch black brush bristles in my mushroom pizza. When I called to inform Palermo's, the owner called me a liar and said it was my hair. I have long curly red hair. When he offered to make me a new pizza I declined because I was grossed out and asked for my money back. I eventually convinced him to give me a refund and he sent a driver to pick up the pizza. The owner called me back several minutes later and said "that's just how the mushrooms are", with no apology. I will never eat there again. He was rude and their were brush bristles baked into the pie. There is no way it could be confused with a mushroom. So, if you don't mind some "extras" on your pizza, this is your place.
• • •
Bhavya Phogat's profile photo
Bhavya Phogat
3 months ago
Christopher Pryce
a year ago
Great food and service
Gary Edelstein's profile photo
Gary Edelstein
11 months ago
Their tomato pie is incredible. I come from Cherry Hill often. Consistently the perfect pie!
Response from the owner - 11 months ago
Thanks for the great review!
Michael Grainger's profile photo
Michael Grainger
a year ago
We USED to go here regularly because of the good tomato pies, I just had delivery of a meatball parm sub- frozen processed meatballs... The cheap ones from bottom dollar taste better then this. What a shame
Mike Jones
3 years ago
Food is usually good, sauce is fantastic though pizza is usually TOO crispy, place could use a remodel though.
Betty Stefanelli
a year ago
Tomato pies are usually consistent, ask for extra sauce.


Palermo's hasn't shared anything with you.

People are more likely to share with you if you add them to your circles.