Cover photo
Verified local business
Italian Restaurant$$
Contact Information
Map of the business location
674 US-206 Bordentown, NJ 08505
674 U.S. 206USNew JerseyBordentown08505
$$Italian Restaurant, Pizza Restaurant
Italian Restaurant
Pizza Restaurant
Google+ URL

Street View

Write a review
Review Summary
24 reviews
5 star
13 reviews
4 star
7 reviews
3 star
No reviews
2 star
2 reviews
1 star
2 reviews
"Tomato pies are usually consistent, ask for extra sauce."
"There is no way it could be confused with a mushroom."
"Their tomato pie is incredible."
Upload first public photo
Your Activity
All reviews
Katy Ciampa's profile photo
Katy Ciampa
2 months ago
Antipasto was very good. I enjoyed that it was chopped. Pizza is an authentic tomato pie. That means there is very little cheese & if you go for toppings there is just enough. The sauce is on the sweet side for my liking, but the crust is crispy without being overdone.
2 years ago
I used to eat at this pizzeria frequently, I even had a large party there. The food was always good but today I found some 2 inch black brush bristles in my mushroom pizza. When I called to inform Palermo's, the owner called me a liar and said it was my hair. I have long curly red hair. When he offered to make me a new pizza I declined because I was grossed out and asked for my money back. I eventually convinced him to give me a refund and he sent a driver to pick up the pizza. The owner called me back several minutes later and said "that's just how the mushrooms are", with no apology. I will never eat there again. He was rude and their were brush bristles baked into the pie. There is no way it could be confused with a mushroom. So, if you don't mind some "extras" on your pizza, this is your place.
• • •
Christopher Pryce
a year ago
Great food and service
Betty Stefanelli
a year ago
Tomato pies are usually consistent, ask for extra sauce.
Gary Edelstein's profile photo
Gary Edelstein
9 months ago
Their tomato pie is incredible. I come from Cherry Hill often. Consistently the perfect pie!
Response from the owner - 9 months ago
Thanks for the great review!
Michael Grainger's profile photo
Michael Grainger
a year ago
We USED to go here regularly because of the good tomato pies, I just had delivery of a meatball parm sub- frozen processed meatballs... The cheap ones from bottom dollar taste better then this. What a shame
Mike Jones
3 years ago
Food is usually good, sauce is fantastic though pizza is usually TOO crispy, place could use a remodel though.
Ed Voz's profile photo
Ed Voz
3 years ago
Awesome tomato pies!


Palermo's hasn't shared anything with you.

People are more likely to share with you if you add them to your circles.