Profile

Cover photo
Suyang Liu
Works at Oregon State University
94 followers|112,820 views
AboutPostsPhotosYouTube+1's

Stream

Suyang Liu

Shared publicly  - 
 
 
Apple and Privacy, Just like Google

One thing that really annoys me about Apple is how it is using its reality distortion field to twist the message about privacy. Only a week ago, Tim Cook said this:

”I’m speaking to you from Silicon Valley where some of the most prominent and successful companies have built their businesses by lulling their customers into complacency about their personal information. They’re gobbling up everything they can learn about you and trying to monetize it. We think that’s wrong. And it’s not the kind of company that Apple wants to be. So we don’t want your data. “

“We don’t think they’re worth have your email or your search history or now even your family photos data-mined and sold-off for God-knows-what advertising purpose.”

And then, at the WWDC Keynote, they announced the new Apple News app. What does this app do? Well… I quote from their product page:

”The stories you really care about. The more you read, the more personalized the News app becomes, refining the selection of stories delivered to your screen so they are relevant to you. Easily share articles with others and save them to read offline. News stays on top of the stories you’re interested in. So you can, too.”

So… how can Apple learn what it is that you are interested in, and deliver that information to you without tracking people?

Granted, at the keynote, Craig Federighi also displayed a slide pointing out the privacy features for Apple News. These included:

Anonymous
Not associated with Apple ID
Random identifier
Not linked to other Apple services
Not shared with third parties
You’re in control

Clearly pointing their fingers at Google.

First of all, this is a weird way of doing things. Not having the news targeting data linked to your Apple ID means that it can’t be used across devices. Your iPhone and your iPad won’t know which is which. And if you buy a new iPhone, you will have to teach your news app all over again from scratch.

What’s the point of that? That’s not a privacy issue. That’s just terrible UX. 

It’s also not linked to other Apple services, meaning that Apple won’t be able to show you news from where you are in Apple Maps, compared to your personal interests. That seems like a weird limitation, and again, poor UX.

Finally, we have the “Not shared with third parties”.

It’s so annoying. Why, because neither is Google
It’s the same thing. Google isn’t sharing anything. No advertiser sees any user data, ever.

It’s like when you advertise in a newspaper. You pay the newspaper to display the ad in the right section. But as an advertiser, you have no clue as to who it reaches. You just know it has been targeted right.

That’s how Google Adwords work.

More to the point, tools like Google Analytics work almost exactly like Apple News. It too is anonymous, not associated with people’s Google IDs, uses randomized identifiers, not linked to other Google services, nor is it shared with third parties. 

Granted, you can add aggregated demographic data to this as well, in which case it does link to Google Adwords, but it’s still anonymous, and you have no way to track that on an individual level.

I get so annoyed by this. Apple is promoting itself as the savior of privacy online, bashing Google and others with vaguely misleading statements along the way.

That said, there are genuine concerns about privacy as well.

For instance, there is a real problem around the whole industry of data brokers. These are companies who are buying and selling user data to the highest bidder, from anywhere. For instance, when you go into Target to buy a t-shirt, they will end up knowing your age, income, social status, your food preferences, and sometimes even your medical history. 

Similarly, when I then go into another store a week later, then they suddenly also know that I bought a T-shirt.

That’s not right. That’s terrible! It should be illegal for companies to buy/sell/share their data. (and indeed it is in my country).

If I go into a store, whatever I do and whatever I buy in this store should be kept between the store and me. It is a massive violation of trust when that store sells this information to others. 

That is a real privacy problem.

This also extends to websites. If I visit a newspaper, what I read should not be bought and sold by other companies. That is an interaction purely between me and the newspaper. 

The newspaper can target me all it wants based on the interaction that has taken place between us. But when I then visit another newspaper, they shouldn’t be allowed to know what topics of articles I read elsewhere. 

This is the whole concept of privacy. 

Apple is doing this right because what it tracks is kept within Apple. Which is good. And that is also how Google works. Whatever you do on Google, stays with Google.

But the rest of Apple PR bashing about privacy is just that, PR.

Look at Apple Music, which will be available on iPhone, iPad, Mac, Windows and Android. Here you can create your own playlists, follow artists, like, comment and share things.

The only way they can do that is by linking your actions to your Apple ID. How else would it be able to show you the playlist on your phone that you just created on your Mac? How else would it be able to keep track and notify you across devices when there is an update to something you engage with?

So, Apple is using your data, just like everyone else. As Apple says on their site (about Apple Music)

“Enjoy recommendations handpicked just for you or explore everything they find that’s new and noteworthy in the world of music. It’s all yours.”

“Even with a library this massive, finding the music you’re looking for is easy. The intelligent search engine remembers whether you’re looking in your local library or the Apple Music library, so you get results from the place you expect. You can also browse music you’ve looked for previously, and see what searches are trending.”

”Tell us what you like. Discover something you’ll love. When you tell us the genres and bands you’re into, we’ll bring you more suggestions from our experts who know and love music. They’re out at the big shows and the small gigs, combing scenes to bring you emerging artists and deep cuts, and creating playlists that feel like they’re coming from a friend who knows exactly what you want to hear.”

”The more you listen, the better we hear you. When we make recommendations, we consider what you tell us you like. Whether you love a song or not, your feedback helps our suggestions get better and better. But we also pay attention to what you actually play. So if you’re an EDM fan with a secret affinity for big band music, we’ll find you more stuff that swings. And drops the beat.”

How is this not exactly the same as what Google is doing with their services?

Oh, you say. But Apple isn’t using this to sell advertising. Really? 

Here is the description of ad targeting for the Apple News app:

”Monetization of Apple News Format content is simple with iAd, Apple’s advertising platform. When monetizing with iAd, you’ll have access to iAd’s segmentation capabilities, so your advertisers can reach just the right audience within your content. iAd targeting is accurate and scalable, and based on registration data from hundreds of millions of validated Apple users.”

And here is what Apple writes about iAds in Apple Music:

"Apple Music brings the world's largest community of music fans together all in one place with an expertly curated subscription music service, the world's most popular digital music store, and free streaming radio, including the world's first global live station, Beats 1, all in one app. iAd provides marketers with exclusive access to Apple Music listeners."

"Radio on Apple Music brings the best of iAd to the best in music programming: only iAd has the targeting capabilities borne from Apple user insights, and the integration into Apple hardware and software to bring commercial messages to life across iPhone, iPad, iPod touch, and Apple TV, as well as on Mac and PC."

"Advertisers can reach Apple Music listeners with audio and video ads while they're listening to Radio, and also while they're shopping, playing, and reading in hundreds of thousands of other apps."

And it will even be integrated into Apple Wallet:

iAd helps marketers push Offers to iPhone
Offers allow marketers to put customized, dynamic messages directly into the Wallet that's built into every iPhone - and accessible via Apple Watch.

Marketers can reach loyal customers with specific messages that reflect the customers' interests, or convert a new customer by presenting a reason to try something new.

Because iPhones are location-aware, so are Offers. Offers can be updated to present new messages dynamically, and also triggered with updates specific to a store location via iBeacon. Offers can also be targeted by age, gender, geography, or custom segments built by the marketer, and updated as often as required to keep messages fresh.

So, when Apple said that it was anonymous, not associated with Apple ID, uses a random identifier, nor linked to other Apple services, that apparently only applies to all the things that aren’t iAds. Because with iAds, they can accurately target your content to millions of Apple users.

Again, just like Google.

Add that Apple recently announced they will support ad blockers in Safari on the iPhone, thus blocking newspapers from earning money that way. While iAds does work in their own news app... well...

This is why I get so annoyed when I hear Apple’s PR machine talk about privacy. First, we have Tim Cook saying: “They’re gobbling up everything they can learn about you and trying to monetize it. We think that’s wrong. And it’s not the kind of company that Apple wants to be. So we don’t want your data.“

Then they launch three new services; Apple Waller, Apple Music and Apple News, both featuring individual targeting, tracking and tailoring ... and all directly integrated into iAds.

I call shenanigans. 

Both Apple and Google track what you do. Both companies use that information. And both companies that keep information within themselves, thus ensuring your privacy stays intact. 

There is nothing wrong with that. In fact, as they both show, doing this creates much better products for you and me. I have absolutely no problem with Apple using data about user interests and behavior to create better products, nor do I have anything against iAds. There are plenty of examples of where it creates opportunities for people that otherwise wouldn't exist. 

But, this whole debate is a distraction. Let’s instead focus on the much more important issue of data brokers, and how data from one site is sold or given to others, thus causing one company to know what you did in another store. 

That is the real issue we should be dealing with. Not how data is used between us and the individual companies that we have chosen to be a part of.
1
Add a comment...

Suyang Liu

Shared publicly  - 
 
Sweet
 
The moon's shadow during a solar eclipse. Whoa.
1
Add a comment...

Suyang Liu

Shared publicly  - 
 
Amazing. I have huge respect for the writers.
A show for kids that aired its final season entirely online could have the power to change children’s TV forever. Yes, really.
1
Add a comment...

Suyang Liu

Discussion  - 
 
So I just sideloaded Kit Kat 4.4.1 on my Nexus 5...

Camera seems faster, but I was just so stoked that they upped the vibrate strength and fixed the music popping issue that I didn't even care :D
Go get the update guys, I'm very happy now! My only 2 issues with this phone was low vibrate and audio skipping!
4
Jonathan Killops's profile photoJames Hopkins's profile photoSuyang Liu's profile photo
Add a comment...

Suyang Liu

Shared publicly  - 
 
 
Oh man, I am dead … :)
1
Add a comment...
In his circles
144 people
Have him in circles
94 people
Lucy Watts's profile photo
Ben Brook's profile photo
Justin Ellingson's profile photo
David Ni's profile photo
Logan Picton's profile photo
Kira Loo's profile photo
Jolynn Settler's profile photo
Soo-Hyun Yoo's profile photo
yanni gong's profile photo

Suyang Liu

Shared publicly  - 
 
 
Each moment is a place…
you have never been.
by Beak 
Henley Beach, South Australia

 (2048 x 1332)
Copyright © 2015 – Beak

#HenleyBeach  #Australia
#seascape  #clouds  #colours
#Sunset  #adelaide  #shore
#SouthAustralia  #amazing
#sand  #water  #ocean  #woman
#walking  #reflections  #light
#silhouette  #Beak  #flickr

Location: Henley Beach, South Australia

Uploaded: February 25, 2015

Camera Data
Camera: Canon EOS 450D
Lens: EF-S10-22mm f/3.5-4.5 USM 
Aperture: ƒ8.0
Exposure: 1/125 s
Focal Length: 10.0 mm
ISO Speed: 100
Flash: Off, did not fire

© Beak’s website:
https://www.flickr.com/photos/42049292@N08/16713151545/

File: (9-907)

(Click on slideshow to see full resolution)
1
Add a comment...

Suyang Liu

Nexus 5  - 
 
I flashed the factory image manually without flashing userdata and used the stock recovery to wipe data, except my recovery has been at "formatting /data" for a long time. How long is this supposed to take?
1
Add a comment...

Suyang Liu

Discussion  - 
 
I have Inbox invites. First come first serve. Send me your email in a comment.
4
Ruben vanderVinne's profile photoITGeekMonkeys's profile photoKenneth Wayne Jr.'s profile photoLEONARDO DASILVA's profile photo
11 comments
 
Leopbs@gmail.com
Add a comment...

Suyang Liu

Nexus 5  - 
 
Ok guys, I think we all know you have 4.4.2 now. I got it as well. Is it really necessary for every single person to post a picture of their update?

Its not even very exciting... I get it for posting screenshots of the original kit kat release, but I'm not sure even 80% of people know what came in the 4.4.2 release
3
Add a comment...

Suyang Liu

Nexus 5  - 
 
Has anyone noticed audio popping or skipping while listening to music with headphones? I get the skips with Play Music and Poweramp and even with the audio buffer in Poweramp set to max. I've tried 2 kernels (Franco and faux123) and I have the same issue, screen on or screen off. Is this a problem with Kit Kat? 
1
Darren Mansell's profile photoFaris Fitri's profile photoRahul Saini's profile photoSuyang Liu's profile photo
11 comments
 
k thanks guys. I heard that it may be fixed in AOSP so I'm going to wait for CM or PA to test again 
Add a comment...
People
In his circles
144 people
Have him in circles
94 people
Lucy Watts's profile photo
Ben Brook's profile photo
Justin Ellingson's profile photo
David Ni's profile photo
Logan Picton's profile photo
Kira Loo's profile photo
Jolynn Settler's profile photo
Soo-Hyun Yoo's profile photo
yanni gong's profile photo
Collections Suyang is following
Links
YouTube
Other profiles
Work
Employment
  • Oregon State University
    Research Assistant, 2014 - present
Basic Information
Gender
Male
Apps with Google+ Sign-in
  • Clash of Clans
  • Boom Beach
Suyang Liu's +1's are the things they like, agree with, or want to recommend.
Wildlife Photographer of the Year 2015
www.theatlantic.com

The Wildlife Photographer of the Year competition, co-owned by the Natural History Museum and BBC Worldwide, opened for entries on January 5

How a Nickelodeon Cartoon Became One of the Most Powerful, Subversive Sh...
www.vanityfair.com

A show for kids that aired its final season entirely online could have the power to change children’s TV forever. Yes, really.

Assassin's Creed
plus.google.com

History is our playground. Join us.

BMW
plus.google.com

The official Google+ Page of BMW

Tastiera SwiftKey
market.android.com

SWIFTKEY - LA TASTIERA CHE LEGGE IL PENSIERO L'app n. 1 nelle vendite di Google Play in 58 paesi, con oltre 200.000 ***** recensioni “Incred

The Great Green Meltdown -- How Economic Arguments Against Nuclear Highl...
thebreakthrough.org

After the world's leading climate scientists called on environmentalists to support nuclear power two weeks ago, mainstream green groups wen

Droid Life
plus.google.com

No one does Android news like we do.

Android: A visual history
www.theverge.com

Google’s Android operating system has undergone a pretty incredible metamorphosis in the three short years since it debuted on the T-Mobile

A New Chapter | CyanogenMod
www.cyanogenmod.org

To all CyanogenMod users, contributors, and fans: What follows is a true story. No names have been changed to protect the guilty. Let’s take

Snapdragon 800 (MSM8974) Performance Preview: Qualcomm Mobile Developmen...
www.anandtech.com

We've written about Snapdragon 800 (MSM8974) before, for those unfamiliar, this is Qualcomm's new flagship SoC with four Krait 400 CPUs at u

CyanogenMod
plus.google.com

A community, developer-friendly Android distribution for 80+ devices

StumbleUpon.com: Discover the Best of the Web
www.stumbleupon.com

StumbleUpon is a discovery engine that finds the best of the web, recommended just for you.

The Internet Wins: SOPA Is Dead
www.google.com

Texas Rep. Lamar Smith shelved his terrible internet-destroying Stop Online Piracy Act today after the internet's week-long anti-SOPA freako

The Verge
www.theverge.com

The Verge was founded in 2011 in partnership with Vox Media, and covers the intersection of technology, science, art, and culture. Its missi

Ubuntu for Android | Ubuntu
www.ubuntu.com

A full Ubuntu desktop, on your docked Android phone. Complete desktop solution for full productivity on docked Android phones; Easy to integ

Disconnect: why Andy Rubin and Android called it quits
www.theverge.com

Last week, Google announced that Andy Rubin, co-creator and chief of Android, a job he’s held since 2005, would be stepping aside to join a

Samsung Galaxy S III review | Android Central
www.androidcentral.com

It's our definitive review of Samsung's new international flagship, the Galaxy S III.

Going the distance: driving the Tesla Model S in the real world
www.theverge.com

It’s difficult to get comfortable in the driver’s seat of a $100,000 car that isn’t yours. The particular Model S I flew to Los Angeles to s