Response from the owner - 10 months ago
We do close at midnight. We stop selling tickets at 11:30pm as we don't want to take your money and you not be able to go through all the attractions. We are sorry that you feel that you were given false information but the person you talked to on the phone can't predict when you will arrive. If you show up before the 11:30 ticket sale cutoff, you can make it through all the attractions. However, if you show up after that time you will more than likely not make it through all of them. If we sold you a ticket and you didn't make it through the attractions, you would be even more upset with us because we took your money.
As for not letting you go through after midnight (when we close) we have to enforce this because we allow unlimited entry into all of our attractions which means you can go through over and over again. If we didn't enforce this policy then customers could basically just stay as long as they wanted and we wouldn't be able to close. It is the same idea as going to an amusement park. The rides close when the park does. This info is all listed in our FAQs page.
Again, we are sorry that you had a bad experience and encourage you to try and show up earlier if you decide to come to Indy Scream Park again in the future.