I don't know to be honest would really depend what I was looking for - i.e. I know a journo isn't going to have the new android for sale in which case I'd probably go for the smudge, but also would be attracted to the play.com
listing due to the review (stars) if I was looking for a review. Really difficult landscape especially with the mix of authorship, reviews, news, product feeds... at least there's something for everyone though.
"When all else fails on a somewhat generic query: just serve one of each" seems to be the approach taken here.