Adam Liss

+

3

4

3

4

3

Are you saying the media reported something

*incorrectly*and sensationalized the story???Start a hangout

You might remember the media storm a few months ago about the schoolboy who *"solved problems posed by Sir Isaac Newton that have baffled mathematicians for 350 years"*, etc., etc.. (e.g. http://bit.ly/KPeBFk )

At the time there was no real explanation of what he had done. Now there is, courtesy of Ralph Chill and Jürgen Voigt at Dresden University: goo.gl/jh6Pr

The answer is that he produced analytic solutions for the equations of motion of a particle in fluid and under gravity, e.g. the path of a ball (modelled as a particle) travelling through the air, taking air-resistence into account.

So, did mathematicians already know how to do this? Short answer: yes.

*"The work is without doubt exceptional for a high school student and it merits the attention that it received in a national science competition for high school students... nevertheless all his steps are basically known to experts, and we emphasize that he did not solve an open problem posed by Newton."*

At the time there was no real explanation of what he had done. Now there is, courtesy of Ralph Chill and Jürgen Voigt at Dresden University: goo.gl/jh6Pr

The answer is that he produced analytic solutions for the equations of motion of a particle in fluid and under gravity, e.g. the path of a ball (modelled as a particle) travelling through the air, taking air-resistence into account.

So, did mathematicians already know how to do this? Short answer: yes.

11

1

3 comments

Adam Liss

+

3

4

3

4

3

Are you saying the media reported something *incorrectly* and sensationalized the story???

I am not surprised. Accurateness sacrificed for a good geadline...

I have to admit I don't remember a "media storm", but maybe I was just reading the wrong parts of the papers/websites/blogosphere.

Add a comment...