For years, we have been told that the social networks are worth billions of dollars exactly because they have so much data about us. They say that they can use their platforms, the logged-in user profiling and all those other factors to target people with advertising. And, for years, we have been told that this was what made them special, and that without this treasure trove of data the advertising wouldn't work as well.
The problem is that, in most cases, the returns haven't lived up to this promise. We don't really see the conversions we would expect from this amazing data. Instead, most social advertising campaigns seem to perform no better than anywhere else, with the only real difference being the format. Obviously an in-stream ad that matches the other posts (native posts) will perform better than a display advertising.
And Twitter's US Head of Ad Sales have just confirmed this. In an interview with Digiday, he revealed how they are now running ad campaigns to people coming from outside of Twitter (aka not logged in), and that these ads perform the same as Twitter's internal ads.
“We can provide the same level of deliverable results that we can with logged-in users,” Derella said.
Think about this for a moment. This means that Twitter's massive trove of profiling data isn't worth anything extra.
Granted, Twitter's non-logged in ads are not completely untargeted. They instead use Google/Doubleclick to serve those ads. As they say:
"The ads that are served to these visitors, mostly target by interest, based on the type of tweet they are viewing. For instance, during the Super Bowl, Marshawn Lynch retired from football and announced it with a tweet."
"We do have that understanding of where people are coming from. If they click on a Marshawn Lynch tweet, then we’ll make some assumptions … and we’ll develop a profile to serve the most relevant ad possible."
They are interest based.
I have written about this many times before, but lately in "The Uncertain Future of Advertising"
In this article, I talk about how targeting who people are is mostly crap compared to what people are doing. And Twitter now proves this by saying that ads for non-logged in people perform the same as for those who are logged in. They prove that the real metric for advertising is intent based to a far greater extend than being personality based.
But Digiday still goes on to say:
"Targeting is one of the biggest demands from advertisers, and the larger the logged-in user base, the better a platform knows its users."
No. Not according to Twitter.
Twitter just said that it doesn't matter if they know their users or not. As long as they know what they are doing, they can deliver just as effective ads. Who people are don't matter that much.
I have seen this for years as a media analyst. All the platforms keep talking how valuable they are because of how much data they have about you and how they can use that to target us. But when we look at the advertising results, the ad performance hasn't gone up.
I will repeat what Twitter said:
"We can provide the same level of deliverable results [with interest based ads] that we can with logged-in users [profiling based ads]."
Doesn't that make you think?
You can read Digiday's article here:
Yes, You Really Can Build Links With Twitter - Whiteboard Friday
Since Rand discussed a scammy link building tactics last week, he decided to tackle a good method that anyone can do. This week Rand has 8 t
Why Packers' Secondary Will Thrive Without Woodson
The Green Bay Packers were greeted with some unfortunate news on Monday from team doctors when they found out Charles Woodson broke his coll
Wisconsin Badger Football Tickets - Badger Football - Badger Basketball ...
Wisconsin Badgers football tickets, basketball, and hockey tickets available from a local source. Order Badger tickets online anytime for co
Search Engine Land: News On Search Engines, Sea...
Search Engine Land is a must read hub for news and information about search engine marketing, optimization and how search engines such as Go
Milwaukee Brewers Baseball Tickets - Milwaukee Baseball - Brewers Baseba...
Milwaukee Brewers tickets available from a local source. Order online anytime for pro baseball in any city.
the sixth station blog: Mortality? Family? Milwaukee Music: A Love Letter
Larry Kennedy died last week. I'm not sure what this post is about, because while it is nudged by Larry Kennedy's death, it's no
Wisconsin Badger Football Tickets - Badger Football Tickets - Badger Foo...
Badger Football Tickets are available at Ticket King, a local Wisconsin broker. Call 1-800-334-5434. No extra fees at checkout. In Milwauke
Ticket King Milwaukee: Brewers Tickets: NLDS Home Game 2 Ticket King Giv...
Brewers Tickets: NLDS Home Game 2 Ticket King Giveaway. It just might be your lucky day because Ticket King Milwaukee is giving away a pair
Ticket King Milwaukee: Milwaukee Brewers Playoffs Tickets
Milwaukee Brewers Playoffs Tickets. Milwaukee Brewers playoffs tickets The magic number for our Milwaukee Brewers to clinch the NL Central d