Cover photo
Verified local business
My Tomato Pie
Today 12–11PM
1 follower|386,206 views
Contact Information
Map of the business location
Northtown Plaza Shopping Center 3035 Niagara Falls Blvd Amherst, NY 14228
3035 Niagara Falls BoulevardUSNew YorkAmherst14228
Restaurant, Italian Restaurant
Italian Restaurant
Pizza Restaurant
Banquet Hall
American Restaurant
Today 12–11PM
Sunday 12–11PMMonday 11AM–11PMTuesday 11AM–11PMWednesday 11AM–11PMThursday 11AM–11PMFriday 11AM–12AMSaturday 11AM–12AM
Locally owned and operated, we are one of Buffalo’s Most Unique casual dinning restaurants. Our menu includes homemade soups, gourmet pizzas, calzones, pastas, sandwiches. We also serve Gluten-Free
Google+ URL
Have them in circles
1 person
сиси наскова's profile photo
Write a review
Review Summary
9 reviews
5 star
3 reviews
4 star
2 reviews
3 star
2 reviews
2 star
2 reviews
1 star
No reviews
Specialty pizzas, custom calzones & signature fried green tomatoes in simple strip-mall digs.- Google
"The hummus platter is excellent, very good taste."
"Staff was in back nd audibly fighting."
Scrapbook photo 2
Scrapbook photo 3
Scrapbook photo 4
Scrapbook photo 5
Scrapbook photo 6
Upload public photo
Your Activity
All reviews
Jeff F's profile photo
Jeff F
6 months ago
Excellent. Since moving to the north towns MTP has become our go to for delicious pizza.
Erica R's profile photo
Erica R
3 years ago
It's hard to find places that cater to the Celiac population and take it very seriously. While the owner seems to have a solid understanding of the issues surrounding gluten free eating out of medical necessity, I was less than thrilled with his customer service and "people skills" after my fiance became violently ill following a gluten free lunch over the weekend. It took a few days to get in touch with the owner (after the woman who mans the front desk accused me of trying to get a donation first!) who then tried to tell me that "those aren't usually symptoms of Celiac disease" and "I'm confident the issue isn't cross contamination" and "we had a woman whose son got sick who then called a few days later to apologize to us because it turned out to be viral". Really? Are you a doctor now too? Hmmm. I believe that he takes staff training seriously, but to try to discredit the possibility of cross-contamination in the kitchen and then say "Well, we can't even be certain it was or wasn't the food" was rather irritating. An apology and a "How can I fix this?" would have been sufficient. Wasn't impressed with the ego. Eat at your own risk if you require gluten free, but that is always the case with serious food allergies. We certainly won't be back.
• • •
Dennis P's profile photo
Dennis P
2 years ago
I've only eaten here once, but it was with a very large group of people, and we all had separate checks. Despite this, the staff was very friendly and attentive, the food was excellent, and good times were had by all. I still recommend this place to people.
A Google User
4 years ago
A great menu with a wide selection. Many different kinds of food from sandwiches to salads, calzones, pizza and pasta. Banquet facility is comfortable. This is definitely our first choice any time we mention going to lunch or dinner! Prices are reasonable and the service is usually very good. A little slow at times when the restaurant is busy, but I suppose it's a good thing that the restaurant is busy!
Elisabeth Davis's profile photo
Elisabeth Davis
8 months ago
Service terrible. Staff was in back nd audibly fighting. Just like an episode of Ramsey's kitchen nightmares. Pizza made from frozen crust. Greasy with a bad taste.
Adit Syafruddin's profile photo
Adit Syafruddin
4 years ago
Stopped by because it was on the way, and it had good reviews. I had the hummus platter and the rebecca, my friend had the spaghetti. The hummus platter is excellent, very good taste. I can't say the same about the pizza, and the spaghetti was way to watery.
2 years ago
Good but it took a long time for the food the get to my table about 45
A Google User
5 years ago
I went there for a rehearsal dinner for my sister, the food was very good! The pizza was great and the chicken parm was good. The only problem I had was the staff. The manager, or the was lady who was in charge of the banquet was very rude. She was snippy and the look on her face was snotty. I had my 3 year old with me and he was getting wild, running around and I was trying to leave. I had him next to me and she came up to him, grabbed him and started to yell in his face about him running around, right in front of me! I'm sorry, but that was my job not her's she had no right and that is why I am giving them only 2 stars. As I was leaving, I saw her yelling at a staff member in the main dining room! She should not be working there.
• • •


Have them in circles
1 person
сиси наскова's profile photo

My Tomato Pie hasn't shared anything with you.

People are more likely to share with you if you add them to your circles.