I feel I could start a flame war here, but for the sake of being semi-scientific and maybe help +Ben Zaitz
make better sense of the poll results (not claiming it, only suggesting it, okay?), I'll just point out that I see three groups of men in this thread:
(1) Men who never actually experienced joy and happiness in the presence of a true lady - a stylish, sexy, intelligent and stunning to look at woman - and actually attract her and be with her. That's why they lean to the more cynical point of view. I honestly pity them and wish them good luck because quite frankly, with that attitude of theirs, they'll need it. These guys make most of the "with makeup" choices, IMO.
(2) Men who met their perfect match and over time they realized how wrong they were about so many things, including gender biases, and actually about the whole life in general. I'm in that group. I've always have had an open mind and was rarely judging people all my life, but after I met her I finally understood how much more can I still learn. I think this group dominates the no makeup choice and is part of the minimal makeup results.
(3) Single or taken-but-not-extremely-happy men who are at least with an open mind, are natural and are expecting the same in return. These guys IMO will inevitably join group #2 and probably voted the rest of the minimal makeup results.
But hey, just my theory, pretty damn simplified too (already wrote a book, let's skip the sequel, lol). Not claiming I've deciphered it all. =)