Profile

Cover photo
Lennart Benoot
Works at Mincko
Attended Ghent University
Lives in Halle
428 followers|409,587 views
AboutPostsPhotosYouTubeReviews

Stream

 
#iseewinniethepoohs in my paella
1
frits 1's profile photoPieter - Jan Uyttersprot's profile photoHans Desmet's profile photo
3 comments
 
hehe, weer paddenstoelen gaan plukken in 't hallerbos...
 ·  Translate
Add a comment...

Lennart Benoot

Shared publicly  - 
 
 
Google News just announced that Spain’s recently passed link tax has forced the net giant to remove Spanish publishers from Google News and shut off the service in Spain come Tuesday.

Thus a link tax intended to protect Spain’s publishers will only end up harming them — depriving them of untold audience — and could even end up killing the weakest among them. Spain will also bring damage to the web itself and to the country’s reputation, establishing itself as a hostile environment for investment in technology.

Be careful what you wish for, you old, threatened institutions of media and government, huddling together against the cold wind of the new.

Spain’s link tax is inspired by a similar ancillary copyright law in Germany but goes well beyond the Teutonic statute in one key aspect: The Spanish law requires aggregators (read: Google News) to pay publishers (read: newspapers) for linking to and quoting content at any length. Publishers cannot waive the payment. Thus, come January 1, Google said it could not afford to pay for quoting and sending traffic to the publishers in a service where Google places no ads and says it makes no money.

In Germany, the game over its ancillary copyright law — the Leistungsschutzrecht in local parlance — played out as a theatre of the ridiculous. Quoting a piece I wrote about the sequence for Die Zeit:

Their battle reached a crescendo of absurdity as:
(1) a Leistungsschutzrecht was written to forbid Google et al from quoting snippets of publishers’ content;
(2) the legislation was amended to allow snippets;
(3) publishers sued Google anyway for using snippets, demanding 11 percent of Google’s related revenue;
(4) Google said it would stop using snippets from the litigious publishers;
(5) those publishers accused Google of blackmailing them for taking down the snippets the publishers were themselves using to blackmail Google;
(6) government officials laughed the publishers out of the cartel office;
(7) most of the publishers capitulated because they need traffic from Google;
(8) Springer pulled permission to publish snippets from Die Welt and three minor sites but not from its superbrand, Bild; and
(9) Springer itself capitulated after confessing it lost too much traffic from Google and arguing this demonstrated Google’s crushing market power.
The publishers have succeeded in humiliating themselves, their industry, and their nation.

In Germany, publishers led by conservative powerhouse Axel Springer used their considerable political capital to enlist politicians at all levels to play a game intended to box their boogeyman giant, Google, into a corner. They lost to fight another day. In Spain, though, something was gained in the translation and the government, goaded by its publishers, struck a tragic blow against the web itself.

Of course, the internet is suffering many more bruises in Europe. There is the fight against Google Street View in Germany and Google’s right to take pictures of public views from public streets, pushing Google to abandon updating its photographic maps there. There is the so-called right to be forgotten from a European court, which tramples over the right to remember, the right to free speech, and the right to a free press, as publications are quickly learning. As the inventor of the web, Sir Tim Berners-Lee, said in Paris this week: “The right to access history is important.” And there is the political pressure brought to bear from publishers that drove the European Union to abandon its antitrust settlement with Google.

I bring my own perspective to this story. I am an American. I am a fan of technology, of Google, of capitalism. As a matter of disclosure, please know that Google has paid my travel to events in Spain and Germany to speak on this topic (like Google, I don’t much like losing money) but never a fee. So take what I say about Google with a grain of salt the size of a cow’s saltlick, if you’d like.

But consider the damage to the web and the internet brought by these protective measures from disrupted publishers and politicians conspiring together. Consider the damage to Spain’s, Germany’s, and Europe’s hopes to build their own futures in technology, to attract entrepreneurs and investment and the risk that invention requires. Consider the damage to speech, to the ability of any of us to quote and link to anyone else.

Last month, I attended an “unconference” of journalists, publishers, educators and technologists convened in Phoenix by Google and the Knight Foundation (further disclosure: the latter is a funder of my work at the City University of New York). In an unconference, the participants set the agenda. I was one of more than a few participants who requested a session asking what Google could do for news. At that meeting, we discussed many wishes.

Myself, I wish Google would help news organizations new and old break out of old business models and find new means of sustaining themselves on the net. I wish that Google would help us explore new means of distribution, going to the public rather than making them come to us. I wish that Google would increase its investment in media startups — especially in Europe.

But more than anything, I wish that Google would speak up more often and more boldly in defense of the net itself. I wish Google would defend the net more aggressively against spying by the NSA and GCHQ. I wish Google would defend itself and the net against the protectionism and political opportunism of publishers and politicians. That is just what Google has done in refusing to capitulate to Spain’s link tax. Google is defending the freedom of the link and thus of the web itself.
44 comments on original post
1
Add a comment...

Lennart Benoot

Shared publicly  - 
 
Evening shot of our street
11
Johan Van der Schueren's profile photoKoen Bosmans's profile photoLennart Benoot's profile photofrits 1's profile photo
5 comments
frits 1
 
hé dat ken ik, nonkel van grauwel woont daar ook
 ·  Translate
Add a comment...

Lennart Benoot

Shared publicly  - 
 
Het lijkt er sterk op dat er toch een vervolg komt op de cultserie Twin Peaks. Dat moet blijken uit een aantal tweets van regisseur David Lynch en producer...
2
Add a comment...

Lennart Benoot

Shared publicly  - 
 

Finishing our +app ninjas  presentation for the  +Bel Gaug  event "Startups & the era of cloud".

See you tomorrow  @ +iMinds  !
2
Add a comment...

Lennart Benoot

Shared publicly  - 
 
Who knows this place?
1
Mattias Abrams's profile photofrits 1's profile photoLennart Benoot's profile photo
3 comments
 
Orval idd.
One free Orval for mr Abrams!
Add a comment...
Have him in circles
428 people
Joke Gijsbrechts's profile photo
Mouad Baha's profile photo
osama afram's profile photo
Howard Lewis Ship's profile photo
Mattias Abrams's profile photo
rose Kaylee's profile photo
Kim Claes's profile photo
Refat Imtiaj's profile photo
Lindi Yetu's profile photo

Lennart Benoot

Shared publicly  - 
 
Thanks +Harry Fabel​ for the tip. However no luck for me :(
1
Harry Fabel's profile photoLennart Benoot's profile photofrits 1's profile photo
5 comments
frits 1
+
1
2
1
 
cclean??? wa is er mis met een stalen sponske en ewa cif
 ·  Translate
Add a comment...

Lennart Benoot

Shared publicly  - 
 
 
More than half of large enterprises are either already using public cloud resources for their big data analytic needs or plan to do so, according to a report by Gigaom Research.
View original post
1
Add a comment...

Lennart Benoot

Shared publicly  - 
 
Mountain bike trip in zoniënwoud this morning. Should be autumn but feels like summer today!
1
Add a comment...

Lennart Benoot

Shared publicly  - 
1
Add a comment...

Lennart Benoot

Shared publicly  - 
 
De Amerikaanse gigant Google heeft een VoIP-functie toegevoegd aan zijn mobiele berichtenservice Hangouts. Daarmee kan nu, net als met Skype, gratis of goedkoop via internet gebeld worden.
1
Add a comment...

Lennart Benoot

Shared publicly  - 
 
Bij
 ·  Translate
1
Add a comment...
People
Have him in circles
428 people
Joke Gijsbrechts's profile photo
Mouad Baha's profile photo
osama afram's profile photo
Howard Lewis Ship's profile photo
Mattias Abrams's profile photo
rose Kaylee's profile photo
Kim Claes's profile photo
Refat Imtiaj's profile photo
Lindi Yetu's profile photo
Education
  • Ghent University
    Computer Science, 1995 - 1999
Basic Information
Gender
Male
Birthday
April 17
Apps with Google+ Sign-in
Story
Tagline
Natural Born Technophile
Bragging rights
Publilshed Crashed Quest in 1991
Work
Employment
  • Mincko
    Founder, 2013 - present
  • Hill Consulting
    Owner, 2009 - present
Places
Map of the places this user has livedMap of the places this user has livedMap of the places this user has lived
Currently
Halle
Previously
Breedhout - Gent
Links
Contributor to
Should not miss this one when visiting the Cevennes. You can combine the trip from Anduze to Saint Jean du Gard with a visit to the Aquarium in Saint Jean du Gard and/or on the way back visit La Bambouseraie. All is well-organized, crowdy but not over commercialized. Employees are helpfull and friendly, clearly a committed team. tip 1: if you want to enjoy the true flavor of steam and burned coal: pick the first wagons behind the locomotive. However, expect to get some black on your face! tip 2: you can take your own lunch and picknick tables are available free of charge, even without consumption.
• • •
Public - a year ago
reviewed a year ago
Aanrader: cote a los
Public - 2 years ago
reviewed 2 years ago
Food: ExcellentDecor: GoodService: Very Good
Public - 2 years ago
reviewed 2 years ago
Public - 2 years ago
reviewed 2 years ago
14 reviews
Map
Map
Map
Public - 2 years ago
reviewed 2 years ago
Public - 2 years ago
reviewed 2 years ago