Thanks for the feedback and votes! Looking forward to my next turn in the voting pool.
Tyson Jerry2:33 PM
Tyson Jerry - I'm not sure if I like the dock in here or not. The vignetting in the sky is also subtracting for me too.
Steve Bottoms2:33 PM
Very nice; love the color and composition! #save1 (the vignette is a bit strong, but still like it)
C.J. Sros2:43 PM
Way to strong vignette I think.
But still an image I like to look at.
Jeff Anderson2:48 PM
what do you mean by "vignette"? Not familiar with the word...in photography at least. I like the colors and the image as a whole. #save3
C.J. Sros2:51 PM+1
+Jeff Anderson http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vignetting
Jeff Coleman2:53 PMEdit
Thanks for the feedback! Vignetting can be dialed back in LR.
Frank Cava2:57 PM
I agree about the vignette. The line of the dock is being muting by the vignette. The dock is the image here, and should be brought out and not hidden. #delete1
Jeff Anderson2:59 PM+1
Steve Allanson3:00 PM
lovely colours and nice the way the jetty points into the centre of the pic but I just don't understand why the vignette #delete2
Jamal Williams3:55 PM
great color in the sky & I normally like silhouette but for some reason i want to see a bit more detail in the dock. the rest is fine blacked out. for now #delete3
Carrie McGann4:06 PM
#save4 Love the scene and the colorations. The light transitions in the upper portion could be smoother, less banded. I like it anyway.
russ vallelunga4:34 PM
#delete5 by my counting, love the shot, but not the heavy vignette.
Amy Redstone4:38 PM (edited)
I like the color, and the feeling of this scene. A little too much dark on the bottom for me though. I'd like to see it with a crop left and bottom, and also lose the vignette. #delete4
Max Kotchouro5:55 PM
I like composition, colors the silhouettes. Vignette doesn't hurt it. #save5
Porter Yates6:27 PM
On the fence for this one, not crazy about the vignette but I like the silhouette and shapes. #save6
Michael Vesia7:23 PM (edited)
I feel that the vignetting is too strong. It actually takes away from the effect of the silhouette and makes the orange color seem too dense on the edges. #delete5
Benny Sjöstrand7:27 PM
Maybe a little bit too dark. I'm not sure if the vignette is a good idea. But overall, I like the idea, the composition, its a #save7 :)
Melissa Richardson8:18 PM
#save8 Nice shot. I like the vignette as well as the silhouettes. I also like the echo of the shapes of the trees in the clouds above. Nice arrangement of foreground elements too.
Bridget M8:26 PM
Love the colours and I'm a sucker for silhouettes #save9
Delfin Abzueta9:27 PM
I love the golden tones here. #save10
Barry Blanchard10:44 PM
+Jeff Coleman congrats.. your capture has reached save10, and can now be added to The Lightbox: http://goo.gl/rRE2O
We'll be removing it from the voting pool soon.
Jeff Coleman11:14 PMEdit+1
Thanks to all for the feedback. I'll be hiding the vignetting LR preset from myself from now on!
Barry Blanchard11:15 PM
+Jeff Coleman feel free to move this over to The Lightbox now.. and you can even copy the comments made to add with your picture.
After that, do delete it from here.
Me? I liked the vignetting myself. ;)
- The University of AlabamaAccounting, 2000 - 2004
- The University of Alabama - Office for AdvancementIT Specialist, 2014 - present
- The University of Alabama - Office for Sponsored ProgramsCoordinator IT Services, 2012 - 2014
- Boone Newspapers, Inc.IT Specialist, 2005 - 2011
Exclusive: Microsoft's next Xbox will take over your TV, interact with y...
Microsoft is investing in TV in a big way with its next Xbox console as part of a fight for the living room. Multiple sources familiar with
[BusyMac] Problems publishing and subscribing to Google Calendar - Googl...
[BusyMac] Problems publishing and subscribing to Google Calendar, (unknown), 6/28/12 7:01 AM, Hi Charles, Yes it does. Here is the only hack
Here’s How Planetary Resources Plans to Mine Asteroids (Release)
Planetary Resources is building its own spacecraft to mine asteroids for raw materials, including platinum and water.
Google reactivates Speak2Tweet for Syrian Internet cutoff
A service to broadcast voice messages over Twitter is back up and running as Google tries to sidestep Syria's Net blackout -- but it might n
Watch the Picturephone's 1970s debut on the AT&T archives
AT&T has released a video of the Picturephone's commercial debut along with a bit of history on a device that was expected to change the fut
A look inside Leap Motion, the 3D gesture control that's like Kinect on ...
Leap Motion's not the household name Kinect is, but it should be — the company's motion-tracking system is more powerful, more accurate, sma
Widespread Amazon and Internet Taxes Coming Soon - Forbes
Image via CrunchBase Amazon taxes are not new taxes. They merely address who is responsible for collecting tax that's always been due on tan
How Publishers Will Beat Amazon - Technology Review
Companies that have existed for centuries could be gone in a generation unless they make a single radical change.
The Floppy Disk means Save, and 14 other old people Icons that don't mak...
Scott Hanselman on Programming, User Experience, The Zen of Computers and Life in General
iOS 6: Apple drops Google Maps, debuts in-house ‘Maps’ with incredible 3...
Rough mockup showing the user-enabled 3D mode (on the right). According to trusted sources, Apple has an incredible headline feature in deve
Microsoft to bring full Internet Explorer browsing to Xbox 360 with Kine...
Microsoft is currently testing a modified version of Internet Explorer 9 on its Xbox 360 console, according to our sources. The Xbox 360 cur