The galaxy S5 is NOT waterproof. It is 'water resistant' (http://aceeca.com/handhelds/ip67
). Other than that detail, I think the review was fairly good. My experience with the S5 has been great. I probably would have been just fine with my S4, but I do like having a slightly better camera, which takes some great pictures. I'm not a fan of Touchwiz, but I like to use Nova Launcher anyway.