Profile

Cover photo
Dimitri Rastoropov
Works at Dimitri Rastoropov
Attended Lancaster University
Lives in Caernarfon, UK
1,210 followers|80,801 views
AboutPostsPhotosVideos+1's

Stream

Dimitri Rastoropov

commented on a video on YouTube.
Shared publicly  - 
 
Wow. He should fire his campaign managers.
1
Add a comment...

Dimitri Rastoropov

commented on a video on YouTube.
Shared publicly  - 
 
You are looking from a perspective of a person who doesn't run a business and doesn't own property. What if you run a business and you own property? How does your comparison work then?
Either way, whatever you say about this, in a free society you free to do whatever you want – want to start a cooperative? Please do. Want to live in a housing cooperative. You're welcome to do that. But how can you tell me that this is better for me? I'm pretty sure I should be able to own property or rent property if I want. If I want to be an employee or a freelancer, and take no part in ownership/management etc., I also should be able to do that, and I'm afraid that not you or anyone else may have a say in that. That's if you want a free society, not some sort of warped, quasi-free communes.
1
Nox Aternum's profile photogregkahuna1's profile photoZack tech:Folder's profile photo
Add a comment...

Dimitri Rastoropov

commented on a video on YouTube.
Shared publicly  - 
 
Юм шотландец!
 ·  Translate
1
Add a comment...

Dimitri Rastoropov

Shared publicly  - 
 
The campaign is live!
A nomadic contamporary arts festival. We're in Caernarfon in 2014; in 2015 we may be in your town.
1
Add a comment...

Dimitri Rastoropov

Shared publicly  - 
 
 
Mies van der Rohe - Farnsworth House 3D
 ·  Translate
1
Add a comment...
Have him in circles
1,210 people
John Hynes's profile photo
Asenateqk Sousa's profile photo
Stephen Boyd's profile photo
Dan Tharp's profile photo
Agus Try's profile photo
Houston Texas's profile photo
‫محمد الشناوى‬‎'s profile photo
James Smith's profile photo
gascuenha fidel's profile photo

Dimitri Rastoropov

commented on a video on YouTube.
Shared publicly  - 
 
I'm sorry, but you are wrong. Anarchy means 'without a leader', not 'without hierarchy' and it was first used in the modern sense by Kropotkin in reference to the State and only to the state. IMHO neither ancap or ancom are oxymorons, the focus is on the an-, not on the second part. If you want to live in a commune and do things your way, you're welcome do it as long as you don't inflict violence on anyone. Which is often the case with communists, as they usually come from a point of some sort of moral superiority.
1
Seditious Citizen X's profile photoDimitri Rastoropov's profile photo
18 comments
 
I am saying that there is nothing to argue about, the different meanings of leader and hierarchy are facts, their relationship doesn't imply substitution, and anarchy is etymologically derived from 'arkhos' – 'leader', not 'ierarchy'.

If something existed in the past, it doesn't mean that it can or will exist in the future. Statements based on anecdotes aren't arguments. History and its interpretations are too subjective for any reasonable theory.

All you are saying is that at a certain point in history business owners benefited from government protection. No shit Sherlock—if you haven't noticed—that exactly what's happening and what has been happening all the time, because people will always use the power of the state to protect their wealth if they have the opportunity to do so.

So how exactly would you make this 'taking back the means of production' happen?

Who exactly defines who is oppressed? Who decides when and how to expropriate? How and when does one decide he can 'expropriate' property? Or 'fight back'? Fight back to what precisely? I understand fighting against taxation, when they come for your money, but how do you establish who and when can one 'fight back' against things that happened centuries ago? And fight against whom? Precisely?

Well what if they don't want to work in your cooperative society, they just want to somehow benefit from whatever system that allows them not to work? Just like under state capitalism, in your ancom fairyland there will be people who will be exempt from this rule, because they will be able to live of (steal) someone else's labour.
Add a comment...

Dimitri Rastoropov

commented on a video on YouTube.
Shared publicly  - 
 
The only way to pay for her rent? You can't just make up an abstract situation and then jump to conclusions based on that. Why is that the 'only' choice for her? Millions of people work and pay their rent and they're not prostituting themselves. Prostitution is a very simple and short term solution and the fact that someone is a prostitute does not mean they were forced to take this choice, it only means they have made this choice based on what they know and what they are willing to do. If there are two people in the same situation—sisters for example—one may choose to work as a prostitute, the other one gets a low paying job but eventually builds up some experience that makes hiring her more lucrative to employers. Is the one that chose prostitution forced in that situation? In order to make sense out of this, you really have to make the case to redefine 'force', otherwise these are just statements.
2
RileyKaiSeeker's profile photoYoko Kanno's profile photo
26 comments
 
+RileyKaiSeeker


"Right now, the top 400 richest americans have more money combined than the bottom 150 million americans. However, were you to take it away from the top and give it to the bottom equally, they might get an extra 1000 dollars each. Extend that to all rich and all poor, they might get an extra 3-5 thousand dollars each. But then there's all the starving people around the world, and were it extended to them to, we'd all end up with maybe 10 - 20,000 per year. The earth simply doesn't have the capacity to sustain 7 billion people in style and comfort."

This is completely besides the point. Anarcho-communists aren't arguing for a redistribution of money. We are arguing for the abolition of money. Have workers take control of the factories and give everyone access to the means of production.

The problem here isn't in the earth's natural resources, it's in the system we use to distribute those resources and the restrictive nature of capitalism when it comes to allowing people to access those resources.

We throw away roughly 30% of all produced food every day, we have the resources to feed alot more people we simply aren't using them efficiently. That's the problem. It's never about the amount of resources, it's about how you set up a system which allows for those resources to be accessed by more people.

"Think of a knife. You can use it to kill someone but that doesn't make knives bad. You could use it to perform an emergency appendectomy and save someone's life, but that doesn't make knives good.
It's the same with capitalism. Someone can use capitalism to screw over the little people and advance their own greed, but that doesn't make capitalism 'immoral', any more than someone using capitalism to make billions and donating it all to charity makes capitalism 'moral'. Capitalism is amoral. It is not an ideology. It doesn't have anything to say on the way society 'ought' to be run. It merely describes free trade. Some people may use it for good, some may use it for bad. It is an extension of the best and worst of human nature. Pointing out it's flaws is merely pointing out the flaws in humanity, and they don't magically disappear when you eradicate capitalism. The problem with marxism is that it is ideologically motivated. It makes moral pronouncements on the way the world and people 'ought' to be. The only way it can work is by forcing people to adhere to it, which means taking away the freedoms of people who have done nothing wrong."

Complete rubbish and totally a-historical. You have such limited understanding of the matter it's honestly frustrating to even talk to you.

Capitalism was imposed on people by the state and the rich, read up on the enclosure movement. This argument that Capitalism is just "natural" "apolitical" or has no intrinsic "ideology" is so far from the truth.

This is generally the problem with people like you, you have bought into neoclassical/neoliberal economic dogma and you will happily reconstruct history to somehow fit your narrative. Capitalism isn't natural, it's a state-imposed system that mainly favours the rich.

I hear this argument that Capitalism is somehow natural and Communism has to be imposed on people all the time, but historicaly the exact opposite is true. Capitalism was state-imposed, whereas commonly owned and shared land was pretty much the global norm in most societies throughout history.

I don't attribute this to malice on your part, I honestly think it's ignorance, read up on the violent history of Capitalism and how it was state-imposed, how commoners were expropriated by the state and their land was then given to the rich ruling class.

This is why Capitalism exists, it's not natural, in fact if anything commonly owned land was the natural order of things after feudalism and capitalism was then violently imposed on people.

""Can you guarantee that we will find a treatment or cure?"
"No, but it's possible."
"Is there a good chance you will find a treatment?"
"We have no idea till we try."

...however, person 'B' argues....

"We should use the resources to help the lives of people here and now."
"Can you guarantee that it will improve the lives of people here and now?"
*"Yes, absolutely. 100% guaranteed""

What an absolute shit thought experiment is that? If there is a potential cure for something communists would have as much reason to research that cure as capitalists would have. In fact if the cure wasn't financially lucrative communists would have even more reason to search for that cure than capitalists.

Take the example of magnetic trains, we have the technology, but no capitalist would ever invest in it because it's extremely expensive with almost no potential short-term profit. It might be profitable over 50 to 60 years, but why should the capitalist care given that he will probably be dead by then?

In a communist society we would collectively pool resources together to build those magnetic trains, because in our society we wouldn't value short term profit, in fact in an anarcho-communist society it wouldn't ever be about profit, but using resources to the benefit of all.

In many ways Capitalism actually slows down our progress, anything that shows no potential for short term profit necessarily needs to either be researched by the public sector or it won't be researched at all.

In a Capitalist system you have no reason to care about what happens in 40,50 or 60 years, because it's all about short term profit.

From a logical perspective Capitalists have no incentive to invest in things that may not be lucrative for another 40+ years, but they have incentive to invest in things that could turn a profit within the next 5-10 years.

In communism it wouldn't make any difference, as short term profit (I'm talking 5-10 years) wouldn't be the primary motivating factor of the economy.

"Elite private schools, hospitals and institutions which can afford state of the art equipment and the best teachers would be abolished, thus fewer people with elite educations to drive humanity forward. Landing on the moon and the space program would take a back seat to the physical and emotional well being of people living today, so we'd have no satellite network. Marxism is all about the well being of all peoples here and now, not what 'might' be possible."

BULLSHIT. Why would we abandon schools, hospitals and institutions with state of the art equipment? Our implicit goal would be to provide all schools, hospital and institutions with the same state of the art equipment.

And you are actually a moron, NASA and the space program are for the most part publicly funded programs, Capitalism has next to interest in space exploration because from a market perspective there is NO incentive to explore space as this could never be lucrative in the short term.

It's so incredibly stupid, you list examples of public funding and the public sector pooling together resources (in this case via the state) as examples of how great capitalism is, even though the capitalist market has next to interest in space exploration.

You gotta be fucking kidding.
Add a comment...

Dimitri Rastoropov

commented on a video on YouTube.
Shared publicly  - 
 
This video is funny because to me, it looks like they deliberately called an idiot to talk in order to make this video and feminism look better by contrast.
44
Daniel Bermel's profile photoblacktee31's profile photoCory Karp's profile photo
59 comments
 
+Daniel Bermel
Lets not forget, many former second wave feminists have seen the light when it comes to modern feminism too, former feminists like Dr. Warren Farrell, and Erin Pizzey, they are not anti-feminist, because of the cancer on society that modern third wave feminism has become.

Not all women are feminists, in fact, many think for themselves in a rational manner, and are anti-feminist.
Add a comment...

Dimitri Rastoropov

Shared publicly  - 
 
I contributed to the campaign – it's a great project!
Bocs's Incubation Space will host young start-up designers led by an in-house mentor.
1
Add a comment...

Dimitri Rastoropov

commented on a video on YouTube.
Shared publicly  - 
 
Isn't capitalism somehow related to capital? Markets and trade are non-violent because they assume work and production. Capitalism is the accumulation of capital through interest and rent.
3
Dimitri Rastoropov's profile photomarcocampa94's profile photoR Roosnaja's profile photoesmifrado's profile photo
6 comments
 
+R Roosnaja That should be common knowledge (not to mention loans) but this guys have some serious issues....
Add a comment...

Dimitri Rastoropov

commented on a video on YouTube.
Shared publicly  - 
 
People seem to like to use historical excursions to justify territorial claims, so here's some food for thought: Kiev was there before Russia even existed and was the central city of Rus' before it spread eastward. Then Moscow came into power and its rulers helped ravage Kiev so that it loses its power, which is what happened.
1
Eduard Rastoropov's profile photo
2 comments
 
Twenty years ago you was 6, now you are 26. Are there one person or two?
Add a comment...
People
Have him in circles
1,210 people
John Hynes's profile photo
Asenateqk Sousa's profile photo
Stephen Boyd's profile photo
Dan Tharp's profile photo
Agus Try's profile photo
Houston Texas's profile photo
‫محمد الشناوى‬‎'s profile photo
James Smith's profile photo
gascuenha fidel's profile photo
Work
Occupation
Composer, sound artist, curator
Skills
Music Composition, Songwriting, Orchestrating, Arranging, Mixing, Sound Design,
Employment
  • Dimitri Rastoropov
    Guitar and Piano Teacher, 2006 - present
  • Dimitri Rastoropov
    Arts Centre Coordinator at Bocs, 2013 - present
  • Dimitri Rastoropov
    Composer, present
Places
Map of the places this user has livedMap of the places this user has livedMap of the places this user has lived
Currently
Caernarfon, UK
Previously
Lancaster, UK - St. Petersburg, Russia - Jurmala, Latvia - Rotterdam, Holland
Story
Tagline
Music and sounds.
Introduction
I'm a composer. 
Education
  • Lancaster University
    Contemporary Arts Practice - Music, 2012 - 2013
  • St. Petersburg State Conservatory
    Composition, 2008 - 2012
  • International School of Latvia
  • American International School of Rotterdam
Basic Information
Gender
Male
Other names
Dimitriy, Dimitry, Dima, Dimitrij, Dimitrijs, Dmitri
Dimitri Rastoropov's +1's are the things they like, agree with, or want to recommend.
My, your, our Riga 100 years ago - Google Cultural Institute
www.google.com

The Google Cultural Institute brings together millions of artefacts from multiple partners, with the stories that bring them to life, in a v

LD System - Driving Lesson 12 Dual carriageways
www.learnerdriving.com

The aim of this driving lesson is to learn how to safely deal with fast moving traffic and all the different types of junction found on dual

Textra SMS - Android Apps on Google Play
play.google.com

Let's face it, the stock Android Messaging app really sucks! So time to try something new, but it has to be pretty special, right? It's here

Persimmon plc
www.persimmonhomes.com

Persimmon Heights is a stunning new development in the heart of Worcester. With its range of 2, 3 & 4 bedroom homes there’s a fantastic choi

Art won’t look after itself
www.artsprofessional.co.uk

As the Lords debate shines a spotlight on the Government’s support of artists, Susan Jones reviews the current situation.

Liftshare
market.android.com

Sick of high petrol prices? Need a ride? Join over 400,000 Liftshare members enjoying cheap travel by sharing car journeys. Find a lift or o

Social Media Management Dashboard - Hootsuite
hootsuite.com

Enhance your social media management with Hootsuite, the leading social media dashboard. Manage multiple networks and profiles and measure y

Axisweb
www.axisweb.org

The curated showcase for UK contemporary art. We help you make connections, find work and stay informed.

Dimitri Rastoropov | Artist and Creative Industries Professional
www.rastoropov.co.uk

Dimitri Rastoropov is a sound artist, composer, guitar teacher, piano teacher, and creative industries professional

Seven Traces Contemporary Arts Festival
www.indiegogo.com

A nomadic contamporary arts festival. We're in Caernarfon in 2014; in 2015 we may be in your town.

Free DjVu to PDF online converter
www.djvu-pdf.com

Converts PDF to DjVu and DjVu to PDF online. Ideal for making your DjVu documents readable by e-book readers. Small and searchable PDF files

Freelance Advisor
plus.google.com

Advice, news and resources for UK freelancers and contractors

Liberty.me: Liberty Lives Here
liberty.me

Friendship, publishing, learning, networking for liberty-minded people the world over.

Кровь, бурьян и 20 триллионов. О чем Путин и депутаты говорили в Ялте
www.snob.ru

Президент России выступил в Ялте перед депутатами Госдумы и пообещал выделить 20 000 000 000 000 рублей на развитие вооружений. В ответном с

Bitcoin and Litecoin Donation Button
coinwidget.com

Coin Widget is an open source Bitcoin/Litecoin donation button for your websites.

Screen Light
market.android.com

Screen Light is simple free flashlight application for your android device.[+] Maximum brightness [+] Lowest possible system requirements [+

It’s not just David Byrne and Radiohead: Spotify, Pandora and how stream...
www.salon.com

More musicians are taking aim at the rates paid by Spotify and Pandora, and warning whole genres are in danger

Gentrification: what happens to those left behind? | Society Professiona...
www.theguardian.com

When the pub becomes a wine bar and the corner shop a coffee house, residents can feel isolated in their own communities • Beveridge revisit

Christmas starts early
www.artsprofessional.co.uk

The height of summer is the best time for venues offering a Christmas show to start gearing up for success. Hannah Mitchell explains why.