Profile cover photo
Profile photo
Denis Wallez
372,853 followers -
«Intentions do matter.»
«Intentions do matter.»

372,853 followers
About
Denis Wallez's posts

Post has attachment
Worldly winds

People hide. They're trapped by the "eight worldly winds" (gplus.wallez.name/B5DDP1UscX6 and gplus.wallez.name/UUUbKEuFCiC).
To hide, they lie… including tho themselves (gplus.wallez.name/NPY9So13jED).

To tell the truth is not easy, for words have destructive power, and telling the truth doesn't imply being insensitive: the Buddha mentioned 5 factors for a statement to be faultless, "spoken at the right time, spoken in truth, spoken affectionately, spoken beneficially, spoken with a mind of good-will." Truthfulness is a valid concern, but it's not the only one!

But, ultimately, telling the truth takes courage… more courage than most people are willing to invest maybe: invest for the sake of what exactly?
• Of empowering others —even though this also requires us to accept their freedom to act in a way we might prefer they wouldn't. Buddhism has a version of the Golden Rule: Hurt not others in ways that you yourself would find hurtful (Udānavarga 5.18). Empowering others is a moral duty if you feel hurt when your potential is limited by the context. Empowering others is a form of danā, of generosity (as explained against complicit silence in www.koan.mu/what-did-I-do.htm).
• Of engaging constructively and creatively with "reality as it is" —we can only work on what we're aware of, so "accepting reality as it is" is a prerequisite to reform (it's not passive submission to the unacceptable: it's seeing the unacceptable as such, and seeing the available opportunities to engage with it).

One of the difficulties though is that "the truth" is too often seen as static, but it changes from moment-to-moment: our thoughts are not monolithic, and conflicting (subconscious) thoughts do not all come to the surface at the same time… It's possible to be kind, then angry, then calmer… Which is the truth? All, and none. It's impermanent, it's changing. A good question is: is it changing in a wholesome direction? What can I do about it? Well, apparently, this article suggests that spreading information and supporting curiosity (our own and others') remain key.

#Buddhism #Dharma

Post has attachment
24'08''

Post has attachment

Post has attachment
January – … — June 2017

The beginning of 2017 has proven pretty challenging, for a variety of reasons, so much of my activity online has been around curation —rather than personal posts— as well as moderating and answering numerous questions in the "Buddhism Q&A" and "Buddhism and Meditation" communities.

Yet, 13 original contributions still appeared on top of the many carefully selected shares, links, etc.:
Put more chances to succeed on your side!
gplus.wallez.name/3qNGFQugobr
Croire ou ne pas croire…
http://secret.dharma.house/newsletters/201701fr.htm
(or To believe or not to believe…
http://secret.dharma.house/newsletters/201702en.htm)
Tout le problème, en un mot ? "Rituel"
gplus.wallez.name/2up9kTrvFw4
• Above the Xiashui village
gplus.wallez.name/WckeVT1twhg
Spring, like the rest of the year, is harvest time!
gplus.wallez.name/gEdRcxPkn94
An abundance of "expedient means"
gplus.wallez.name/E6GfTGDjuHh
Should we always use the 12 nidānas backward?
gplus.wallez.name/fW8cobyBVSV
Watch your "ordinary" mind, now, in your "ordinary" life, with all its unnecessary drama, not just when you're "practising"!
gplus.wallez.name/TZwG3HppriY
Seeing, and accepting, things as they are
gplus.wallez.name/3JBpbX6dpP3
Légalité (variable) n'est pas moralité
gplus.wallez.name/HtNefWXTi6h
Ère de l'information : derniers jours du Dharma ?
http://secret.dharma.house/newsletters/201707fr.htm
Striving for moral consistency?
gplus.wallez.name/RqADkJCEGVN
In large public settings, it is responsible to have first aiders…
gplus.wallez.name/hMZ1CFv2EhP
(individual guidance is available: http://en.dharma.house/samsara.htm)

Contributions to the "Buddhism Q&A" and "Buddhism and Meditation" communities are not listed. As always, alms are very welcome, via koan.mu/donate.htm (or http://en.dharma.house/donate.htm).


#Buddhism #TableOfContents
Photo

Post has attachment
October — November — December 2016

14 original contributions, on top of reshares, links, etc.:
On using science to support/weaken Buddhist doctrines
gplus.wallez.name/Dpu1tSpTpgM
Maddening expression of the day: kālena kālaṃ
gplus.wallez.name/VbT3rzohj4N
The Buddha, on fear
gplus.wallez.name/4LdLEZFQ4iR
a striking call for change
gplus.wallez.name/J4QwCZJGNpd
Love and detachment
http://secret.dharma.house/newsletters/201611en.htm
(ou Amour et détachement
http://secret.dharma.house/newsletters/201611fr.htm)
The #AskMeAnything silly "Thank you" celebration!
plus.google.com/+DenisWallez/posts/iiAjuSGTcGD
Getting back into practice, after a lapse, is the priority
gplus.wallez.name/9CbYPu39Y7m
Automatic translations
gplus.wallez.name/jMGPr1uFHd4
What did I do, to deserve this?
www.koan.mu/what-did-I-do.htm
Confusion
gplus.wallez.name/f9DKuRwYUJH
Dualism
gplus.wallez.name/d9Xqcms8vqc
Continuité karmique: pollution
gplus.wallez.name/Lu6wA5gQH7w
Samaññaphala sutta (DN 2)… or why some monks definitely motivate me to keep +Dharma.house both non-sectarian and lay!
gplus.wallez.name/WGsrjwBcg7w
Dāna?
gplus.wallez.name/3ChrpBhQbGN
Floating on a lotus
http://secret.dharma.house/newsletters/201612en.htm

As usual, answers in the "Buddhism Q&A" community are not listed above (plus.google.com/communities/115670914730176750973)

#Buddhism #TableOfContents
Photo

Post has shared content
In large public settings, it is responsible to have first aiders, AED defibrillators, etc. You don't know "who" might have an emergency, but you know it's likely "someone" will.

Any teaching taken out of context, repeated in loop by ignorant parrots, can be dangerous… The Buddha's words have been used e.g. to attack an ethnic and religious minority in Myanmar, or e.g. to minimise the guilt of Japanese soldiers during WWII (« there's no self, there's no being truly being killed »)… The words of an experienced and sensitive teacher can become an insensitive, insensible hammer when quoted and yielded by less qualified, less awakened repeaters.

Retreats in the Goenka traditions are based on the traditional teachings of the spiritual leader Goenka, who died in 2013. His daily lessons have been videotaped and are played nightly for meditators at retreats. So there is no "main teacher" on site. Volunteer "assistant teachers" are supposed to guide meditators, but their qualifications are unclear (read: usually none, the only requirement is that they have attended at least one previous meditation course). There is generally one "lead" assistant teacher who is supposed to be trained… if you're lucky… but that doesn't even mean (s)he will speak your language well enough to understand, let alone discuss, a subtle change of mindset (which might later snowball into devastating madness).

By now, I've heard of enough cases of psychosis (including one of my friends), heard of enough bad advice given, heard of enough ludicrous assertions (the Buddha only taught the (mahā)satipatṭhāna sutta, really?), and met enough people who needed serious post-retreat psychological help, in order not to recommend the vipassana retreat in the Goenka tradition. And yes, I know of some people who got a lot from these retreats, and who will sound like enthusiastic supporters, good for them, but « it went well for me, therefore it should go well for you too » is very flawed and self-centred logic!

And this is not because I doubt of Goenka's attainments, but because of the way the teachings are now spread, without a qualified and experienced meditator to help people go through the difficulties that may arise. This is irresponsible, in my view: it's too easy to wash one's hands and say it's the problem of the meditator going crazy. Blaming the victim and denial of personal responsibility go against "right effort".

In large public settings, it is responsible to have first aiders, AED defibrillators, etc. You don't know "who" might have an emergency, but you know it's likely "someone" will.
In the same way, if you run meditation retreats, you ought to be trained enough in psychology (ideally both Western and Eastern versions) and in meditation techniques to cope with the inevitable troubles that "someone" will experience. You also ought to run retreats in languages you're truly fluent in.
No teacher is perfect, no one makes no mistake, but "right effort" certainly calls for refraining from complacency or negligence… Running retreats without sufficient proficiency in the side-effects of what you prescribe is negligence.

Passing information (by playing tapes) is not the same as understanding, which itself is not the same as manifesting wise appropriateness…
One has to remember that the student's circumstances dictate what's appropriate, the teacher's preferences don't (one of the founding principles at +Dharma.house)!

If you don't experiment with powerful medication (without the supervision of some doctor, who knows more than his own health history), then don't experiment with powerful mental techniques (without supervision of some qualified practitioner, who knows more than just his own spiritual history)!

#Buddhism #meditation
ANOTHER MEDITATION RELATED SUICIDE
As we have discussed before meditation [sometimes] has a darkside, and while such tragic outcomes are rare, there is a growing body of research that highlights the dark side of intense meditation.

Vogt wasn't the first to die by suicide after a meditation retreat, according to experts who are aware of other cases. And she wasn't the first to go into psychosis or experience serious mental issues after taking a a course of intense meditation.

http://www.pennlive.com/news/2017/06/york_county_suicide_megan_vogt.html

Post has attachment
Zen and martial arts… or how to go beyond fear?
August 26th–27th, 2017

Post has attachment
Striving for moral consistency?

« What people should strive for (…) is moral consistency » is a challenging perspective, because blanket, context-insensitive, one-size-fits-all answers are doomed to fall for abusive generalisations!

Consistency sounds great… until you start looking at reality! Reality is contingent, ineffable, perpetually changing.
Intuitively, doing the 'right' thing does not imply doing the same as before, "for the sake of consistency".
And you can never list all the nuances and sub-cases relevant to make a 'rule' appropriate to every single situation that may arise… A 'good' rule might cover 99% of cases, or even 99.9%, but there will always be exceptions, and so striving for 'consistency' has to be mitigated with striving for 'appropriateness'.

If impermanence is a key trait of reality, then consistency is a poor compass to navigate it. Imagine you're on a ship. You might think that to go 100km north from where you are, sailing consistently 100km north is a good strategy… but it is not!
Because you'll drift along the way, due to imprecisions and imperfections as well as sea currents, and if you never compensate for that drift, consistency will not get you to your destination.
It's not a like a compass pointing north is useless, quite the contrary, but consistency isn't a solution to the actual problem at hand (i.e. "getting to your destination", not "pointing north"!). Similarly, compassion is useful, but isn't a magic solution either (in particular if equanimity is left behind).

A comment in Lion's Roar on the article attached mentioned the Buddha stating « It is impossible for a monk whose mental fermentations are ended to intentionally deprive a living being of life. » — Sutava sutta (AN 9.7) in relation to the "trolley problem", but I'd argue this is irrelevant.
An arahant has no personal 'agenda', no personal 'intention', but (s)he still perceives appropriateness: (s)he sees when non-acting —'letting' 5 people die— is a form of acting. And it's not that complicated: non-acting is acting when there's something you could do to make the situation more wholesome (also known as "right effort") but you refrain from doing it. Non-acting is acting when you're actively going against the stream of (or refraining from) what would be wholesome. In fact, an arahant has left the raft of the Dharma behind, after crossing to the other shore, so it wouldn't even come to his/her mind to cling to a generic quote from a sutta, out of context, in order to self-servingly justify inaction.

#Buddhism #Dharma

Post has attachment
Ère de l'information : derniers jours du Dharma ?

Titre légèrement dramatique, puisqu'on m'a demandé d'écrire dans un style plus "journalistique"… Vous savez : pas trop difficile à lire, éviter les références sérieuses, éviter le besoin de réfléchir par soi-même, titres aguicheurs, etc.

Bref! Cet article est dans la partie « Ère de l'information » du numéro 23 (juillet–août 2017) du premier magazine francophone inspiré du bouddhisme et de sa philosophie de vie, www.regardbouddhiste.com

La prochaine retraite en français à +Dharma.house est « Zen et arts martiaux… ou comment dépasser ses peurs ? » (23–24 septembre), http://fr.dharma.house/retreats/retreat16.htm

Inscrivez-vous pour recevoir notre newsletter à http://secret.dharma.house/newsletters/

Post has attachment
Ère de l'information : derniers jours du Dharma ?

Slightly dramatic title, as I was asked to write in a more "journalistic" style… You know: not too difficult to read, avoid serious references, avoid any requirement to think by oneself, attention-grabbing headlines, click baits, etc.

Anyway! This piece is in the « Ère de l'information » section of the #23 (july–august 2017) issue of the first francophone magazine inspired by Buddhism and its philosophy of life, www.regardbouddhiste.com

The next retreat in French at +Dharma.house is « Zen et arts martiaux… ou comment dépasser ses peurs ? » (23–24 septembre), http://fr.dharma.house/retreats/retreat16.htm

Subscribe to our newsletter at http://secret.dharma.house/newsletters/
Wait while more posts are being loaded